During most economic downturns, the government sector “is a source of stability,” observes Bob Peck, Gensler’s Principal and Global Practice Area Leader–Government and Defense. Dave Barr, a Vice President with Burns & McDonnell’s Federal Group, agrees, noting that government, like manufacturers and utilities, “must continue to design, build, operate, and maintain systems and facilities to keep the country safe and functioning.”
But not since the Great Depression have such propositions been tested as they have been during the coronavirus pandemic. With tax revenue evaporating as a result of COVID-19-related business shutdowns, state budget shortfalls from this fallout could total a cumulative $555 billion over the states’ fiscal years 2020-2022, according to estimates from the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities.
Consequently, laments Peck, “it is hard to pin down long-term effects” on government construction spending.
AEC firms report that most of their federally funded projects have continued apace during the pandemic. These include the Army Corps of Engineers East Campus Building 2, a seven-story, 826,114-sf building in Fort Meade, Md., which when completed this fall will support more than 3,100 cybersecurity personnel. HOK and Clark Construction are key members of this $700 million project’s design-build team.
The Gensler-designed Vermont Corridor is a 21-story mixed-use building that will be the headquarters for the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health and Workforce Development, Aging and Community Services. Rendering: Gensler
Projects funded by states or cities, however, are different stories, as those governments struggle with budget-balancing mandates. With less tax revenue being collected, “state- and locally-funded building projects are likely to be delayed, deferred, or cancelled,” say Edward C. Newman, PE, CCM, LEED AP, a Senior Vice President of Business Development for Hill International, and Michael J. Mologne, PE, CCM, a Vice President with the firm.
Conversely, they say the federal building market in the Mid-Atlantic states—one of Hill’s primary areas of activity—“looks strong” for the next 12 to 15 months. “Many federal buildings are in need of complete modernization, and several large projects are set to move forward in 2021 and 2022.”
Government buildings in an pandemic era
Stephen Lesser, Associate Principal at Arup’s Washington, D.C., office, notes that many government buildings—including courthouses, city halls, and embassies—are geared toward the public and visitors. “A number of these building types have security focused on protection from physical threats, but not necessarily the biological threat posed by COVID-19 within public-facing spaces.” Eric McConahey, a Principal in Arup’s Los Angeles office, suggests that the government might narrow the projects that get “early funding” to security, indoor air quality, and social distancing.
McConahey adds that on a state level, “we are seeing energy efficiency improvements to support carbon neutrality.” One example is the new Lowell Judicial Center in Massachusetts, a $180 million, 265,000-sf building that is one of three pilot projects Gov. Deval Patrick chose to assess the potential of being a zero net energy building.
Thomas McCarthy, AIA, Senior Principal at Page, says his firm’s outlook through 2021 is based on timing: “If procurement activity is not severely limited by site access, and a CR [Continuing Resolution] does not limit funding work into summer 2021, then we expect that the next 12-15 months will be robust. But those are two big ‘ifs.’”
Lowell Judicial Center is the largest of three pilot projects that Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick chose to assess the potential of becoming a zero net energy building. Photo: Finegold Alexander Architects
Page is collaborating with Flad Architects and WSP on a 160,000-sf High Containment Continuity Laboratory that will be part of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s 2025 masterplan for its Roybal Campus in Atlanta. Construction is scheduled to begin early next year, with McCarthy Building Companies as the CM.
Skidmore, Owings & Merrill is not anticipating a huge slowdown in its government funded work. Its Director, Joseph Ruocco, AIA, says that projects from the Department of Defense have been “especially strong,” as have federally funded projects with the General Services Administration and the Department of State Overseas Building Operations. Even state-funded public buildings on both coasts are advancing through their design processes, says Ruocco.
SOM recently coordinated a petition statement to the World Health Organization promoting a collaboration with the design industry to develop guidelines that would prevent the spread of viruses. Its solutions, says Ruocco, include enhanced natural air ventilation and high-performance air filters, appropriate humidity control, and access to sunlight and UV light. “There is an immediate need to elevate our interior environments to higher standards,” he says.
Virtual solutions will reshape government buildings
On many projects, including those in the civic and government sectors, SOM has been evaluating what programs can be moved outdoors. These areas potentially include security processing in lobbies, public counters for business transactions at courthouses and consulates, jury assembly spaces, and collaboration spaces.
Ruocco also points out that during the pandemic, state and county courthouses have continued to operate through virtual proceedings. And for six days last May, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments via teleconferences for the first time in its history.
AEC firms agree that the pandemic has elevated the importance of technology to the design, engineering, and construction of government buildings. “We continue to incorporate and support the use of state-of-the-art systems, whether they support virtual jury selection, enhanced security, or training programs of government personnel,” says Bill Stinger, ASLA, LEED GA, Marketing Principal in HOK’s Washington, D.C., studio.
Technology is also becoming more present at the jobsite, especially now when the number of people working at once is being limited. Newman and Mologne at Hill International are seeing more interest among their government clients in virtual inspections. And Burns & McDonnell has successfully conducted design charrettes and review meetings virtually.
“Technology advances in how we communicate and collaborate have certainly minimized the impact to our design services,” says Barr. But he’s quick to add that the long-term impact of the coronavirus is still uncertain, especially the extent that social distancing will be enforced.
Gensler’s Peck observes that the government sector has been slower than others to embrace open and flexible workplaces. Indeed, federal, state, and local governments have been reducing their office footprints per employee. But Peck thinks those footprint-reduction mandates might be relaxed or even reversed to allow more space between workers. (He concedes that such a reversal might be countered by governments allowing more employees to work at home.)
Other trends for government buildings that AEC firms cite include a greater emphasis on health and wellness via better indoor air quality and touchless access. HVAC upgrades seem to be at the top of everyone’s to-do lists, too. And security will continue to be a priority for any government project.
ALSO SEE: New VA care center showcases the agency’s P3 approach to financing healthcare facilities
The 160,000-sf, three-story VA Ambulatory Care Center opened in Omaha, Neb., in August. This is the first of five pilot projects authorized to be built under the Communities Helping Invest through Property and Improvements Needed for Veterans Act, otherwise known as CHIP IN, which became law in 2016 and allows the cash-strapped U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs to use private investments to fund construction and real estate purchases. Read the story
Hill International’s principals say that sustainable design continues to be an important trend, and that there is more attention being paid to the building envelope, engineering, and related testing and commissioning. There is also an increased reliance on the construction manager at risk delivery method for larger projects.
HOK and Gensler, on the other hand, say design-build remains the delivery method of choice for government clients. Public-private partnerships are also being looked at more seriously, especially by cash-strapped states and cities.
One recent P3 project is the Gensler-designed Vermont Corridor, a tower with 13 office levels, seven parking levels, and ground-floor retail, that will be the new headquarters for the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health and Workforce Development, Aging and Community Services. Trammell Crow, the county, High Street Residential, Meta Housing, and Public Facilities Group are redevelopment partners in this $302 million project, which is scheduled for completion in late 2021. (Hathaway Dinwiddie Construction is the general contractor on the project.)
The partners are also reviving two other sites along the Koreatown district’s Vermont Avenue, including a Steinberg Hart-designed adaptive reuse of an existing 12-story office building for 172 residential units and 4,700 sf of retail; and a Y&M Architects-designed 72-unit senior affordable housing complex with a 13,000-sf community center.
Related Stories
Giants 400 | Oct 23, 2023
Top 190 Multifamily Architecture Firms for 2023
Humphreys and Partners, Gensler, Solomon Cordwell Buenz, Niles Bolton Associates, and AO top the ranking of the nation's largest multifamily housing sector architecture and architecture/engineering (AE) firms for 2023, as reported in Building Design+Construction's 2023 Giants 400 Report. Note: This ranking factors revenue for all multifamily buildings work, including apartments, condominiums, student housing facilities, and senior living facilities.
Affordable Housing | Oct 20, 2023
Cracking the code of affordable housing
Perkins Eastman's affordable housing projects show how designers can help to advance the conversation of affordable housing.
Senior Living Design | Oct 19, 2023
Senior living construction poised for steady recovery
Senior housing demand, as measured by the change in occupied units, continued to outpace new supply in the third quarter, according to NIC MAP Vision. It was the ninth consecutive quarter of growth with a net absorption gain. On the supply side, construction starts continued to be limited compared with pre-pandemic levels.
Warehouses | Oct 19, 2023
JLL report outlines 'tremendous potential' for multi-story warehouses
A new category of buildings, multi-story warehouses, is beginning to take hold in the U.S. and their potential is strong. A handful of such facilities, also called “urban logistics buildings” have been built over the past five years, notes a new report by JLL.
Building Materials | Oct 19, 2023
New white papers offer best choices in drywall, flooring, and insulation for embodied carbon and health impacts
“Embodied Carbon and Material Health in Insulation” and “Embodied Carbon and Material Health in Gypsum Drywall and Flooring,” by architecture and design firm Perkins&Will in partnership with the Healthy Building Network, advise on how to select the best low-carbon products with the least impact on human health.
Contractors | Oct 19, 2023
Crane Index indicates slowing private-sector construction
Private-sector construction in major North American cities is slowing, according to the latest RLB Crane Index. The number of tower cranes in use declined 10% since the first quarter of 2023. The index, compiled by consulting firm Rider Levett Bucknall (RLB), found that only two of 14 cities—Boston and Toronto—saw increased crane counts.
Office Buildings | Oct 19, 2023
Proportion of workforce based at home drops to lowest level since pandemic began
The proportion of the U.S. workforce working remotely has dropped considerably since the start of the Covid 19 pandemic, but office vacancy rates continue to rise. Fewer than 26% of households have someone who worked remotely at least one day a week, down sharply from 39% in early 2021, according to the latest Census Bureau Household Pulse Surveys.
Luxury Residential | Oct 18, 2023
One Chicago wins 2023 International Architecture Award
One Chicago, a two-tower luxury residential and mixed-use complex completed last year, has won the 2023 International Architecture Award. The project was led by JDL Development and designed in partnership between architecture firms Goettsch Partners and Hartshorne Plunkard Architecture.
Giants 400 | Oct 17, 2023
Top 130 Sports Facility Architecture Firms for 2023
Populous, Gensler, HOK, and HKS head BD+C's ranking of the nation's largest sports facility architecture and architecture/engineering (AE) firms for 2023, as reported in Building Design+Construction's 2023 Giants 400 Report.
Office Buildings | Oct 16, 2023
The impact of office-to-residential conversion on downtown areas
Gensler's Duanne Render looks at the incentives that could bring more office-to-residential conversions to life.