The most likely beneficiaries of new infrastructure investment in the U.S. would be the engineering, construction, and industrial manufacturing sectors. And as government officials debate the next major infrastructure stimulus plan, PwC, the accounting and consulting firm, argues in a new study that industrial products and services companies must think proactively about positioning themselves as suppliers, planners, and even investors to help direct which infrastructure projects get funded, and how they are paid for.
The Trump Administration and the leadership of the Democratic Party have each come up with programs to infuse an estimated $1 trillion of infrastructure spending into the economy over the next decade. Those plans roughly align on where that investment is most heavily needed. Where they diverge—or at least are presumed to diverge, as details remain unclear—is primarily over how projects would be funded.
The Democrats’ plan would be chiefly debt financed, but also includes a $10 billion provision for an infrastructure bank to extend loan guarantees and low-cost loans to spur investment. Trump’s plan—which includes paying for a security wall across the U.S.-Mexico that alone could cost up to $25 billion—favors some combination of tax incentives and public-private partnerships, as long as what gets built subscribes to Trump’s “America First” mantra for hiring and product purchasing.
(A stumbling block to new legislation could be Republican budget hawks who have expressed opposition to any plan that isn’t revenue neutral. House Speaker Paul Ryan has gone so far as to state that every dollar of federal money for infrastructure spending must be matched by $40 of private investment. Some Democrats have also objected to the developer-heavy council Trump has assembled to pick and choose projects worthy of stimulus money.)
The U.S. seriously lags behind other industrial nations in the quality of its infrastructure. Image: PwC study “What a U.S. Infrastructure Stimulus Could Mean for the Industrial Sector.”
Meanwhile, the clock keeps ticking on the country’s crumbling bridges, roads, tunnels, and airports. The American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) estimates $3.3 trillion of investment is needed to maintain, repair and build new infrastructure through 2025, and sees a funding gap of $1.4 trillion to meet those needs. ASCE expects the gap to widen if current public and private investment trends continue unchanged, and further estimate that the economic impact of not filling the gap will sideline a potential $3.9 trillion GDP boost and 2.5 million jobs.
The public wants dramatic action to be taken, but continues to send out mixed signals about stimulus spending: PwC quotes a recent poll, conducted by Politico and Harvard’s T. H. Chan School of Public Health, which found 61% of Americans favor major new tax credits for business to build roads, bridges, waterways, airports and other infrastructure, while 75% says it was important for these projects to be federally funded.
PwC, though, thinks the time is “ripe” for more P3 activity in the U.S., partly because many states, restricted by balanced budget mandates and their unwillingness to raise taxes, simply can’t afford to take on big projects.
The question, though, is how to get more investors into the game. Through mid 2016, infrastructure funds that target North American assets were sitting on $75 billion in unspent capital. “The attractiveness of U.S. infrastructure [as an investment] needs to improve,” observes PwC.
The accounting firm thinks it “makes sense” to focus more on projects that enhance the America’s global competitiveness. In the latest World Economic Forum’s annual Global Competitive Index, a global ranking of the quality of the business environment, U.S. infrastructure lags other economies across several categories, ranking 12th overall, 13th in quality of roads, and ninth in air transport. Since 1980, public spending in transportation and water infrastructure, as a percentage of GDP, has held at around 2.5% compared to its 1959 peak of 3%. “The trend is hard to dislodge,” states PwC.
The irony is that greater investment pays dividends, if the Obama Administration’s $831 billion stimulus package through the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 is any barometer. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated that real GDP in 2010 was between 0.7% and 4.1% higher and that employment was between 700,000 and 3.3 million jobs greater (measured in employment years) than had the stimulus not been carried out. Over the 2009–2011 period, the number of jobs saved or created by ARRA investment was estimated by CBO to be between 1.4 million and 6.8 million.
PwC asserts that if the Trump Administration dedicated $100 billion per year to rebuilding infrastructure, job creation and business activity in the industrial sector would inevitably follow. “For a sustained effect, a strong emphasis should be placed not only on short-term jobs creation and economic stimulus, but also on long- term impact on productivity rates, sustainability and efficiencies that have strong fiscal multiplier effects. For example, embedding ‘smart’ technology in all new infrastructure is critical, to ensure that infrastructure assets are ‘future proof.’ ”
Perhaps the most controversial part of PwC’s report—and one Trump and many of his supporters would find hard to swallow—is its business-centric view that any infrastructure stimulus plan shouldn’t get too hung up on how many jobs it generates.
“Considering the ongoing shifting nature of jobs,” PwC continues, “as manufacturers adopt advanced manufacturing technologies is just as important as—and perhaps more important than—the number of jobs in the industrial labor force.”
Related Stories
MFPRO+ News | Jun 3, 2024
New York’s office to residential conversion program draws interest from 64 owners
New York City’s Office Conversion Accelerator Program has been contacted by the owners of 64 commercial buildings interested in converting their properties to residential use.
Adaptive Reuse | May 15, 2024
Modular adaptive reuse of parking structure grants future flexibility
The shift away from excessive parking requirements aligns with a broader movement, encouraging development of more sustainable and affordable housing.
Retail Centers | May 3, 2024
Outside Las Vegas, two unused office buildings will be turned into an open-air retail development
In Henderson, Nev., a city roughly 15 miles southeast of Las Vegas, 100,000 sf of unused office space will be turned into an open-air retail development called The Cliff. The $30 million adaptive reuse development will convert the site’s two office buildings into a destination for retail stores, chef-driven restaurants, and community entertainment.
Student Housing | May 1, 2024
Pfluger Architects unveils renovated student lounges at all-girls dormitory
In a step toward updating and modernizing on-campus housing to attract a range of students, Texas-based Pfluger Architects renovated the student lounges in Kinsolving Hall, a five-story, all-girls dormitory at The University of Texas at Austin initially built in 1958.
Adaptive Reuse | Apr 29, 2024
6 characteristics of a successful adaptive reuse conversion
In the continuous battle against housing shortages and the surplus of vacant buildings, developers are turning their attention to the viability of adaptive reuse for their properties.
Resiliency | Apr 22, 2024
Controversy erupts in Florida over how homes are being rebuilt after Hurricane Ian
The Federal Emergency Management Agency recently sent a letter to officials in Lee County, Florida alleging that hundreds of homes were rebuilt in violation of the agency’s rules following Hurricane Ian. The letter provoked a sharp backlash as homeowners struggle to rebuild following the devastating 2022 storm that destroyed a large swath of the county.
Building Materials | Apr 22, 2024
Tacoma, Wash., investigating policy to reuse and recycle building materials
Tacoma, Wash., recently initiated a study to find ways to increase building material reuse through deconstruction and salvage. The city council unanimously voted to direct the city manager to investigate deconstruction options and estimate costs.
Mixed-Use | Apr 9, 2024
A surging master-planned community in Utah gets its own entertainment district
Since its construction began two decades ago, Daybreak, the 4,100-acre master-planned community in South Jordan, Utah, has been a catalyst and model for regional growth. The latest addition is a 200-acre mixed-use entertainment district that will serve as a walkable and bikeable neighborhood within the community, anchored by a minor-league baseball park and a cinema/entertainment complex.
Reconstruction & Renovation | Mar 28, 2024
Longwood Gardens reimagines its horticulture experience with 17-acre conservatory
Longwood Gardens announced this week that Longwood Reimagined: A New Garden Experience, the most ambitious revitalization in a century of America’s greatest center for horticultural display, will open to the public on November 22, 2024.
Sustainability | Mar 13, 2024
Trends to watch shaping the future of ESG
Gensler’s Climate Action & Sustainability Services Leaders Anthony Brower, Juliette Morgan, and Kirsten Ritchie discuss trends shaping the future of environmental, social, and governance (ESG).