Although wood is commonly used as a finish material in nonresidential buildings, more and more Building Teams are specifying wood as a structural material to accompany steel or concreteâor sometimes to be used entirely on its own. Recent studies show that wood offers such benefits as speed of construction, cost effectiveness, durability, and sustainability (see box, page 53). Structural wood products such as cross-laminated timber (CLT) and parallel strand lumber (PSL) are attracting the attention of architects, structural engineers, and contractors.
Research by the National Science Foundation and other partners on the performance of wood buildings during seismic eventsâthe so-called NEESWood Capstone testsâis yielding promising results. For example, Japanese researchers built a seven-story wood-frame residential structure on a shake table and subjected it to Kobe-level earthquake conditionsâ6.9 on the Richter scale (see http://www.apawood.org/level_b.cfm?content=srv_newsinfo_34). âThere was virtually no damage to the building,â says Dwight Yochim, national director of WoodWorks, an alliance of North American wood associations, headquartered in Vancouver, B.C.
Yochim says that one of the concerns with building with concrete or steel is the temptation to overbuild to compensate for the mass of the material itself. âWood has many redundant connections and itâs light,â he says, âso when an earthquake hits, it doesnât have the same impact on the buildingâ as it would with a steel or concrete structure.
Yochim says some glulam manufacturers are adding steel straps to their beams to help carry the load over long spans. The Richmond Olympic Oval, built for the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver, B.C., has a wood roof with a clear span of more than 300 feet. Part of the roof is constructed of double Douglas-fir glulam beams reinforced with steel straps.
âWood is a viable building product and a good alternative to conventional construction,â says Blakely C. Dunn, AIA, NCARB, principal of CADM Architecture, El Dorado, Ark. âItâs easy to erect, and itâs easy to correct something thatâs incorrect.â He notes that wood usually has a shorter lead time for delivery compared to other structural materials: âYou donât have to wait weeks for it to show up at the job site.â
Applications for structural wood expand
- Architects and engineers are substituting wood framing for steel and concrete as a cost-saving measure.
- Manufacturers are adding steel straps to glulam beams to help carry loads over long spans.
- Cross-laminated timber is making its debut in the U.S. as an innovative framing material for buildings up to 10 stories in height.
- Heavy-timber construction showcases the versatility, strength, and beauty of wood and can help keep projects on budget.
CROSS-LAMINATED TIMBER CROSSES THE POND
Cross-laminated timber has been widely used in Europe since the 1980s but is not well known in North America. CLT panels are manufactured by stacking multiple layers of wood, each about 20 to 38 millimeters in thickness, at right angles and gluing them together in a press. Typical widths are 0.6, 1.2, and 2.95 meters (up to 4 meters), in lengths up to 24 meters.
The cross-lamination process minimizes swelling and shrinkage and increases resistance. CLT panels are used for floor, wall, and roof systems. Pre-assembled wall sections can be lifted into place with cranes and attached to each other with screws or steel brackets.
âCLT competes head-to-head with concrete buildings up to six stories,â says Yochim. So far, the tallest CLT structure built in Europe is nine stories. Researchers in Austria are testing something called the life cycle tower, a combination of glulam beams, CLT, and concrete slabs that could go much higher. âTheyâre all prefabricated assemblies,â says Yochim. âOnce youâve got your foundation down, the rest of the building just bolts together.â
The first nonresidential CLT building to be constructed in the U.S., a 78-foot church bell tower, was completed in December 2010 in Gastonia, N.C. The tower has a 12x12-foot base and wood panels of varying lengths, which provide the strength and stability of concrete but are much lighter, says Michael DeVere, principal of MDS10 Architects, Asheville, N.C. The foundation is three feet deep.
To better analyze the stresses inflicted by wind and seismic loading and swinging bells, Medlock & Associates Engineering, Asheville, N.C., modeled the tower using RISA-3D design software. This enabled the engineers to keep the project within its $450,000 budget. For ease of assembly, they used a panelized system and kept connection variations to a minimum.
The panels were prefabricated in Austria, reducing the amount of on-site labor and virtually eliminating job-site waste. Tim Richards, vice president of general contractor M-Y Construction of Tryon, N.C., says a comparable steel structure would have taken three to four weeks to complete. With CLT, it took five-and-a-half days.
DeVere points out that CLT is also a green material, accounting for significantly less greenhouse gas emissions than concrete or steel. He also likes its creative nature. âIt can free you from many of the constrictions of conventional construction,â he says. âDepending on the design, you can eliminate lintels and headers as well as columns and deep horizontal framing members.â Exterior wall panels distribute the bearing load evenly across the entire length, so most point loads can be dispersed, avoiding piers and pad footings and reducing the amount of concrete in the foundation.
âSome have described CLT as âLegos on steroids,ââ says DeVere. âWe see it as a game changer for the construction industry.â He and his business partner, Crawford Murphy, hope to open a CLT manufacturing facility in the U.S.
HEAVY TIMBER PLAYS LEAD ROLE IN THEATER
In British Columbia, the use of heavy timber in nonresidential projects is commonplace. But the concept raised eyebrows when first proposed for Arena Stage at the Mead Center for American Theater, in Washington, D.C.
âThe local building authorities were skeptical at first about the use of timber for large institutional assembly buildings,â says Michael Heeney, MAIBC, FRAIC, LEED AP, principal of Bing Thom Architects, Vancouver, B.C. âThey were concerned about flammability.â The firm and its fire engineers, LMDG, presented a fire report and char analysis which showed that the effects of a fire on the structure would be minimal. In fact, charring on the outside of the wood columns would actually protect the interior of the wood.
One of the project goals was to double the space of Arena Stage and the adjacent Kreeger Theater. There was no money in the budget for finishes, yet the structure had to be beautiful, so wood made perfect sense as both a structural and finish material. The architects wrapped the two theaters with an insulated glass wall, providing acoustic separation from nearby Reagan National Airport and highway traffic.
StructureCraft Builders, a specialty timber-frame design/builder based in Delta, B.C., crafted 18 giant columns out of parallel strand lumber (PSL) for the perimeter of the Arena Stage façade. The columns are unreinforced, solid engineered wood that use no internal steel support. Bing Thom Architects designed the kinds of connections used in a steel-frame building so that local steelworkers could install them.
âWood is a very versatile material, but you need to spend time making the connections economical by encouraging as much repetition as possible,â says Heeney. âThe PSL columns at Arena Stage connect to specially designed iron castings that would have been prohibitively expensive had we made only one.â
WOOD FRAMING SAVES $2.7 MILLION FOR SCHOOL
When the El Dorado (Ark.) School District needed a new high school for 1,600 students, the Building Team compared the cost of structural steel, precast concrete, and wood as a framing system.
Blake Dunn of CADM Architecture says the schoolâs construction budget was $134.78/sf. Had it been built with steel and masonry, the cost would have been $50/sf too high. Wood framing saved $2.7 million.
The original design intentâto use wood for exposed areas inside the buildingâwas extended to concealed areas such as columns, beams, demising walls, office partitions, exterior walls, floors and roof systems. The structural components are predominately Southern yellow pine. Interior doors are maple; the paneling and trim are red oak. âThe auditorium has large acoustical deflectors on the side walls that are made out of maple plywood,â he says. âTheyâre angled in such a way as to tune the space.â +
MORE ON THE BENEFITSÂ OF STRUCTURAL WOOD
âScience Supporting the Economic and Environmental Benefits of Using Wood and Wood Products in Green Building Construction,â Michael A. Ritter, Kenneth Skog, and Richard Bergman, USDA Forest Service.
âWood Products Used on the Construction of Low-Rise Nonresidential Buildings in the United States, 2008,â David B. McKeever, USDA Forest Service.
âMaximizing Forest Contributions to Carbon Mitigationâ (CORRIM Fact Sheet, March 2009).
âProduct and Process Environmental Improvement Analysis for Buildings (Carbon Life Cycle Assessment)â (CORRIM Fact Sheet, December 2009).
Related Stories
| May 19, 2014
Why e-commerce won't kill 'bricks and mortar' retail sector
Despite emerging structural challenges and newly-announced store closings, such as those of Radio Shack and Office Depot, the U.S. retail sector has continued on its solid recovery.
| May 16, 2014
BoA, USGBC to offer $25,000 grants for green affordable housing projects
The Affordable Green Neighborhoods Grant Program will offer 14 grants to developers of affordable housing in North America who are committed to building sustainable communities through the LEED for Neighborhood Development program.Â
| May 16, 2014
HED expands leadership in San Diego
Neville Willsmore, Thomas Christian join leadership team for Harley Ellis Devereaux.
| May 16, 2014
Toyo Ito leads petition to scrap Zaha Hadid's 2020 Olympic Stadium project
Ito and other Japanese architects cite excessive costs, massive size, and the project's potentially negative impact on surrounding public spaces as reasons for nixing Hadid's plan. Â
| May 15, 2014
Paints, coatings, and sealants: 10 new ways to seal the deal
Color-shifting finishes, dry-erase surfaces, and stain-blocking paints are highlighted in this round up of new offerings in paints, coatings, sealants, and finishes.Â
| May 15, 2014
Biking to work up by 60 percent, according to Census Bureau report
Many U.S. cities are seeing an increase in bicycle commuters, according to new a U.S. Census Bureau report. While bicyclists still account for just 0.6% of all commuters, some of the nation's largest cities have more than doubled their rates since 2000.
| May 15, 2014
'Virtually indestructible': Utah architect applies thin-shell dome concept for safer schools
At $94 a square foot and "virtually indestructible," some school districts in Utah are opting to build concrete dome schools in lieu of traditional structures.Â
| May 15, 2014
First look: 9/11 Memorial Museum opens to first-responders, survivors, 9/11 families [slideshow]
The 110,000-sf museum is filled with monumental artifacts from the tragedy and exhibits that honor the lives of every victim of the 2001 and 1993 attacks.Â
| May 14, 2014
New study shows employees aren't happier working in green buildings
People working in buildings certified under LEEDâs green building standard appear no more satisfied with their workplace environments than those in conventional buildings, according to new research from the University of California, Berkeley, and the University of Nottingham.
| May 14, 2014
Construction growth looking up: Gilbane Spring 2014 Economic Report
Construction spending for 2014 should finish 6.6% higher than in 2013, with nonresidential work contributing substantially.