In the six quarters ended June 30, nearly 95 million square feet of new office space had been delivered in the U.S., and another 25 million sf were under construction for delivery in 2019. With available office space outpacing demand, coupled with a significant flight to quality by companies, landlords are vying for tenants with more generous improvement packages.
Tenant improvement packages, in fact, have helped landlords offset peak rents as well as premium pricing for new construction, whose final price tag continues to be adversely affected by steadily rising materials and labor costs.
Against the backdrop of these dynamics, during what has been the second-longest period of economic expansion in the country’s history, JLL this week released its second annual U.S. and Canada Fit Out Guide and Office Cost Benchmarking Report for 2018, which can be downloaded here.
The guide is based on 2,800 JLL-managed projects for more than 100 clients in 59 markets and 17 industries. Its purpose is to provide a reference for average costs to build out three different office layouts—progressive, moderate, and traditional—within a matrix of high, medium, or base levels of space quality and complexity (see chart).
The guide, based on 2,800 projects, compares the different cost structures for three styles and three quality levels of office fit outs. Image: JLL
This year’s guide adds office layout and space quality components that allow users to evaluate how different layouts, project complexities, and materials selections might affect bottom-line costs. JLL also worked closed with its supply-chain and project managers to provide allowances for furniture, fittings and equipment (FF&E), and AV installation. The latest guide also removed contingencies associated with high-level budgeting.
During a teleconference previewing this report, three JLL executives—Scott Kessling, who heads up its Business Intelligence team; Lauren Harsha, Senior Business Intelligence Analyst; and David Barnett, Senior Analyst-Research—explained how decisions about office-space design and fit-out expenditures are being driven by five factors that are dictating the future of work: human experience, financial performance, digital drive (i.e., harnessing digitalization and rich data to enhance people and enterprise performance), continuous innovation, and operational excellence.
Fit out budgets are also being impacted by labor shortages, and by materials costs that last year rose 3.4% and continue upward in 2018, in some cases—like softwood lumber and steel—by double digits.
To help companies determine which fit out style suits their personalities and strategy, JLL calls out key space considerations for each.
The Progressive style is the favored layout for tech companies and startups. It’s open, with 100% benches and no enclosed offices. It can accommodate between 20% to 50% more employees than the Moderate or Traditional style. A standard plan would have 28 conference rooms and seven open collaborative and multi-use spaces. Project budgets for Progressive fit outs tend to be lighter on hard costs due to minimal dividing walls or enclosed offices. And this style saves on traditional FF&E spending.
A Moderate-style fit might work best for a company transitioning into a more efficient office model. It features a mix of workstations and limited (10%) private offices. It can handle between 20% to 25% more employees than a Traditional-style fit out, and its standard plan would include 20 conference rooms and five collaborative spaces. While more expensive per sf than the Progressive style, a Moderate fit out can capture cost efficiencies by integrating a higher percentage of bench-style desks.
Law firms and financial service providers are among the businesses that favor Traditional-style fit outs, where at least 30% of the space is for enclosed offices, and its floor plan features 8x8-ft cubicles. Traditional will have the highest FF&E costs of the three styles. But JLL also points out that tenant factors are comparatively small within a Traditional model due to lessened need for common areas or multi-use space furniture.
The largest metros are typically the most expensive for office fit outs, but there are still bargains are there, as in Austin, where 3 million sf of new office space is under construction and whose vacancy rate hovers near 11%. Image: JLL
JLL’s report does a deeper dive by offering breakdowns—by 59 metros in the U.S. and Canada, and by fit out style—of hard costs, design and fee costs, FF& costs, and tenant factor costs that are further delineated by base, medium, and high space quality and complexity.
The report then provides more detail on six metros—Austin, Chicago, Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco, and Toronto—that are among the most active places for office construction and redevelopment.
In all six markets, office construction is moving full speed ahead, despite double-digit vacancy rates in four of the six cities. In San Francisco—where 68.8% of new construction is already preleased—absorption rates are expected to rise significantly. In Los Angeles, a big market driver is an expanding digital media sector. And in New York, new supply additions are creating conditions more favorable to renters and are pushing higher-than-ever concessions packages.
Related Stories
Market Data | Jun 15, 2020
International Code Council offers guidance on building re-occupancy for reopening economies
Companies and building managers can access free resources at the Code Council’s Coronavirus Response Center.
Market Data | Jun 12, 2020
6 must reads for the AEC industry today: June 12, 2020
How will museums change in the face of COVID-19 and the patriarch of The Boldt Company dies.
Market Data | Jun 11, 2020
5 must reads for the AEC industry today: June 11, 2020
Istanbul opens largest base-isolated hospital in the world and AIA issues tools for reducing risk of COVID-19 transmission in buildings.
Market Data | Jun 10, 2020
6 must reads for the AEC industry today: June 10, 2020
Singapore's newest residential district and CannonDesign unveils COVID Shield.
Market Data | Jun 9, 2020
ABC’s Construction Backlog Indicator inches higher in May; Contractor confidence continues to rebound
Nonresidential construction backlog is down 0.8 months compared to May 2019 and declined year over year in every industry.
Market Data | Jun 9, 2020
6 must reads for the AEC industry today: June 9, 2020
OSHA safety inspections fall 84% and the office isn't dead.
Market Data | Jun 8, 2020
Construction jobs rise by 464,000 jobs but remain 596,000 below recent peak
Gains in may reflect temporary support from paycheck protection program loans and easing of construction restrictions, but hobbled economy and tight state and local budgets risk future job losses.
Market Data | Jun 5, 2020
7 must reads for the AEC industry today: June 5, 2020
The world's first carbon-fiber reinforced concrete building and what will college be like in the fall?
Market Data | Jun 4, 2020
7 must reads for the AEC industry today: June 4, 2020
Construction unemployment declines in 326 of 358 metro areas and is the show over for AMC Theatres?
Market Data | Jun 3, 2020
Construction employment declines in 326 out of 358 metro areas in April
Association says new transportation proposal could help restore jobs.