The news this week that the regional First Republic Bank lost $102 billion in bank deposits in the first quarter of 2023—more than half of the $176 billion the bank was holding at the end of last year—was further evidence that investors and depositors are more than a little jittery about the financial condition of the banking industry.
While First Republic stated that its deposit-and-withdrawal activities had stabilized in late March and mid April, the bank is also in the process of reducing its workforce by one quarter and slashing its executive compensation.
First Republic’s travails, coupled with the recent takeover of Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank by federal regulators, has industry observers wondering whether these bank failures are signs of something more ominous. This is particularly true among real estate developers that rely heavily on bank lenders to capitalize their purchases and projects.
To sort out the latest banking turmoil and where the Commercial Real Estate (CRE) sector fits in, Cushman & Wakefield on April 19 posted a list of 14 frequently asked questions and weighed in on each. The topics touched on:
•What happened?
•How is this different from other banking failures?
•Why is commercial real estate in the limelight?
•What key metrics bear watching?
“Don’t panic,” C&W advises. But developers should also be aware that recent banking failures have toughened the lending environment; the percentage of banks that say they have tightened their lending standards for CRE loans and other business loans is the highest it’s been in 13 years.
“There are reasons to be both optimistic and concerned,” says C&W. “The sky isn’t falling; at this stage, it’s more overcast than anything else.”
This doesn't look like mid-2000s déjà vu
Of all the sources the CRE sector turns to for money, banks provide between 40 and 45 percent of the sector’s financing. Community and regional banks “are the lifeblood of the CRE lending landscape,” says Cushman & Wakefield. And smaller banks are responsible for the majority of multifamily, nonfarm residential, and acquisition/development/construction loan lending.
The failures of a handful of banks, out of a total of more than 5,000, don’t qualify as a crisis. And the banks that have failed in recent months had idiosyncratic factors that contributed to their unraveling. For example, C&W observes that, in the failures of Signature Bank and Silvergate Bank (the latter of which started liquidation proceedings in March), “underlying losses in the value of cryptocurrency served to act as a deposit outflow prior to outright withdrawals happening.”
C&W states that while no bank can survive a run on its deposits, and that a few more failures wouldn’t be a surprise, the U.S. banking system as a whole remains “well capitalized,” with most bank deposits spread across an array of sectors and individuals. The key in the future, C&W says, will be sustaining confidence in the solvency of that system.
It's worth noting that lenders had been pulling back on their CRE lending since last summer, homing in on high-quality assets like industrial and multifamily. C&W is keeping an eye on how the debt market perceives risk for CRE borrowers. On a broader scale, C&W is watching deposit flows, lending patterns to see how banks are navigating incoming maturities, liquidity based on the Federal Reserve’s provision of credit to banks, and jobless claims and inflation, which could be signs of recession.
Recent banking failures haven’t altered Cushman & Wakefield’s prediction of a mild recession in 2023 that will abate as tighter credit and slower economic growth stem inflation.
What C&W doesn’t predict is a repeat of the Great Financial Crisis of the mid-2000s. The financial system is “much stronger” now, and policymakers are responding to problems much quicker and aggressively. The size of the banking failures (so far, at least) is much smaller, and those failures relate not so much to credit but to the ramifications of a rising-rate environment and its impact on bond and securities values.
Most development is an attractive risk
Any weaknesses in the CRE sector will pose challenges to lenders. C&W doesn’t expect those weaknesses to pose a systemic banking sector failure. But, it cautions, there could be isolated instances of loan or credit stress for the banking sector, stemming from any combination of factors that might include oncoming loan maturity, a diminishing of underlying asset value, or deteriorating cash flows.
What does this mean for companies that are leasing space? C&W predicts that most property types will shift toward a tenant-friendlier environment. But landlords will also favor higher-quality tenants “to ensure the viability of the lease agreement.” For companies leasing space in ongoing construction, “the good news is that most development is considered to be attractive on a risk-adjusted basis.” So even if banks pull back, other lending groups are likely to step into that breech.
For signposts about what might happen next, C&W recommends following commercial mortgage-backed securities loan performance data across the CRE industry, and measuring that data against CRE debt financing. It might also be insightful to track prevailing underwriting standards and banks’ forward-looking expectations for the credit market.
What C&W doesn’t recommend is overreacting to the recent failure of Credit Suisse, and its takeover by rival UBS, as indicators of a European domino effect to what’s happening in the U.S.
Related Stories
AEC Tech | Apr 30, 2024
Lack of organizational readiness is biggest hurdle to artificial intelligence adoption
Managers of companies in the industrial sector, including construction, have bought the hype of artificial intelligence (AI) as a transformative technology, but their organizations are not ready to realize its promise, according to research from IFS, a global cloud enterprise software company. An IFS survey of 1,700 senior decision-makers found that 84% of executives anticipate massive organizational benefits from AI.
AEC Innovators | Apr 15, 2024
3 ways the most innovative companies work differently
Gensler’s pre-pandemic workplace research reinforced that great workplace design drives creativity and innovation. Using six performance indicators, we're able to view workers’ perceptions of the quality of innovation, creativity, and leadership in an employee’s organization.
MFPRO+ News | Apr 12, 2024
Greystar becomes top apartment owner, manager, and developer in 2024
One firm set records for this year’s National Multifamily Housing Council Top 50 roundup of multifamily firms. Greystar now sits at number one in the NMHC’s lists for top apartment owner, manager, and developer in 2024.
K-12 Schools | Apr 10, 2024
Surprise, surprise: Students excel in modernized K-12 school buildings
Too many of the nation’s school districts are having to make it work with less-than-ideal educational facilities. But at what cost to student performance and staff satisfaction?
Multifamily Housing | Apr 9, 2024
March reports record gains in multifamily rent growth in 20 months
Asking rents for multifamily units increased $8 during the month to $1,721; year-over-year growth grew 30 basis points to 0.9 percent—a normal seasonal growth pattern according to Yardi Matrix.
Retail Centers | Apr 4, 2024
Retail design trends: Consumers are looking for wellness in where they shop
Consumers are making lifestyle choices with wellness in mind, which ignites in them a feeling of purpose and a sense of motivation. That’s the conclusion that the architecture and design firm MG2 draws from a survey of 1,182 U.S. adult consumers the firm conducted last December about retail design and what consumers want in healthier shopping experiences.
Industry Research | Apr 4, 2024
Expenses per multifamily unit reach $8,950 nationally
Overall expenses per multifamily unit rose to $8,950, a 7.1% increase year-over-year (YOY) as of January 2024, according to an examination of more than 20,000 properties analyzed by Yardi Matrix.
Student Housing | Mar 27, 2024
March student housing preleasing in line with last year
Preleasing is still increasing at a historically fast pace, surpassing 61% in February 2024 and marking a 4.5% increase year-over-year.
K-12 Schools | Mar 18, 2024
New study shows connections between K-12 school modernizations, improved test scores, graduation rates
Conducted by Drexel University in conjunction with Perkins Eastman, the research study reveals K-12 school modernizations significantly impact key educational indicators, including test scores, graduation rates, and enrollment over time.
MFPRO+ News | Mar 16, 2024
Multifamily rents stable heading into spring 2024
National asking multifamily rents posted their first increase in over seven months in February. The average U.S. asking rent rose $1 to $1,713 in February 2024, up 0.6% year-over-year.