Granite School District in Utahâs Salt Lake Valley has more than 60,000 students, making it one of the nationâs largest. In 2017, the District approved a $238 million bond that would fund the construction and renovation of 31 schools over a 10-year period.
Skyline High School and Cyprus High School were among those that would be replaced with modern buildings. Just how modern, though, was a point of debate between the District and the two firms hired to design the new construction, according to the lead architect on these projects.
First, some history about Skyline High School, located in Millcreek, Utah: Its current building opened in 1962, and it serves 2,156 students. That original is being replaced by a 427,000-sf school whose capacity will be between 2,200 and 2,300 students. It will have 51 classrooms, 13 labs, 11 specialized labs, abundant collaborative spaces, and six special-education resource teams. So far, the new campusâ pool, gym, and sports fields are completed. The academic building will be move-in ready this summer, at which point demolition on the old school will commence. After that, the new schoolâs auditorium and fine-arts center will be built, along with bus routes and parking areas. The whole project is scheduled for completion by December 2026.
Â
Back to the drawing board
Granite School District hired Fanning Howey to design the new Skyline High School in August 2017. Michael Hall, the firmâs Senior Project Executive and Education Planner, says that the District insisted, for accountability reasons, that Fanning Howey and Naylor Wentworth Lund, another design firm hired for this project, work under a joint venture agreement. (The joint venture is called Elevate.)
But when the firms presented their renderings, the District âreacted negatively,â recalls Hall. He believes that the community thought the designââwhich emphasized glass exterior walls throughoutââstrayed too far from a nostalgic ideal. âIt wasnât what they remembered the school had been,â he says. So the two firms restarted from scratch in 2019, and while glass is still prominent in the revised renderingsâ interior and exterior design, âit wasnât the vision we started with.â
Hall, who is based in Ohio, says he does a Zoom call every two weeks with his team, âand the first thing I ask is âis everyone happy?ââ
Ironically, the District and community signed off on the design teamâs renderings for the new 508,000-sf Cyprus High School, located in Magna, Utah, without much pushback. The Cyprus project is scheduled for completion in 2025.
Embracing space flexibility
Â
The $168 million Cyprus project, built on what had been an empty field with a 40- to 50-ft slope, required $4 million in soil compaction to support the new construction. The $174 million Skyline campus is more tightly configured, says Hall.
Another difference is how each project is being delivered. The old schools have been kept open during construction. Hughes General Contractors is building Skyline as its Construction Manager, whereas Westland Construction is building Cyprus as a General Contractor. To keep the design team in the loop, Westland has been sending Hall drone imagery of Cyprusâ progress every Monday, which prompted Hughes to send drone pictures of Skyline regularly, too.
What binds these two projects is their embrace of collaboration and design flexibility. At a time when some school districts and developers âstill want egg cratesâ for classroom design, Hall lauds the Granite School District for devoting up to 900 sf for each of the numerous collaborative spaces included in Skyline and Cyprus. Glass walls that surround these spaces not only let more natural light into the adjacent classrooms, but provide safety and security with âadult visual controlâ of each room.
Skylineâs athletic buildings, which were completed in 2021, at the height of the COVID pandemic, include disinfecting lighting whose luminaires with 405-mm technology kill harmful airborne viruses and bacteria automatically and continuously.
Despite some of the anomalies and challenges these projects presented, Hall says heâs âexcitedâ about how the schools will look. For Hall, who has been semiretired since 2018, Skyline and Cyprus will also be his âswan songs. When these are done, Iâm done.â
Related Stories
K-12 Schools | Apr 30, 2024
Fully electric Oregon elementary school aims for resilience with microgrid design
The River Grove Elementary School in Oregon was designed for net-zero carbon and resiliency to seismic events, storms, and wildfire. The roughly 82,000-sf school in a Portland suburb will feature a microgridâa small-scale power grid that operates independently from the areaâs electric grid.Â
K-12 Schools | Apr 10, 2024
A San Antonio school will provide early childhood education to a traditionally under-resourced region
In San Antonio, Pre-K 4 SA, which provides preschool for 3- and 4-year-olds, and HOLT Group, which owns industrial and other companies, recently broke ground on an early childhood education: the South Education Center.
K-12 Schools | Apr 10, 2024
Surprise, surprise: Students excel in modernized K-12 school buildings
Too many of the nationâs school districts are having to make it work with less-than-ideal educational facilities. But at what cost to student performance and staff satisfaction?Â
K-12 Schools | Apr 1, 2024
High school includes YMCA to share facilities and connect with the broader community
In Omaha, Neb., a public high school and a YMCA come together in one facility, connecting the school with the broader community. The 285,000-sf Westview High School, programmed and designed by the team of Perkins&Will and architect of record BCDM Architects, has its own athletic facilities but shares a pool, weight room, and more with the 30,000-sf YMCA.
K-12 Schools | Mar 18, 2024
New study shows connections between K-12 school modernizations, improved test scores, graduation rates
Conducted by Drexel University in conjunction with Perkins Eastman, the research study reveals K-12 school modernizations significantly impact key educational indicators, including test scores, graduation rates, and enrollment over time.
K-12 Schools | Feb 29, 2024
Average age of U.S. school buildings is just under 50 years
The average age of a main instructional school building in the United States is 49 years, according to a survey by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). About 38% of schools were built before 1970. Roughly half of the schools surveyed have undergone a major building renovation or addition.
Construction Costs | Feb 22, 2024
K-12 school construction costs for 2024
Data from Gordian breaks down the average cost per square foot for four different types of K-12 school buildings (elementary schools, junior high schools, high schools, and vocational schools) across 10 U.S. cities.
K-12 Schools | Feb 13, 2024
K-12 school design trends for 2024: health, wellness, net zero energyÂ
K-12 school sector experts are seeing âhealthinessâ for schools expand beyond air quality or the ease of cleaning interior surfaces. In this post-Covid era, âhealthyâ and âwellnessâ are intersecting expectations that, for many school districts, encompass the physical and mental wellbeing of students and teachers, greater access to outdoor spaces for play and learning, and the schoolâs connection to its community as a hub and resource.
K-12 Schools | Jan 25, 2024
Video: Research-based design for K-12 schools
Two experts from national architecture firm PBK discuss how behavioral research is benefiting the design of K-12 schools in Texas, Florida, and other states. Dan Boggio, AIA, LEED AP, NCARB, Founder & Executive Chair, PBK, and Melissa Turnbaugh, AIA, NCARB, Partner & National Education & Innovation Leader, PBK, speak with Robert Cassidy, Executive Editor, Building Design+Construction.
K-12 Schools | Jan 8, 2024
Video: Learn how DLR Group converted two big-box stores into an early education center
Learn how the North Kansas City (Mo.) School District and DLR Group adapted two big-box stores into a 115,000-sf early education center offering services for children with special needs.Â