MGM Resorts International shareholders and bondholders have filed an amended class-action lawsuit in hopes of recovering losses from the decline of the Las Vegas company’s stock and bond prices between 2007 and 2009.
Two and a half years ago, stockholders filed six lawsuits after the stock price fell from $99.75 on Oct. 9, 2007, to $1.89 on March 5, 2009. Bondholders sued over similar steep losses.
The securities holders complained the prices fell because of problems related to the global recession as well as undisclosed cost overruns, construction problems, and financial difficulties MGM Resorts faced with its half-owned $8.5 billion CityCenter casino resort complex on the Las Vegas Strip.
The lawsuits complained that MGM Resorts officials failed to promptly disclose many of these problems, causing the stock and bond prices to be inflated before they tumbled once the market realized how serious the issues were.
U.S. District Judge Gloria Navarro in Las Vegas on March 27 dismissed two of the suits, saying they weren’t specific enough.
The shareholders and bondholders responded Tuesday by filing an amended combined lawsuit with more specific allegations about what certain MGM Resorts officials told shareholders, bondholders and analysts in presentations and in earnings reports and conference calls in 2007, 2008, and 2009.
The amended suit says 10 confidential witnesses have provided detailed information to the shareholders’ attorneys about CityCenter construction and financing problems.
The suit says these witnesses are executives who served as a vice president of global sourcing for MGM Resorts, an MGM director of construction management and finance, an MGM design project manager, an MGM corporate finance officer, an MGM financial analyst, an MGM internal audit director, an MGM lead project manager, a cost engineer for general contractor Perini Building Co., a project control director for contractor Tishman Construction and an engineer on the podium portion of the Harmon Hotel, where construction remains halted because of construction defects.
Based on information from these witnesses, the shareholders allege that as early as August 2007 MGM Resorts officials falsely told shareholders that construction was “progressing nicely” on CityCenter and that it was “on budget.”
The shareholders allege these statements were false because much of CityCenter was being designed as it was being built, sometimes forcing contractors to remove components and then rebuild them according to updated designs.
“Constant design changes while construction was already in progress led to increasing construction costs,” the suit says, citing information from one of the confidential witnesses.
One witness “confirmed that MGM’s construction estimates were underestimated from the very beginning of the project because the design drawings were not completed and the exact quantity and grade of materials was not known to Perini when it made its initial bids (the bids on which MGM’s estimates were based),” the suit says. “After Perini submitted its bids, MGM changed the designs, increasing the quantity, grade and price of materials required, thereby increasing the construction costs.”
“The publicly announced construction costs for CityCenter were purposely underestimated. This was so because, while Perini provided accurate cost estimates to MGM, MGM and Tishman arbitrarily reduced those estimates by 20 percent when formulating CityCenter’s estimated construction costs to be reported to the public,” the suit charges.
The shareholders complained that CityCenter was “plagued by construction problems” including at the Harmon, where the suit says major issues were apparent as early as March 2008 but weren’t disclosed until January 2009.
The suit says that even when CityCenter was described as a $7.4 billion project in 2007, MGM Resorts was facing difficulties in finalizing $3 billion in financing for it.
That’s because just as the credit markets were tightening in response to the global recession, MGM Resorts was being squeezed by the declining value of CityCenter as well as a slowdown in visitation to Las Vegas that was reducing its revenue and cash flow.
“CityCenter would prove much more costly to MGM — and its shareholders — than ever disclosed by defendants. In fact, MGM’s crown jewel project would prove to be a virtual black hole, bringing the company to the brink of bankruptcy and causing its investors to suffer massive losses,” the suit complained.
The shareholders and bondholders in Tuesday’s amended complaint are pension funds, including the Arkansas Teacher Retirement System, the Philadelphia Board of Pensions and Retirement, the Luzerne County (Pa.) Retirement System and Netherlands-based pension fund manager PMT.
They claim to have lost about $6.7 million on their MGM Resorts investments and hope to recover their losses and the unspecified losses of others who bought MGM Resorts securities between Aug. 7, 2007, and March 5, 2009.
MGM Resorts – then called MGM Mirage – eventually finalized financing for CityCenter and beefed up its own balance sheet with a series of debt and equity issuances beginning in 2009.
The company has denied the shareholders’ allegations that it failed to disclose problems with the construction and financing of CityCenter; and it’s unknown when or how the shareholder lawsuits will be resolved. BD+C
Related Stories
| Feb 23, 2011
Architecture Billings hold steady after two months of improving conditions
After showing positive momentum during the fourth quarter of 2010, the Architecture Billings Index (ABI) slipped almost four points in January. The January ABI score was 50.0, which is down from a reading of 53.9 the previous month, but still reflects stable demand for design services. Any score above 50 indicates an increase in billings.
| Feb 22, 2011
LEED Volume Program celebrates its 500th certified Pilot Project
More than 500 building projects have certified through the LEED Volume Program since the pilot launched in 2006, according to the U.S. Green Building Council. The LEED Volume Program streamlines the certification process for high-volume property owners and managers, from commercial real estate firms, national retailers and hospitality providers, to local, state and federal governments.
| Feb 22, 2011
HDR Architecture names four healthcare directors
Four senior professionals in HDR Architecture’s healthcare program have been named Healthcare directors.
| Feb 15, 2011
Iconic TWA terminal may reopen as a boutique hotel
The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey hopes to squeeze a hotel with about 150 rooms in the space between the old TWA terminal and the new JetBlue building. The old TWA terminal would serve as an entry to the hotel and hotel lobby, which would also contain restaurants and shops.
| Feb 15, 2011
New Orleans' rebuilt public housing architecture gets mixed reviews
The architecture of New Orleans’ new public housing is awash with optimism about how urban-design will improve residents' lives—but the changes are based on the idealism of an earlier era that’s being erased and revised.
| Feb 15, 2011
LAUSD commissions innovative prefab prototypes for future building
The LA Unified School District, under the leadership of a new facilities director, reversed course regarding prototypes for its new schools and engaged architects to create compelling kit-of-parts schemes that are largely prefabricated.
| Feb 15, 2011
New 2030 Challenge to include carbon footprint of building materials and products
Architecture 2030 has just broadened the scope of its 2030 Challenge, issuing an additional challenge regarding the climate impact of building products. The 2030 Challenge for Products aims to reduce the embodied carbon (meaning the carbon emissions equivalent) of building products 50% by 2030.
| Feb 15, 2011
New Urbanist Andrés Duany: We need a LEED Brown rating
Andrés Duany advocates a "LEED Brown" rating that would give contractors credit for using traditional but low cost measures that are not easy to quantify or certify. He described these steps as "the original green," and "what we did when we didn't have money." Ostensibly, LEED Brown would be in addition to the current Silver, Gold and Platinum ratings.
