When evidence-based design collides with conventional wisdom, the outcome will sometimes be disruptive.
Take, for example, the generally accepted advantages in patient care and observation related to decentralizing nurses’ stations in hospitals, which is becoming standard practice for healthcare clients and their AEC partners.
A recent evaluation of a renovated Missouri hospital, conducted by University of Kansas faculty members, raised questions about the impact of decentralization on patient satisfaction and the communication among nursing teams within the facility.
The St. Louis-based architectural firm Lawrence Group retained the Institute for Health + Wellness Design (IHWD) at KU’s School of Architecture, Design, and Planning to provide a third-party review of the firm’s 2014 remodeling of the orthopedic unit at SSM St. Mary’s Hospital in Jefferson City. That healthcare system was about to embark on an expansion of its St. Joseph Hospital West in Lake St. Louis.
Lawrence Group is an affiliate member of IHWD.
The Institute assessed the unit using an evidence-based design checklist developed by the nonprofit Center for Health Design in California. Its survey included a “space syntax” evaluation that generated a heat map, which showed how the unit’s layout might affect patient satisfaction.
“We wanted to see does moving into a new facility improve patient satisfaction scores, which is one of the most important things for hospital owners today,” said Hui Cai, Assistant Professor at KU, who with Professor Kent Spreckelmeyer and Frank Zilm, IHWD’s chairman, presented findings from the Institute’s nursing unit study at the Healthcare Design Conference 2016 in Houston last November.
The study found, perhaps not surprisingly, that the facility itself showed “statistically significant increase[s]” in scores after the renovation. But patient-quality scores mostly stayed the same, and one score—nurses’ responses to patient calls—actually dropped slightly.
The Institute hypothesizes that decentralization was the culprit, due to the physical distance and visual disconnection of decentralized nursing unit design, which necessitates that nurses must move farther to get from station to station. The Institute suggests these distances might be an impediment to interaction among nurses that might also delay responses to patients.
“This design trend needs to be further investigated before it is accepted as standard for every hospital,” said Cai. “We have to see how to modify the design to achieve balance between shorter walking distance, better patient surveillance and better staff communication and collaboration.”
This is one of the first research studies to link decentralized nurse station design with organizational performance and patient outcomes. The Institute has conducted a second phase of study to evaluate further the degree to which decentralized design affects nurses’ teamwork and patients’ perception of care. In late 2017, IHWD plans to present and publish the results of this study, which included a second hospital, the University Medical Center of Princeton at Plainsboro, N.J.
Related Stories
| Mar 11, 2011
Renovation energizes retirement community in Massachusetts
The 12-year-old Edgewood Retirement Community in Andover, Mass., underwent a major 40,000-sf expansion and renovation that added 60 patient care beds in the long-term care unit, a new 17,000-sf, 40-bed cognitive impairment unit, and an 80-seat informal dining bistro.
| Mar 11, 2011
Research facility added to Texas Medical Center
Situated on the Texas Medical Center’s North Campus in Houston, the new Methodist Hospital Research Institute is a 12-story, 440,000-sf facility dedicated to translational research. Designed by New York City-based Kohn Pedersen Fox, with healthcare, science, and technology firm WHR Architects, Houston, the building has open, flexible labs, offices, and amenities for use by 90 principal investigators and 800 post-doc trainees and staff.
| Mar 11, 2011
Mixed-income retirement community in Maryland based on holistic care
The Green House Residences at Stadium Place in Waverly, Md., is a five-story, 40,600-sf, mixed-income retirement community based on a holistic continuum of care concept developed by Dr. Bill Thomas. Each of the four residential floors houses a self-contained home for 12 residents that includes 12 bedrooms/baths organized around a common living/social area called the “hearth,” which includes a kitchen, living room with fireplace, and dining area.
| Mar 3, 2011
HDR acquires healthcare design-build firm Cooper Medical
HDR, a global architecture, engineering and consulting firm, acquired Cooper Medical, a firm providing integrated design and construction services for healthcare facilities throughout the U.S. The new alliance, HDR Cooper Medical, will provide a full service design and construction delivery model to healthcare clients.
| Mar 1, 2011
New survey shows shifts in hospital construction projects
America’s hospitals and health systems are focusing more on renovation or expansion than new construction, according to a new survey conducted by Health Facilities Management magazine and the American Society for Healthcare Engineering (ASHE). In fact, renovation or expansion accounted for 73% of construction projects at hospitals responding to the survey.
| Feb 22, 2011
HDR Architecture names four healthcare directors
Four senior professionals in HDR Architecture’s healthcare program have been named Healthcare directors.
| Feb 17, 2011
HDR Architecture sponsors national effort to green operating rooms
HDR Architecture, Inc. has joined the group of corporate sponsors of Practice Greenhealth’s Greening the Operating Room Initiative. This sweeping and prescriptive path to green the nation’s operating rooms was launched earlier this year to reduce the environmental footprint of the operating suites in hospitals across the country, which can produce between 20 and 30% of a hospital’s total waste.
| Feb 11, 2011
Iowa surgery center addresses both inpatient and outpatient care
The 12,000-person community of Carroll, Iowa, has a new $28 million surgery center to provide both inpatient and outpatient care. Minneapolis-based healthcare design firm Horty Elving headed up the four-story, 120,000-sf project for St. Anthony’s Regional Hospital. The center’s layout is based on a circular process flow, and includes four 800-sf operating rooms with poured rubber floors to reduce leg fatigue for surgeons and support staff, two substerile rooms between each pair of operating rooms, and two endoscopy rooms adjacent to the outpatient prep and recovery rooms. Recovery rooms are clustered in groups of four. The large family lounge (left) has expansive windows with views of the countryside, and television monitors that display coded information on patient status so loved ones can follow a patient’s progress.
| Feb 11, 2011
Two projects seek to reinvigorate Los Angeles County medical center
HMC Architects designed two new buildings for the Los Angeles County Martin Luther King, Jr., Medical Center as part of a $360 million plan to reinvigorate the campus. The buildings include a 120-bed hospital, which involves renovation of an existing tower and several support buildings, and the construction of a new multi-service ambulatory care center. The new facilities will have large expanses of glass at all waiting and public areas for unobstructed views of downtown Los Angeles. A curved glass entrance canopy will unite the two buildings. When both projects are completed—the hospital in 2012 and the ambulatory care center in 2013—the campus will have added more than 460,000 sf of space. The hospital will seek LEED certification, while the ambulatory care center is targeting LEED Silver.