An estimated 140 million sf of shopping center space was built in the U.S. between 2002 and 2008, according ChainLinks Advisors’ Fall/Winter 2013 Retail Review & Forecast. Since then, retail construction has slowed, even as the U.S. remains the world’s largest market in shopping center space, accounting for two-thirds of total gross leasable area tracked by Cushman & Wakefield, according to its latest Global Shopping Center Development Report.
Retail net absorption totaled 109.8 million sf in 2014, according to JLL’s Fourth Quarter 2014 Retail Outlook. Last year exhibited the strongest absorption rate since 2008. But deliveries, at 60.6 million sf, still fell well below absorptions. JLL reported that 55% of last year’s construction activity was “general retail,” consisting of single-tenant freestanding general commercial buildings with parking. Shopping centers accounted for 19.2% of retail construction, malls 18.1%, power centers 4.4%, and specialty retail centers 3.3%.
New York, Miami, and Washington, D. C., showed the highest absorption rates and rent growth. Combined, they accounted for more than two million sf of storefront construction, or about 7% of the U.S. total last year.
Retailers could be doing a better job of meeting customer expectations. The latest American Customer Satisfaction Index, based on surveys of 70,000 customers, found that all retail categories, with the exception of online retail, showed weakening or flat customer satisfaction in 2014.
JLL cites a report by the Royal Bank of Canada and Retail Lease Trac, which estimates that U.S. retailers in RBC’s database plan to open a total of 77,547 stores over the next two years. Some of these stores might end up replacing retailers commonly found in malls that have announced hundreds of store closings, including Macy’s, JC Penney, and Sears, as well as Radio Shack and Wet Seal, both of which have filed for bankruptcy protection.
Retailers could be doing a better job of meeting customer expectations. The latest American Customer Satisfaction Index, based on surveys of 70,000 customers, found that all retail categories, with the exception of online retail, showed weakening or flat customer satisfaction in 2014.
Nordstrom, which is among the handful of retailers that mall developers covet most as anchors, registered the highest satisfaction index—86—of any brick-and-mortar dealer tracked, matching Amazon.com’s 86 index. However, department and discount stores registered their lowest index since 2007. ACSI data show that customers were dissatisfied with their layouts, cleanliness, inventory availability, and speed of checkout.
JLL suggests that malls and shopping centers are more effective as destinations when their tenant mix appeals to customers’ lifestyles beyond shopping and includes fitness centers, gourmet cooking shops, and sustainable-product options.
The success of any mall redevelopment hinges on the appeal of its tenants. JLL singles out Nordstrom, Neiman Marcus, and fashion retailers H&M and Forever 21 as “huge draws.” It also notes that entertainment is “essential” to injecting “new vitality” into a shopping center. This can include casual restaurants like Chipolte or Smashburger, luxury movie theaters like iPic, or specialty big boxes like Dick’s Field & Stream.
JLL recommends that as malls reinvent themselves, they should add more green space, lounging areas, and free WiFi. Technology tools like beacons (see www.BDCnetwork.com/beacon) can help a retail center connect more directly with customers. “By tracking the location of shoppers and interacting with them through their mobile devices, landlords and retailers gain greater control over the timing and customization of their marketing messages,” says JLL.
Related Stories
Market Data | Apr 13, 2017
2016’s top 10 states for commercial development
Three new states creep into the top 10 while first and second place remain unchanged.
Mixed-Use | Apr 7, 2017
North Hollywood mixed-use development NoHo West begins construction
The development is expected to open in 2018.
Urban Planning | Mar 31, 2017
4 important things to consider when designing streets for people, not just cars
For the most part what you see is streets that have been designed with the car in mind—at a large scale for a fast speed.
Retail Centers | Mar 23, 2017
The retail renaissance part I: How architecture will shape the future of shopping
The retail sector is charting unfamiliar territory as web sales and evolving tastes force a paradigm shift. In our Retail Renaissance blog series, architects, interior designers, planners and engineers from different GS&P markets will consider the impact of retail trends and discuss how clients and developers can successfully navigate this new age of shopping.
Retail Centers | Mar 21, 2017
A giant ‘show pool’ is the highlight of a new food- and entertainment-centric mall in Turkey's largest metro
WaterGarden Istanbul hopes to attract 15 million visitors a year.
Retail Centers | Mar 9, 2017
When everyone shops online, what happens to mixed-use retail?
NBBJ’s David Yuan explains how changing retail trends are creating new opportunities for urban experiences and public space.
Retail Centers | Mar 7, 2017
Five facets of successful retail that further social connection
What’s driving experiential retail in 2017 and beyond?
Retail Centers | Jan 24, 2017
Sensational shopping: Retail and the emotional connection
CallisonRTKL's Bret Wiggins discusses how to design the retail environment in a way that taps into the shopper psyche.
Retail Centers | Dec 23, 2016
Wayfinding trends: Modern digital signage caters to personal tastes and profiles of shoppers
Applications like Bluetooth-driven Beacon systems and cellular Wi-Fi systems can now be used to help people navigate space in a more profound way, writes CallisonRTKL’s Cody Clark.
Architects | Nov 20, 2016
D.C.’s first distillery-eatery taps into a growing trend
The stylish location targets customers craving craft spirits and late-night dining.