Situated on a tiny, quarter-acre lot along bustling University Avenue, Berkeley, Calif.’s, new West Branch library may not be large in stature, but it’s one of the most significant library projects of the year.
Due to open in August, the 9,500-sf facility will join a handful of libraries across the country that are net-zero energy performers. And, if all goes as planned, the facility will achieve net-positive energy performance—supplying power back to the city’s electrical grid—and have a carbon-neutral footprint.
The project’s Building Team, led by Harley Ellis Devereaux’s GreenWorks Studio (www.harleyellisdevereaux.com), is targeting LEED Platinum. The $5.5 million library is one of the first projects to take part in the California Public Utility Commission’s ZNE Energy Pilot Program, supported by the Pacific Gas and Electric Co.
Michael Bulander, LEED AP BD+C, Associate with Harley Ellis Devereaux, says the PG&E partnership was critical to achieving NZE performance on the West Branch project. The utility subsidized early computer modeling work, including computational fluid dynamics analysis of ventilation schemes and a solar axis study for the rooftop solar installations.
The latter was especially tricky, says Bulander, due to the project’s tight urban site. “The starting point for the entire design was actually the building’s roof,” he says. “Because taller buildings surround the tiny site—including a three-story hotel next door—the team had to determine the optimal roof configuration for accommodating as many PV and solar thermal panels as possible, and for minimizing shading from the other buildings.”
Projected Energy Performance
Renewable energy generation
Photovoltaic panels 15.4 kBtu/sf/year
Solar thermal panels 2.0 kBtu/sf/year
Total power generation 17.4 kBtu/sf/year
Building electrical load
Lighting 3.8 kBtu/sf/year
Heating 3.5 kBtu/sf/year
Cooling (heat pumps) 2.2 kBtu/sf/year
Plug load 6.3 kBtu/sf/year
Hot water 0.9 kBtu/sf/year
Ventilation fans 0.7 kBtu/sf/year
Total power load 17.4 kBtu/sf/year
Net energy consumption 0.0 kBtu/sf/year
The rooftop solar panels also had to compete for space with three rows of skylights that were instrumental to the building’s daylighting scheme. And, of course, the roof configuration had to meet the programmatic requirements for the library.
“It was a real balancing act,” says Gerard Lee, AIA, LEED AP, Associate and Project Manager with Harley Ellis Devereaux. “We had to find the sweet spot between what the building wanted to be from a program standpoint and what it should be from an energy-performance standpoint.”
Through modeling, the design team determined that the optimal design consisted of a compact, rectangular roof, 24 feet high. The solar panels are oriented horizontally, stacked three high at a 20-degree angle to maximize solar collection throughout the year. Four PV arrays are interspersed between three rows of skylights. A total of 120 panels will generate 75,050 kWh/year with a final system efficiency of 93.8%. The 16 solar thermal panels are located in two arrays at the northeast corner of the roof.
“The design takes into consideration the skylight locations and heights,” says Lee. “The PV panels are angled and located to avoid casting shadows on the skylights, and the same can be said for the skylights.”
The team modeled the design to maximize the number of solar panels that could be installed on the compact roof. The photovoltaic and solar thermal panels were situated so as not to interfere with the three rows of skylights.
Once the roof design scheme was established and the team could accurately calculate the amount of solar energy that would be harvested, they went about designing the building to minimize the energy use intensity to match the renewable energy supply.
“Our EUI is very low in relation to other projects—just 17 kBtu/sf/year,” says Bulander. For comparison, the average office building has a EUI of 193; hospitals can exceed 500.
Passive design requires careful modeling, detailing
Passive design strategies like natural ventilation, radiant heating/cooling, and daylighting helped meet the aggressive energy goals. Prevailing winds off the Bay made natural ventilation a logical approach, but the site proved problematic yet again. Because the building is located in a high-traffic area next to a stoplight, placing operable windows in the main façade was not feasible. “Trucks often wait at the red light in front of the building,” says Bulander. “We needed to block that out.”
To minimize energy consumption in the building, the design scheme utilizes daylighting through a series of skylights and a large glass curtain wall on the main façade. Where possible, the team minimized the amount of electrical lighting in the building, such as in the back office areas. When the library closes for the day, the entire facility will essentially go dark to reduce energy use.
With the help of CFD modeling, the design team devised a clever natural ventilation scheme that uses negative pressure to pull in fresh air at the rear of the building and then circulate it through the interior spaces.
“We’re essentially using the steady wind that is blowing over the top of the front façade to create a negative pressure that pulls the air through the building,” says Lee. A series of louvers and ventilation fans at the roof level will exhaust the warm air as needed, and radiant flooring will provide supplemental heating and cooling. A building automation system will monitor and control the entire process, ensuring that the interior climate remains comfortable for the staff and patrons.
“We’re trying to make the facility as automated and foolproof as possible,” says Lee. He says the BAS will allow staff to override certain settings—such as closing an operable window on an unusually windy day—but it will automatically revert to its programmed settings at the end of the day. “For the most part, it’s a very intelligent building that needs very little interference from the librarians and staffers.”
As with any net-zero building project, plug loads are a major concern for the Building Team. Library patrons will notice a dearth of outlets in the new facility. This is meant to minimize the number of people who plug in their energy-gobbling laptops, smart phones, and tablets. The library will offer free computer and Internet access for visitors, but in lieu of desktops that are plugged in all day, users will be able to check out fully charged laptops. A charging station will allow the staff to track and control the amount of energy being consumed by the computers.
Lee and Bulander are fully confident that the library staff and patrons will embrace the resource conservation efforts. A building performance dashboard will greet all visitors at the main entrance, providing a real-time snapshot of the building’s energy production and energy/water consumption.
“We’re taking advantage of the ‘Prius effect,’” says Bulander. “When you see a display showing how much energy and water you’re using, you feel more involved in trying to minimize it. It becomes a game.”
The building’s natural ventilation scheme involves pulling in outdoor air from the rear of the building and circulating it throughout the interior spaces. A series of louvers and fans at the roof level will exhaust the air as needed.
PROJECT SUMMARY
Berkeley Public Library – West Branch
Berkeley, Calif.
BUILDING TEAM
Client: City of Berkeley, Calif.
Architect, sustainability consultant, commissioning agent: Harley Ellis Devereaux, GreenWorks Studio
General contractor: West Bay Builders
MEP engineer: Harley Ellis Devereaux
Structural engineer: Tipping Mar
Civil engineer: Moran Engineering
Landscape architect: John Northmore Roberts and Associates
Cost estimator: Cumming Corp.
GENERAL INFORMATION
Size: 9,500 sf
Cost: $5.5 million (est.)
Completion: August 2013
Related Stories
| Dec 17, 2013
CBRE's Chris Bodnar and Lee Asher named Healthcare Real Estate Executives of the Year
CBRE Group, Inc. announced today that two of its senior executives, Chris Bodnar and Lee Asher, have been named Healthcare Real Estate Executives of the Year by Healthcare Real Estate Insights.
| Dec 16, 2013
Is the metal building industry in a technology shift?
Automation is the future you can’t avoid, though you may try. Even within the metal building industry—which is made up of skilled tradesmen—automation has revolutionized, and will continue revolutionizing, how we work.
| Dec 16, 2013
Why employees don’t trust their leaders
Trust, one of the key elements to productive business relationships, is in short supply these days. An Associated Press-GfK poll discovered that only one-third of Americans say most people can be trusted and nearly two-thirds says “you can’t be too careful” in dealing with people.
| Dec 16, 2013
Construction materials prices remain stable in November
Overall, construction materials prices fell 0.5 percent in November and are up only 1.1 percent year over year, according to the Department of Labor’s Dec. 13 Producer Price Index.
| Dec 16, 2013
Helene Combs Dreiling, FAIA, inaugurated 2014 AIA President
Helene Combs Dreiling, FAIA, executive director of the Virginia Center for Architecture, was inaugurated as the 90th president of the American Institute of Architects (AIA) during ceremonies held on December 12th at the Andrew W. Mellon Auditorium. She succeeds Mickey Jacob, FAIA, in representing nearly 83,000 AIA members.
| Dec 13, 2013
GRW acquires West Virginia design firm Chapman Technical Group
GRW is expanding its capabilities through the recent acquisition of Chapman Technical Group, a 36-person West Virginia-based firm.
| Dec 13, 2013
AIA, MIT issue joint report on impact of design on public health
The research looks at the health of eight U.S. cities and lays out a path for translating the research into meaningful findings for policy makers and urban planners.
| Dec 11, 2013
Wyndham unveils hotel prototype for its Hawthorn Suites chain
The extended-stay hotel prototype reduces development costs by 46% for franchisees and enhances the overall guest experience.
| Dec 10, 2013
16 great solutions for architects, engineers, and contractors
From a crowd-funded smart shovel to a why-didn’t-someone-do-this-sooner scheme for managing traffic in public restrooms, these ideas are noteworthy for creative problem-solving. Here are some of the most intriguing innovations the BD+C community has brought to our attention this year.
| Dec 9, 2013
Tips for designing higher education's newest building type: the learning commons
In this era of scaled-down budgets, maximized efficiencies, new learning methods and social media’s domination of face time, college and university campuses are gravitating toward a new space type: the learning commons.