When residents of San Francisco’s Millennium Tower plunked down the cash (sometimes as much as $10 million) to live the 58-story building, they were probably expecting their new home to be packed with amenities and luxuries to make their lives as easy as possible. But the odds are, what they weren’t expecting was the need to question whether or not their new living arrangements were safe. But that is exactly what many residents are beginning to do after the tower has sunk 16 inches since its completion in 2009. The tower has also tilted by two inches at the base and about 6 inches at the top.
According to sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com, a spokesman for Millennium Partners, the building’s developer, says some sinking was expected, but the 16 inches is almost three times more than what was originally predicted. Even so, the spokesman says the seismic performance has not been affected and the leaning and sinking does not represent a safety risk.
Millennium Partners is blaming the issue on the Transbay Joint Powers Authority, saying the construction of their new rail terminal is to blame. To build the terminal, Transbay dug a 60-foot hole to create a dry construction site and pumped out millions of gallons of groundwater, which compressed and weakened the soil under Millennium Tower.
Transbay Joint Powers Authority, however, is pointing the finger back at Millennium Partners, saying the building had already sunk 10 inches before construction on the terminal even began. They say the real reason for the issue is due to Millennium Partners cutting corners to save money. Instead of driving piles about 200 feet down into bedrock, they were instead driven 60 to 90 feet down into dense sand. The transit authority released a statement saying the building would not be tilting today if it had been anchored to bedrock.
Millennium Partners spokesman says the building was built correctly and other buildings in the area, such as the Intercontinental and St. Regis hotels, have similar foundations.
While safety is a major concern to residents, many are also worried about the issue affecting property values. To this point, the cracks that have appeared in the walls due to the building settling have all appeared in the parking garage, and no damage has occurred to any of the units.
*Update* (Feb. 6, 2017)
Over the past few months, things have certainly not gotten any better for the ailing tower or its frsutrated residents. According to experts that have continued to do site inspections, Millennium Tower is still safe to live in, but that hasn't stopped a group of more than 20 residents from filing multiple lawsuits against Millennium Partners, the City of San Francisco, and the Transbay Joint Powers Authority (TJPA).
According to the Denver Post, the 20 or so residents, who collectively paid around $75 million for their condos, allege that Millennium Partners knew the building had sunk 8.3 inches into the ground as early as 2009, just one year after the building was completed. Furthermore, they believe Millennium Partners hid the building’s faulty structure from buyers, saying the city’s administrators also helped to conceal the engineering flaws. Both Millennium Partners and the city deny the allegations.
The TJPA has also been named in the residents’ suit due to the construction of the new rail terminal. If the TJPA is found to be at fault, San Francisco taxpayers may find themselves on the hook for covering the building’s repair costs. The TJPA has also denied the allegations.
Another development has arisen that may add to the collective headache of Millennium Tower residents. As the Denver Post reports, Millennium Partners is insured to cover around $100 million in damages caused by settlement or construction defects with the policy split among several insurers. The building’s architect, structural engineer, and general contractor hold ancillary policies worth another $50 million to $100 million. The problem is, rectifying the problems plaguing the ailing tower could cost much more than that amount.
And if that isn’t bad enough, the coverage may not even be available under the liability policy. There is a possibility coverage has been voided by the flaws in the building.
As the building continues to lean and responsibility for the failure continues to get passed around, any possible solutions for Millennium Tower grow more and more complicated.
Related Stories
| Aug 25, 2014
Tall wood buildings: Surveying the early innovators
Timber has been largely abandoned as a structural solution in taller buildings during the last century, in favor of concrete and steel. Perkins+Will's Rebecca Holt writes about the firm's work in surveying the burgeoning tall wood buildings sector.
| Aug 25, 2014
'Vanity space' makes up large percentage of world's tallest buildings [infographic]
Large portions of some skyscrapers are useless space used to artificially enhance their height, according to the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat.
| Aug 25, 2014
Photographer creates time-lapse video of 1 WTC using 30,000 photos
Choosing from 30,000 photos he took from the day construction began in 2006 to the day when construction was finished in 2012, Brooklyn-based photographer Benjamin Rosamund compressed 1,100 photos to create the two-minute video.
| Aug 19, 2014
Goettsch Partners unveils design for mega mixed-use development in Shenzhen [slideshow]
The overall design concept is of a complex of textured buildings that would differentiate from the surrounding blue-glass buildings of Shenzhen.
| Aug 15, 2014
First look: RMJM’s 'jumping fish' tower design for the Chinese Riviera
The tower's fish-jumping gesture is meant to symbolize the prosperity and rapid transformation of Zhuhai, China.
| Aug 12, 2014
Shading prototype could allow new levels of environmental control for skyscraper occupants
Developed by architects at NBBJ, Sunbreak uses a unique three-hinged shade that morphs from an opaque shutter to an abstract set of vertical blinds to an awning, depending on what is needed.
| Aug 6, 2014
Vegetated residential tower breaks ground in Taiwan
With vegetated balconies reaching the full height of the 100-meter tower, the One More residential development aims to establish a relationship between its residents and nature.
| Aug 5, 2014
New bomb-proof concrete mixture used in One World Trade Center
The new concrete mix deforms instead of breaking, removing the threat of flying debris in an explosive attack.
| Jul 30, 2014
Wolf Point high-rise development begins construction in Chicago
Designed by Pelli Clarke Pelli Architects, the 48-story luxury residential tower is part of a three-tower mixed-use development along the Chicago River.
| Jul 24, 2014
High-rise 'slum' in Venezuela to be shuttered
Authorities have decided to move 4,400 squatters out of Venezuela's third-tallest skyscraper, allegedly to investigate the structural soundness of the tower.
