Cities and suburbs all over the country face the same problem: not enough affordable housing for their own police, firefighters, EMTs, teachers, and lower-level administrative staff in schools and government agencies. C. Kat Grimsley, PhD, has a suggestion: If your school district is building a new school, build housing in the air space above it and put lower-paid public employees at the front of the line to live there, at subsidized rental rates.
Grimsley, who directs the master’s in real estate program at George Mason University, won a competition for best paper from RCLCO Real Estate Advisors for this idea. She tested her theory out using the third-largest school district in Virginia, Loudoun County, where the Area Median Income is $134,464, but where there’s a need for 10,000 affordable rental units for families.
Her scheme envisions a three-story concrete school at the base topped by a three-story wood-framed apartment building. (Such a configuration would meet most local fire codes for wood buildings.) This could yield 42 one-bedroom units (for, say, young single teachers or EMTs making almost nothing), and six each of two- and three-bedroom apartments for families, for a total of 54. The mix could be juggled depending on local needs.
There's a lot to like about this idea. First, land costs for the residential structure would go down to zero, or there could be some cost sharing with the school district. But still a bargain. The school district would already be paying to bring in utilities to the site, so that would be another savings for the apartment portion of the project. The scheme would also step around the “taking issue,” since any land that the school district acquired through eminent domain would be primarily for a public purpose (building the school), not a private one.
Parking could be shared. The school would get use of the parking lot from, say, 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. on school days; the residents could use it after 4 and at night.
Teachers could roll out of bed in the morning and take the elevator to school (there would be separate elevators and entrances for the school and residences). Police, firefighters, EMTs, and school maintenance staff could live in the same town where they work, instead of having to live in a more distant town where the housing is more reasonably priced.
Grimsley focused on using her scheme for new school construction, but the real payoff would come with using existing schools. Loudoun County, for example, has more than 90 education facilities for its 81,622 students. Building in the air rights over an active K-6 would be difficult to impossible, of course. But what about that ground-level parking lot? Could it be converted to structured parking (at school district cost) with housing above? That would be a piece of cake for any builder. School districts need to look into their real estate portfolios to see if there’s land on school properties that could be turned into housing.
Sure, Grimsley’s modest proposal needs more work, but something tells me there’s a brilliant idea here. Do you agree? Disagree? Send me your thoughts at the email below.
Related Stories
Market Data | Feb 24, 2021
2021 won’t be a growth year for construction spending, says latest JLL forecast
Predicts second-half improvement toward normalization next year.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 23, 2021
Rising costs push developers to consider modular construction
The mainstreaming of modular construction offers a cost-effective and creative solution to develop new types of urban developments.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 21, 2021
Multifamily Amenities Survey 2021: Early results show COVID-19 impact on apartment amenities
Survey of multifamily developers, owners, architects, and contractors shows many adjusting their amenities to deal with the impact of the pandemic on property occupiers.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 19, 2021
Former motorcycle factory converted into affordable housing
The Architectural Team designed the project.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 12, 2021
Benefits of a factory-installed ceiling radiation damper explained
Greenheck applications engineer Craig Kulski explains the benefits of a factory-installed ceiling radiation damper.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 10, 2021
The Weekly show, Feb 11, 2021: Advances in fire protection engineering, and installing EV ports in multifamily housing
This week on The Weekly show, BD+C editors speak with AEC industry leaders from Bozzuto Management Company and Goldman Copeland about advice on installing EV ports in multifamily housing, and advances in fire protection engineering.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 10, 2021
10 significant multifamily developments to open in late 2020 and early 2021
Seattle's new twisting condo tower and Rem Koolhaas's first residential building are among 10 notable multifamily housing projects to debut in late 2020 and early 2021.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 8, 2021
Vista Railing Systems expands its senior management team
Chris Dooley and Tom Killy join Vista Railings, the British Columbia manufacturer of commercial/multifamily railings.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 8, 2021
Veterans Village supplies 51 units of supportive housing for U.S. military veterans in Carson, Calif.
Withee Malcolm Architects designed the supportive housing community for developer Thomas Safran & Associates.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 2, 2021
Tahanan supportive housing development brings 145 apartments to San Francisco
David Baker Architects designed the project.