Natural disasters that have devastated Puerto Rico over the past few years—at least 160,000 homes were destroyed by Hurricane Maria in September 2017, and another 30,000 were damaged by Hurricane Dorian last August, to say nothing of the damage caused by a 6.4-magnitude earthquake that shook the island last month—exposed the longstanding deficiencies in the commonwealth’s construction practices.
Close to half of Puerto Rico’s housing has been built—and continues to be built—“informally,” meaning that owners didn’t get permits, didn’t hire a licensed architect, and in all likelihood didn’t build to code.
With the island in need of between 60,000 and 90,000 new housing units by 2023, the question before Puerto Rico’s leaders and citizens is whether rebuilding and renovation will take safety and resilience more seriously.
“The problem is not the codes, which are equal or similar to what’s followed in the U.S.,” explains Ricardo Alvarez-Diaz, founder and chairman of Alvarez-Diaz & Villalón, the island’s largest architecture firm. He is also a member of the Construction Council of Puerto Rico. “The problem is the implementation of the codes and their enforcement.”
He says more rigorous enforcement will require a change in cultural mindset among the island’s residents for whom “informal” construction has been a way of life, and a girding of political will among politicians who too often turn a blind eye to illegal construction every election cycle.
The situation in Puerto Rico is complicated by many factors, not the least of which being that the laws mandate that licensed architects and contractors take full responsibility for code enforcement. But because Puerto Rican contractors don’t need licenses to operate, the onus of code enforcement falls squarely on the architects, whose liability insurance premiums are second only to doctors', says Alvarez-Diaz.
He notes, however, that there’s been a “big push” to require contractors to be licensed, which he believes could happen later this year.
Homeownership in Puerto Rico, at around 70%, is higher than in the U.S. But that ownership rate, says Alvarez-Diaz, is a double-edged sword because owners that have paid off their mortgages typically don’t carry insurance, or are less educated about the benefits of hiring professionals for rebuilding or remodeling.
What’s changing the island’s attitudes about following building codes, however, have been mandates by the Federal Emergency Management Administration (FEMA), and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) that federal funding for rebuilding is contingent on more rigorous code enforcement.
This is nothing new: FEMA and HUD imposed similar requirements after Hurricane Andrew wiped out parts of Florida in 1992 and exposed shoddy construction and, in some markets, nonexistent code enforcement.
Puerto Rico desperately needs the U.S. government’s money. A few years back the island’s Governor’s office estimated that rebuilding what Hurricane Maria destroyed would cost at least $31 billion, well beyond the means of a financially precarious commonwealth whose poverty rate hovers around 44%.
Currently, the government evaluates properties to determine whether they are worth rebuilding or if their residents need to relocate. And one of the criteria for those determinations is whether the building is in an existing flood plain. “FEMA has made it clear, as has the government, about not wanting to rebuild in flood plains,” says Alvarez-Diaz. HUD’s CDBG-DR funding allow for building above flood plain levels, but the ultimate decision lies with Puerto Rico’s Housing Authority.
Alvarez-Diaz cites estimates that more than 73,000 housing units, out of the 250,000 affected by recent storms, might need to be moved to higher ground, and that only about 35,000 units are in good enough condition to be rebuilt or elevated.
So what’s the alternative? One solution could be urban densification. Alvarez-Diaz says that only recently have Puerto Ricans become more receptive to renting as opposed to owning. That change of heart might also be motivated by the government issuing Section 8 vouchers that can be used for rental housing.
Bayshore Villas is a mixed-use complex that offers 170 rental apartments that range in size from 600 to 1400 sf.
For the past several years, Alvarez-Diaz’s firm has been trying to bring more affordable rental housing to the island. Its first big project was Renaissance Square, a 170-unit building that is Puerto Rico’s first mixed-income public housing development, and the island’s first Energy Star-rated project. Renaissance Square was approved in 2014, started in 2017, delayed by the storms, and completed last year.
Alvarez-Diaz & Villalón has two similar projects on the island. Bayshore Villas, located on the former Puerta de Tierra public housing project near Old San Juan, offers 174 rental units ranging from 600 to 1,400 sf, more than 5,800 sf of commercial space, and 6,000 sf for community and administrative uses. Last May, construction began on the Jose Gautier Benitez development in Caguas, P.R. This 21-acre development is divided into six residential blocks, and will include 438 one- and two-bedroom apartments as well as a five-story elderly housing facility. This building should be completed next year.
Alvarez-Diaz says the success of Renaissance Square has gotten his firm work in Texas, Florida, and the Virgin Islands.
Related Stories
Multifamily Housing | Jun 13, 2018
Multifamily visionaries: KTGY’s extraordinary expectations
KTGY Architecture + Planning keeps pushing the boundaries of multifamily housing design in the U.S., Asia, and the Middle East.
| May 30, 2018
Accelerate Live! talk: An AEC giant’s roadmap for integrating design, manufacturing, and construction
In this 15-minute talk at BD+C’s Accelerate Live! conference (May 10, 2018, Chicago), Skender CEO Mark Skender and Chief Design Officer Tim Swanson present the construction giant’s vision for creating a manufacturing-minded, vertically-integrated design-manufacturing-build business model.
| May 30, 2018
Accelerate Live! talk: From micro schools to tiny houses: What’s driving the downsizing economy?
In this 15-minute talk at BD+C’s Accelerate Live! conference (May 10, 2018, Chicago), micro-buildings design expert Aeron Hodges, AIA, explores the key drivers of the micro-buildings movement, and how the trend is spreading into a wide variety of building typologies.
Codes and Standards | May 30, 2018
Silicon Valley cities considering taxes aimed at large employers
The aim is to offset the impact on housing costs and homelessness by tech companies.
Multifamily Housing | May 30, 2018
Concentrated redevelopment: Apartment complex takes mixed use to the next level
An “intergenerational” mixed-use apartment complex may be a prototype for reenergizing neglected neighborhoods in America’s largest county.
| May 24, 2018
Accelerate Live! talk: Security and the built environment: Insights from an embassy designer
In this 15-minute talk at BD+C’s Accelerate Live! conference (May 10, 2018, Chicago), embassy designer Tom Jacobs explores ways that provide the needed protection while keeping intact the representational and inspirational qualities of a design.
BD+C University Course | May 24, 2018
Building passively [AIA course]
17 tips from our experts on the best way to carry out passive house design and construction for your next multifamily project. This AIA CES course is worth 1.0 AIA LU/HSW.
Multifamily Housing | May 23, 2018
Yankee Dandies: Century-old New England mills become multifamily residences
Having long outlived their original uses, two century-old New England mills have become valuable community assets once again—as multifamily residences.
Multifamily Housing | May 16, 2018
Pampering the pups: Why dog-washing stations are a must-have in multifamily developments
Self-serve dog-washing stations are reinforcing strong bonds between multifamily residents and their beloved canines.
Mixed-Use | May 16, 2018
Los Angeles mixed-use building uses prefabricated wood frame to reduce costs
SPF:architects designed the building.