A new study released by the Mayor’s office shows that New York City is making great strides in identifying energy wasted from its largest source of climate change pollution: its buildings.
The report provides information on energy performance of the city’s largest buildings (mostly commercial, multi-family residential). It provides an analysis of 2011 data from city-required energy “benchmarking”—or the tracking and comparison of energy performance—in more than 24,000 buildings that are over 50,000 square feet.
This report is a follow-up to one the city released in 2012. Last year’s report was remarkable in that it gave an initial glimpse into how New York City’s buildings use energy. This year’s report is the first time that such a rich two-year dataset has ever been available for comparative analysis. Now we can really begin to see trends and to pose new questions.
Along with this year’s report, the city is also releasing detailed disclosure data for the city’s largest multi-family residential buildings (meaning residents can actually look up their building’s address and find its energy usage information). This is not only the first time New York City has done that – but the first time any city in the country has made this kind of detailed information publicly available for large multi-family buildings. It will be joined within a few years by Chicago and Washington, DC. Just as we read nutrition labels or compare MPG when buying a car, millions of New Yorkers now have transparent information about their apartment buildings’ energy use. (For more information on what this data reveals about these multi-family buildings, check out this blog from the folks at the Institute for Market Transformation.)
Why does any of this matter? According to the City’s most recent inventory, 74% of citywide greenhouse gas emissions come from the energy used in its buildings. And of that, more than half comes from energy used in just 2% of the largest properties. Those 2% are required to benchmark and disclose their energy use in accordance with a city law that is designed to cut emissions citywide (30% by 2030). By tracking and disclosing this information on building energy performance, we can better understand the problem and how to fix it. This can help reduce climate change pollution and lower buildings’ energy bills.
Today’s report is a testament to New York City’s leadership in embracing benchmarking as a means to improving energy efficiency and combating climate change. And this report offers the largest-ever collection of benchmarking data for a single jurisdiction in the nation – providing more information on building energy use than 7 other cities that are tracking this information combined (Austin, Boston, Minneapolis, Philadelphia, San Francisco, Seattle, and DC).
Here’s a quick overview of this new report’s top findings:
- NYC’s buildings are more efficient than the national average – although their efficiency seems to be quite similar to buildings in the Northeast. This could be that buildings in the Northeast, including NYC, are generally older and more solidly built in comparison to the rest of the U.S. (It may surprise some to know that older NYC office buildings, for example, tend to be more efficient than new office construction has been in recent years.) Another factor might be that NYC’s buildings are more intensively used, both in terms of occupant density and operating hours. To be able to fairly compare similar buildings across the country, the ENERGY STAR rating takes key drivers of energy consumption in different building types into account. These include operational characteristics (like the number of workers and hours of use) and weather (warmer or cooler climates). This information is helping show the City where to best focus its efforts when boosting energy efficiency.
- Not all NYC buildings are created equal. NYC buildings that are home to retail businesses showed a huge range in energy intensity – think large chain stores vs. your mom-and-pop shops. The most energy-intensive retail buildings used five times more energy per square foot than the least intensive users. Meanwhile, multifamily residential buildings showed only a small variation in energy consumption between the most and least intensive users. These findings are intriguing and point to the opportunity for energy conservation programs aimed at different building uses and types.
- The city’s median ENERGY STAR score increased from 64 to 67. ENERGY STAR is the standard benchmark used by jurisdictions across the country to rate the efficiency of their buildings. This is a trend that we should watch in future reports to determine whether there is a true increase in NYC building efficiency -- especially as the impacts of Greener, Greater Buildings Plan laws kick in over the next few years.
In addition to identifying these broad takeaways from the raw data, the report draws attention to a couple of excellent local benchmarking success stories—one commercial office building, and one multi-family residential property. These stories show how the city’s benchmarking program is helping to save building owners money and reduce climate change pollution in each sector.
Commercial Building Benchmarking Success Story: 5 Penn Plaza
The benchmarking process allowed building managers at 5 Penn Plaza—a typical large office building in Manhattan—to identify how much energy they were using and uncover opportunities to reduce their usage. As a result, they have taken strides to improve their efficiency. This includes upgrading common area lighting, installing occupancy sensors in restrooms, putting timers on hot water heaters to prevent excess usage during periods of vacancy, installing pipe insulation, installing a boiler efficiency module, and installing efficient lighting and occupancy sensors during the fit-out of a new full floor tenant. As a result, they have saved money and reduced their fuel oil use by 25%, qualified for special ENERGY STAR recognition, and decreased their overall energy intensity by 5%.
Residential Building Benchmarking Success Story: 250 Cabrini Boulevard
Due to building upgrades identified in an energy audit, 250 Cabrini Boulevard—a 77-unit coop in Manhattan—is saving almost $11,000 a year in operational costs and has lowered its maintenance expenses. One of the improvements included a new boiler control that responds to interior apartment and outdoor temperatures. Not only are the residents are more comfortable, but their coop is saving money. Even though the latest round of reported benchmarking data includes only a few months of usage after the upgrades it shows that the building saw a 6% reduction in its fuel oil consumption. And, the latest data is showing that they managed to reduce their further heating fuel usage by 21% over the entire 2011-2012 heating season.
NYC’s benchmarking law is helping to shepherd in a new era of energy awareness and improvement. And, because the City also requires that buildings disclose their benchmarking scores, owners can compare their buildings to their peers’. This awareness can help building tenants, operators and businesses uncover major energy savings while unlocking market-driven demand for energy-efficiency products and local skilled workers.
It is no wonder that nine major U.S. cities have adopted similar policies as the basis for their efforts to reduce the huge amount of wasted energy in America’s existing buildings. Which cities are next?
Related Stories
| Jan 3, 2012
AIA Course: New Developments in Concrete Construction
Earn 1.0 AIA/CES learning units by studying this article and successfully completing the online exam.
| Jan 3, 2012
The Value of Historic Paint Investigations
An expert conservator provides a three-step approach to determining a historic building’s “period of significance”—and how to restore its painted surfaces to the correct patterns and colors.
| Jan 3, 2012
28th Annual Reconstruction Awards: Bringing Hope to Cancer Patients
A gothic-style structure is reconstructed into comfortable, modern patient residence facility for the American Cancer Society.
| Jan 3, 2012
Art Gensler: Still Making a Difference for Clients Every Day
After running what is today the largest architecture firm in the world for more than four decades, M. Arthur Gensler, Jr., FAIA, FIIDA, RIBA, is content to be just another employee at the firm that bears his name.
| Jan 3, 2012
Gensler: 'The One Firm Firm'
The giant architecture firm succeeds by giving each of its more than 3,000 employees the opportunity for career growth and professional leadership.
| Jan 3, 2012
Rental Renaissance, The Rebirth of the Apartment Market
Across much of the U.S., apartment rents are rising, vacancy rates are falling. In just about every major urban area, new multifamily rental projects and major renovations are coming online. It may be too soon to pronounce the rental market fully recovered, but the trend is promising.
| Dec 29, 2011
OSHA enforcing new fall hazard standards
OSHA is enforcing its new fall protection standards, as evidenced by a recent crackdown in New York.
| Dec 29, 2011
Decision not to fireproof the new World Trade Center Transportation Hub criticized
Some criticized the decision, reasoning that the structure could be a terrorist target.
| Dec 29, 2011
Seismic safety in question at thousands of California public schools
California regulators responsible for enforcing earthquake safety laws have failed to certify more than 16,000 construction projects in California public schools, increasing the risk that some projects may be unsafe, according to a state audit report.
| Dec 29, 2011
GreenWizard offers cloud-based LEED credit management, assessment
The company recently began offering companies the ability to run assessments for design credits, in addition to traditional product-specific LEED credits.