“This isn’t the end of office. This is merely survival of the fittest.”
So concludes Frank Petz, Office Lead-U.S. Capital Markets for Colliers International, about the viability and efficacy of office conversions, in a new white paper on the topic released jointly by Colliers and the architecture, design and planning firm SGA.
The white paper is in the form of a Q&A, with Colliers’ Director of National Capital Markets Research Aaron Jodka interviewing Petz and Maren Reepmeyer, AIA, LEED AP, Vice President with SGA, about what is likely to become of the current glut of vacant office space in markets around the country.
Along with the white paper, SGA and Colliers have produced an Office Conversion Compatibility Chart that breaks down 14 building types by structural considerations, MEP/FP infrastructure considerations, code considerations, envelope considerations, and servicing/operational considerations.
For example, if a developer wants to convert an office building into a space for life science research or labs, the Chart contends that the developer or owner needs to consider the building’s structural grid layout constraints, slab and roof capacity (150 pounds per sf), vibration criteria (4 MIPS+), floor-to-floor heights (15 ft minimum), slab penetrations for MEP/FP shafts, vertical additions for a mechanical penthouse and/or screening, increased air exchange (10 cubic ft per minute minimum), HVAC redistribution, individual tenant generators, specialty exhaust, increased fire resistance and ratings, sound attenuation, roof upgrades, a secure site or chemical storage, and hazardous waste requirements.
PDFs of the full report and compatibility chart can be downloaded from here.
Office-to-housing can be expensive
What happens to vacant office space is a question of considerable urgency for cities like San Francisco and Boston, whose office real estate represents between 18% and 22% of their property tax revenue. “I heard anecdotally that 90% of tenants are looking for 10% of the buildings. So where does this leave the rest of them?” asks Jodka. That question is especially relevant as businesses “recalibrate” their definitions of office and work to factor in work-from-anywhere options.
Petz and Reepmeyer run through what have become familiar pros and cons about office conversions. In urban markets, says Reepmeyer, this conversation mostly revolves around adding more residential to downtown central business districts. “Part of this stems from government agencies and jurisdictions looking to solve the housing crisis while bringing vibrancy and occupancy to vacant office buildings,” she explains.
However, there is a particular set of challenges that comes with office-to residential conversions. For example, bringing light and air deep into high-rise floorplates can drive costs exponentially. “It’s often a density play in the form of a vertical addition that makes these projects viable,” observes Reepmeyer.
Cost definitely can make conversions problematic. Petz points out that, assuming all the structural elements can be met, there’s still a broad $450-$650 per sf price range for a conversion in urban markets, depending on the extent of renovation necessary. Even if the conversion of a Class B office building can be lowered to $150-200 per sf, Colliers estimates that “all-in” costs total somewhere around $550 to $850 per sf, making an office-to-res conversion “economically unfeasible.”
Conversions to other building types besides housing, like self-storage or hotels, might make more sense economically (albeit with their own issues). And Petz predicts that demolition of existing office buildings could be a more expedient route to achieving residential redevelopment because it would “benefit from better zoning, higher densities, and quicker approval processes.”
Petz asserts that for offices to be converted to residential in suburban markets, “a public policy decision must be made around housing and affordability.” That translates into local municipalities offering tax abatements, financing support, accelerated permitting and broader zoning. “Policy changes must be abrupt and clearly defined,“ says Petz.
Reepmeyer notes that Boston—following the leads of other cities such as Chicago and New York—has unveiled plans to implement a pilot program that would reduce tax burdens by 75 percent over a 29-year period, for office properties converting to residential use.
![Several cities reconsider density regs](/sites/default/files/inline-images/Compatibility%20density.png)
But, she adds, discussions about office-to-res conversions have been rendered all but moot in suburban markets where there’s much more interest in converting vacant offices to spaces for life sciences, tech, R&D, industrial, and auxiliary spaces supporting science, research, and manufacturing. “Depending on infrastructure parameters, a substantial amount of suburban inventory is well-suited for these types of conversions, given their high bays and long spans from a structural perspective,” Reepmeyer states.
Offices might also be suitable for conversions to distribution centers and so-called “last mile” warehouse facilities that are much sought after by suburban municipalities.
Offices still ‘necessary’
Colliers and SGA aren’t ready to give up on offices yet, especially now that more companies are pushing for their employees to return to workplaces, even if for only a few days per week. Earlier this month, President Biden called on his Cabinet to “aggressively execute” plans for federal employees to work more from their offices by this fall.
“There will always be a need for commercial office space, and the flight-to-quality will continue as long as supply outweighs demand in the commercial office sector,” says Reepemeyer. She notes that more companies are taking advantage of market conditions to improve their corporate footprint, promote culture, and prioritize the human experience as it relates to their organization. This shift includes upgraded user-focused working environments, access to vibrant sought-after amenities, and a new-found focus on collaboration and community-building.
“It’s interesting that these attributes are not unlike the placemaking and activation that are so strongly desired at city and neighborhood scales,” Reepmeyer adds.
Petz agrees that all office “isn’t going away.” He believes that a significant number of office buildings in cities remain viable, and the majority “will be necessary” in the future, as new industries and businesses, like artificial intelligence, lure workers back to places like San Francisco.
Related Stories
Giants 400 | Aug 7, 2015
GOVERNMENT SECTOR GIANTS: Public sector spending even more cautiously on buildings
AEC firms that do government work say their public-sector clients have been going smaller to save money on construction projects, according to BD+C's 2015 Giants 300 report.
Giants 400 | Aug 6, 2015
GREEN BUILDING GIANTS: Green building movement hits a new plateau, but the underlying problems remain
Today, the green building movement is all about eliminating toxic substances in building materials and systems and, for manufacturers, issuing environmental and health product declarations. Whether these efforts will lead to healthier products and building environments remains an open question.
Codes and Standards | Aug 6, 2015
Difference in male-female thermal comfort is due to clothing, ASHRAE says
Women wear lighter clothing in the summer, so they tend to be cooler in air-conditioned rooms, according to the group.
Giants 400 | Aug 5, 2015
GIANTS 300 REPORT: Top 85 Office Sector Construction Firms
Turner, Structure Tone, and Gilbane top BD+C's ranking of the nation's largest office sector contractors and construction management firms.
Giants 400 | Aug 5, 2015
GIANTS 300 REPORT: Top 75 Office Sector Engineering Firms
AECOM, Jacobs, and Burns & McDonnell head BD+C's ranking of the nation's largest office sector engineering and engineering/architecture firms.
Giants 400 | Aug 5, 2015
GIANTS 300 REPORT: Top 135 Office Sector Architecture Firms
Gensler, HOK, and Perkins+Will top BD+C's ranking of the nation's largest office sector architecture and architecture/engineering firms.
Giants 400 | Aug 5, 2015
OFFICE SECTOR GIANTS: Today’s workplace design must appeal to Millennials’ ‘activity-based’ lifestyle
Office market AEC Giants discuss the latest trends workplace design, and the state of the office construction sector.
Office Buildings | Jul 31, 2015
Design unveiled for Apple HQ visitor center
A glass-walled single-story building alongside the main office building in Cupertino, Calif., will be used as a visitor center.
Office Buildings | Jul 29, 2015
Design plans for Fannie Mae’s new HQ revealed
The developer/owner, Carr Properties, envisions a 1-million-sf plus mixed-use center with a large retail pavilion.
Contractors | Jul 29, 2015
Consensus Construction Forecast: Double-digit growth expected for commercial sector in 2015, 2016
Despite the adverse weather conditions that curtailed design and construction activity in the first quarter of the year, the overall construction market has performed extremely well to date, according to AIA's latest Consensus Construction Forecast.