Last year, contractors used mass timber to construct an estimated 78 buildings in the U.S., representing 4 million sf of space. A comprehensive new report on the North American mass timber market projects that the number of mass timber buildings could double every two years. By 2034, there would be new demand for 12.9 billion board feet of lumber that would require the establishment of nearly 77 million acres of new forestland.
The 156-page mass timber report—produced by The Beck Group, Forest Business Network, Treesource, and Kaiser + Path, a real estate developer/builder and architect—takes a deep dive into current and possible future supply and demand for mass timber components and panels for the U.S. and Canada. Its primary argument is that significant growth in the use of mass timber as a building material is achievable without serious deforestation. The report also justifies its forecasts about mass timber’s expanded use as a building product on the premise that the products would deliver myriad benefits, vis-a-vis other materials, to owners, builders, designers, occupants, and the environment.
(If mass timber use expands as predicted, the report contends that, by 2034, the North American building industry will store more carbon than it emits.)
Also see: Vermont’s Burr and Burton Academy expansion will feature mass timber and flexible spaces
WILL SUPPLY KEEP UP WITH MASS TIMBER DEMAND?
The number of mass timber buildings is expected to double every two years through 2034, at which point the construction industry would be storing more carbon than it emits. Charts and images: North American Mass Timber Report: 2020 State of the Industry
Some of the report’s assumptions rest on incomplete data. For example, when it discusses overharvesting, the report’s conclusions are drawn from so-called “growth to drain” estimates that, for the U.S., stop at the year 2012, and at 2016 for Canada, where the report says more active forest management is needed to make Canada’s lumber more resilient to climate change and infestation.
Nevertheless, the report places mass timber within the larger context of available construction materials. To produce a cubic foot of mass timber raw material requires about 22.5 board feet of lumber. The estimated demand for mass timber products last year was between 20 million and 25 million cubic feet. The 450-500 million board feet of softwood lumber consumed for North American mass timber in 2019 represented less that 1% of the total softwood lumber produced that year.
“Even if the lumber demand expands to 3 billion board feet per year (more than six times the current level), it would represent only a 5% share of today’s lumber production,” the report states. “The mass timber industry can expand several times its current size before it will make a significant impact on the North American lumber industry.” The report also believes the expansion of North American lumber capacity will help absorb new demand expected from increased mass timber construction.
Also see: Mass timber construction grows up
However, the report acknowledges that the industry’s capacity to produce mass timber is nowhere close yet to meeting future demand. For example, the report estimates that by 2034 North American buildings could consume 576 million cubic feet of mass timber panels annually. That means manufacturers would need to boost their current capacities by a factor of nearly 40 to meet those demand projections.
(That’s not inconceivable, though: the report notes that panel manufacturing capacity in North America increased by more than 1,000% between 2010 and 2020.)
The current supply chain in North America needs to expand its production capacity to meet the mass timber demand projected by the report.
Manufacturer investment in new capacity is worth the risk, the report contends, given recent code changes that will allow the use of mass timber for buildings up to 18 stories, as well as efficiency improvements, government incentives and support, and product standardization. Mass timber can also burnish a supplier’s and owner’s environmental rep, as there’s an estimated 0.023 tons of carbon offset for every building that uses mass timber instead of steel or concrete; and 0.0047 net tons of carbon is sequestered by mass timber for every square foot of a building.
STILL A SLIVER OF NONRES CONSTRUCTION
Mass timber has a long road to hoe to make serious inroads into nonresidential construction, which currently accounts for only around 5% of mass timber consumption, versus 70-75% that’s consumed by homebuilding and residential renovation.
Cost remains a factor, as it’s still cheaper to use wood and concrete than cross-laminated timber (CLT) components to build with. (Lumber represents about half of the total production cost for cross-laminated timber, and operating costs for production range from $5-7 per cubic foot.)
Also see: More mass timber beam and column options available in the U.S.
Homebuilding and renovation account for between 70-75% of the mass timber consumed annually. But the use of mass timber in nonresidential construction continues to grow.
But the nonresidential application of mass timber keeps growing. In Portland, Ore., an urban infill project completed in April called Sideyard—a 20,000-ft wedge-shaped building that reconnects a roadway to that city’s Burnside Bridge—features a new CLT structural system with an open ground-level commuter-oriented retail space that’s geared toward guests and tenants. The Building Team included Skylab (architect), Anderson Construction (GC), Harper Houf Peterson Righellis (CE), catean engineers (SE), and PAE (mechanical engineer). DR Johnson supplied the CLT panels and glulam members, and Freres Lumber supplied the mass plywood panels.
The report also points to Lendlease’s 50-year agreement to provide lodging for the U.S. Army. The contractor has built hotels on more than 40 installations and joint bases, including Redstone Arsenal in Alabama where Lendlease built with mass timber and completed the project 37% faster and with 44% fewer worker hours than the other hotels.
Mass timber demand is greatest in California, where there were 32 mass timber buildings completed and 68 in design as of 2019. The next closest states were Washington (28 built, 44 in design), and Texas (17 and 37). All told, there were 248 mass timber buildings completed and 460 in design in the U.S. by the end of last year.
The International Code Council's 2021 building code would allow the use of mass timber in buildings up to 18 stories tall. Codes changes are one of the report's justifications for recommending that manufacturers invest in production capacity.
INSURERS ARE SKEPTICAL
The report claims that occupants in buildings made with mass timber benefit from better air quality and thermal comfort. (The report references research establishing links between wood and human health.) Owners might benefit as “the carbon impact of an investment will factor into market value,” as well as from reduced construction time and carrying costs, resilience (including seismic), and opportunities to reuse mass timber after demolition.
One caveat, the report notes, is that these and other benefits, such as better fire resistance, don’t always register with insurers that still tend to view all wood buildings similarly for liability risk.
Related Stories
Sponsored | Metals | Mar 10, 2015
Metal Building Systems: A Rising Star in the Market
A new report by the Metal Building Manufacturer's Association explains the entity's efforts in refining and extending metal building systems as a construction choice.
Building Materials | Feb 19, 2015
Prices for construction materials fall in January, following plummet of oil prices
The decline in oil and petroleum prices finally showed up in the produce price index data, according to ABC Chief Economist Anirban Basu.
Steel Buildings | Feb 10, 2015
Korean researchers discover 'super steel'
The new alloy makes steel as strong as titanium.
| Dec 29, 2014
From Ag waste to organic brick: Corn stalks reused to make construction materials [BD+C's 2014 Great Solutions Report]
Ecovative Design applies its cradle-to-cradle process to produce 10,000 organic bricks used to build a three-tower structure in Long Island City, N.Y. The demonstration project was named a 2014 Great Solution by the editors of Building Design+Construction.
| Dec 28, 2014
New trends in ceiling designs and materials [AIA course]
A broad array of new and improved ceiling products offers designers everything from superior acoustics and closed-loop, recycled content to eased integration with lighting systems, HVAC diffusers, fire sprinkler heads, and other overhead problems. This course describes how Building Teams are exploring ways to go beyond the treatment of ceilings as white, monolithic planes.
| Oct 30, 2014
CannonDesign releases guide for specifying flooring in healthcare settings
The new report, "Flooring Applications in Healthcare Settings," compares and contrasts different flooring types in the context of parameters such as health and safety impact, design and operational issues, environmental considerations, economics, and product options.
| Oct 16, 2014
Perkins+Will white paper examines alternatives to flame retardant building materials
The white paper includes a list of 193 flame retardants, including 29 discovered in building and household products, 50 found in the indoor environment, and 33 in human blood, milk, and tissues.
| Oct 14, 2014
Proven 6-step approach to treating historic windows
This course provides step-by-step prescriptive advice to architects, engineers, and contractors on when it makes sense to repair or rehabilitate existing windows, and when they should advise their building owner clients to consider replacement.
| Sep 25, 2014
Arup's Solarleaf façade system wins Zumtobel innovation award
The system uses the bio-chemical process of photosynthesis to absorb CO2 emissions, while cultivating microalgae to generate biomass and heat as renewable energy resources.
Sponsored | | Sep 15, 2014
Fire resistance of metal cladding is an asset in wildfire-prone areas
Construction projects in fire-prone areas need to take wildfire danger into account, and metal panels provide some fire-resistant qualities.