The U.S. government, through its departments, agencies, and military services, remains one of the largest clients for many architecture, engineering, and construction firms. BD+C Giants 300 firms like AECOM, URS, Lend Lease, and Jacobs perform billions of dollars of work for federal civilian and military clients every year, as do many medium-size and even some boutique firms. Getting a generous slice of the federal/military design and construction pie is, for many AEC firms, a vital business strategy.
However, if private-sector development is going through one of its most difficult periods right now, construction at the federal level may be facing even greater challenges, given the specter of budget constraints and the struggle over the national debt.
In that context, Building Design+Construction asked high-level representatives from three of the most active federal entitiesāthe General Services Administration, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and the Naval Facilities Engineering Commandāfor āthe ownerās perspectiveā on how the Building Team can work more successfully with them in these difficult economic times. Hereās what we learned.
GENERAL SERVICES ADMINISTRATION
The General Services Administration is the division of the Public Buildings Service that operates as landlord for the civilian portion of the federal government. The GSA is responsible for new construction as well as leasing space to serve its client agencies, such as the Department of Justice, the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office, the IRS, and the Social Security Administration.
The GSA owns or leases 9,624 properties in the 50 states, representing more than 370 million square feet of space. This inventory includes some 481 historic properties, such as the Old Executive Office Building in Washington and numerous landmark courthouses and office buildings. All this makes the GSA arguably the largest non-military landlord in the world.
The GSAās client agencies can be tough customers to deal with. āWe have sophisticated clients,ā says Bill Guerin, the Public Buildings Serviceās Assistant Commissioner for Project Delivery. An architect by training, with a degree from the University of California at Berkeley, Guerin has devoted his 29-year career to service with the federal government, first in California, more recently in Washington, D.C. āGovernment work is rules-based,ā he says. āYou have to jump through a lot of hoops if you want to move from private work to public work.ā
Currently, the two busiest builders among GSAās clients are the federal courts and the U.S. Customs and Border Patrol, the latter of which has been intensely active building land ports of entry along the Canadian and Mexican borders. Many of these projects fall under the GSAās acclaimed Design Excellence program. Their funding has been largely through the $787 billion American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009.
9 KEYS TO UNLOCKING U.S. CIVILIAN AND MILITARY CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
1. Demonstrate durability, long life. The feds build for 50- to 100-year cycles, so use products and systems that can last.2.Ā Follow the clientās rulesāand the Brooks Actāto the letter. Youāre dealing with Uncle here, so keep all your paperwork in shipshape order.
3.Ā Donāt bait and switch. Make sure the team leaders you paraded at the interview are the ones who show up on the job.
4.Ā Understand the clientās unique goals and needs. Like private-sector clients, each federal/military agency has its own priorities. Listen carefully and make them feel special.
5. Ā Emphasize value, not value engineering. The budget is the budget. Your job is to show how much long-term value you can produce within the dollar constraints.
6.Ā Check the BIM situation. BIM may or may not be required, so check with the respective agency. Federal clients are looking to see how BIM can help them with ongoing operations and maintenance.
7. Ā Think LEED Gold and up. LEED Gold and 30% better energy efficiency have become the price of admission. Youāve got to do better. On the near horizon: LEED Platinum and net-zero energy use.
8.Ā Integrate your project delivery. A contractual IPD agreement will probably not be required, but government/military clients want to see Building Team integration through such mechanisms as joint ventures or design-build.
9.Ā Donāt be afraid to apply. Government clients are looking for fresh faces and fresh ideas. Show how your expertise in the private sector or at the state/local level can be applied to federal/military work.
According to Guerin, each of these clients has a strong sense of the programmatic needs for its buildings, which may result in vastly different architectural expressions. The federal courts want to project a sense of stability and endurance in their architecture, to symbolize the solidity and permanence of the federal judicial system.
On the other hand, U.S. Customs and Border Patrol wants its new ports of entry to reflect change. For example, new border stations are experimenting with technology that uses the energy generated by cars braking to power the lights.
Guerin says most architects, engineers, and construction professionals are āthrilledā to work with GSA client agencies. āThese agencies know what they want, but theyāre open to new ideas,ā he says.
For AEC firms, one factor that makes the GSA refreshingly different from many private-sector clients is its emphasis on the long life of its buildings, a timeline that can extend as long as a century. āWeāre building for the long term, so we use life cycle costing versus short-term costs,ā says Guerin. While that perspective sometimes leads to intense scrutiny from both the executive and legislative branches that control GSAās budget, the agency has been able to successfully argue for the long-term investment, says Guerin.
A strong component of that argument has to do with the symbolism of federal buildings. āWe want them to look durable,ā Guerin says. āThey are meant to represent the United States of America.ā If they are to express the longevity and endurance of the nation, the argument goes, federal buildings must use quality materials and systems and be built to the highest standards.
One of the GSAās most ambitious current projects is the modernization of its own headquarters building at 1800 F Street, NW, in Washington, D.C. The 710,000-sf structure was originally built for the Department of the Interior in 1917. It has been home to the GSA since 1949 and was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1986.
CATCH THESE VIDEOS TO LEARN WHAT THE FEDS ARE LOOKING FOR
Public Buildings Commissioner Peck:
āWe want you to challenge usā
Robert A. Peck, Commissioner of Public Buildings for the GSA, is responsible for the nationwide asset management, design, construction, leasing, building management and disposal for 370 million square feet of government-owned and leased space, accommodating one million federal workers. He oversees an annual budget of $9.1 billion and a workforce of 7,005. In this video, he encourages Building Teams to challenge the GSA with fresh thinking.
www.bdcnetwork.com/robertpeck
Eleni Reed, GSAās First Chief āGreeningā Officer
From a background in real estate (Cushman & Wakefield), Eleni Reed, PP, AICP, LEED AP, in 2010 was named first Chief Greening Officer at the General Services Administration. She talks with BD+Cās Robert Cassidy about the Public Buildings Servicesā efforts to implement Executive Order 13514, which commits the government to net-zero energy use in its buildings by 2030, and implementing the GSAās five-year Strategic Sustainability Performance Plan.
www.bdcnetwork.com/elenireed
GSAās Lance Davis on āDesign Excellenceā
Lance Davis, AIA, LEED AP, Program Manager for Design Excellence Architecture+Sustainability in the Public Building Servicesā Office of Design and Construction, discusses the GSAās Design Excellence program and innovative technology in current GSA projects, notably at a soon-to-be LEED Platinum border station.
www.bdcnetwork.com/lancedavis
When new, the building was considered the first truly modern federal office building and remained a model for federal office buildings until the early 1930s. The four-year, $200 million renovation, by a joint venture of Whiting-Turner and Walsh Construction, will add 146,000 sf while restoring 1800 F Streetās place as a model for other federal facilities. Designed by the architecture/engineering team of Shalom Baranes in association with Studios and Syska Hennessy Group, the headquarters renovation will be āa technical marvelā when itās done, says Guerin.
The 1800 F Street project is scheduled to achieve LEED Gold certification. The GSA has been a pioneer in LEED, at first requiring LEED Silver certification for all its new buildings, more recently specifying Gold. The GSA has completed 123 LEED-certified buildings, and some of the ARRA-funded projects that are nearing completion will attain LEED Platinum status. But thatās just the start. āWeāre now requiring LEED Silver for our leases,ā says Guerin. āThatās pushing the commercial real estate market.ā
GSAās greening efforts seem to be working. A recent post-occupancy evaluation of 22 GSA buildings ("Green Building Performance") showed 25% less energy use for GSA sustainably designed buildings versus the national average (66 kBtu/sf/yr vs. 88 kBtu/sf/yr), 19% lower aggregate operational costs ($1.60/sf vs. $1.98/sf), and 36% lower carbon emissions.
U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS
The U.S Army Corps of Engineersā 34,000 civilian and military employees serve as the executive engineer for the Army, Air Force, Army Reserve, and Air Force Reserve. The process for getting a project with USACE is similar to that of other federal agencies, says Diane McCartin, a project manager with the USACEās Louisville office: āWe advertise A/E opportunities on the FedBizOpps website.ā Typically, thereās a single-phase selection thatās based on providing best value, not necessarily lowest cost. āWe judge qualifications based on work on similar projects,ā says McCartin.
McCartin was the primary āownerā contact for the Armed Forces Reserve Center in Middletown, Conn., a $51.5 million project that was designed and built in 14 months from the selection of KBE Ventures, a Farmington, Conn.-based joint venture of KBE Building Corporation and Derita Construction. The 164,000-sf structure houses administrative, educational, assembly, library, learning center, vault, weapons simulator, and physical fitness areas for four Army Reserve units and six Connecticut Army National Guard units.
The Middletown project, a product of the 2005 Defense Base Closure and Realignment Commission, was solicited as a design-build project, but the USACE wanted prospective teams to stretch a bit, which is how KBE Ventures won the project. āThe designers added an extra loading dock,ā says McCartin. āThat added functionality.ā KBE principal and director of procurement Simon Etzel says that, with clients like the Corps of Engineers, itās often not enough just to satisfy the program. āWe added value,ā he says.
Another factor that contributed to the Middletown project was its architectural style. āWe always want our projects to fit in to the community, but this was more specific,ā says McCartin. āWe asked forāNew England-style architectureā and gave them examples of what we wanted.ā
As the owner of the project, the USACE functions as the agent for the end users in all discussions with the Building Team. āThe program is an iterative process that starts with the end users,ā says McCartin, who came to the USACE with a real estate background. āThe team has all disciplinesāenvironmental, real estate, design, and so on,ā she says. āWe need a diverse team.ā
Durability and permanence are important to USACE. A lifespan of 50-75 years is understood as the standard, says McCartin. The correct choice of building materials and construction systems is always done with this goal in mind, as long as those specifications fit within the prescribed budget. āShould it be a standing seam metal roof or a shingle roof?ā McCartin asks. āIt comes down to price and whatās the best value.ā The Corps wants the Building Team to provide options, but it has to do so with final cost in mind.
The Corps of Engineers requires its new facilities to meet the equivalent of LEED 2.0 Silver certification through its own Sustainable Project Rating Tool, called SPiRiT (click here to download). According to the U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center website, SPiRiT is ātailored to meet Army-specific needsā while taking a whole-building approach that improves the facilityās life cycle management. As for the USACEās energy-efficiency goals, āWeāre strict about achieving 30% better than ASHRAE standards,ā says McCartin.
Even though the SPiRiT process is self-certified, that doesnāt make it any easier than getting LEED certification, according to KBEās Etzel. āSubmitting the documentation to USACE was just as rigorous as dealing with the USGBC,ā he says. The Middletown project is currently tracking Gold certification, exceeding the original requirement (Silver) set by the SPiRiT rating system.
McCartin says her biggest problem is working with Building Teams that donāt read and respond to documents; after that, itās Building Teams that donāt respond quickly and effectively to problems that come up on the job. Of course, the USACE isnāt necessarily your typical client. āWe have a specific process for delivery,ā McCartin says. āIt reflects lessons learned. We know what we need.ā
NAVAL FACILITIES ENGINEERING COMMAND
The Naval Facilities Engineering Command is the oldest of the Navyās System Commands, dating back to 1842. NAVFAC serves a similar role for the Navy and the Marine Corps as the USACE does for the Army and Air Force. It has an annual budget of $5 billion, with 3,000 Navy engineering professionals under the supervision of Joseph E. Gott, PE, a fire protection engineer by training and NAV FACās Chief Engineer and Director of Capital Improvements.
As in the case of the GSA and the Corps of Engineers, NAVFAC hires its Building Team members through a qualifications-based process under the Brooks Act (P.L 92-852), the 1972 law that prescribes the process for selecting architects and engineers for federal projects. āWe look at past experienceāwhatās relevant,ā says Gott. āIf youāre thinking of trying to get a barracks project, then hotel design experience would be relevant.ā In other words, your experience must line up in some tangible way with the project.
BIM AND IPD AT THE FEDERAL LEVEL
The General Services Administration was an early advocate of BIM. Since October 2007, GSA has required spatial program BIM models to be submitted to the Office of the Chief Architect for all major prospectus-level projects seeking GSA funding. The GSA also āencouragesā Building Teams to ādeploy mature 3D, 4D, and BIM technologiesāspatial program validation and beyondāat strategic project phases in support of specific project challenges,ā according to its BIM website.While the Army Corps of Engineers has its specific protocols, theyāre still engaged with common practices used in the private sector. āWe try to follow industry standards,ā says the USACEās Diane McCartin. BIM is being used increasingly in USACE projects like the new $51.5 million Armed Forces Reserve Center in Middletown, Conn. āItās been a good experience,ā says McCartin.
The Naval Facilities Engineering Command is making BIM a part of its everyday requirements but not for the flashy, high-level 3D drawings it can produce. āWe use it for management,ā says Joseph E. Gott, PE, NAVFACās Chief Engineer and Director of Capital Improvements. āWe are using it to see the maintenance cycle in digital formāāHereās what I need to do and when I need to do it.āā By the end of 2012, NAVFAC is going to have its own specifications for BIMāa development thatās worth watching for, as itās likely to distill best practices from a number of federal and military agencies.
On integrated project delivery, NAVFAC doesnāt require a strictly delineated IPD document, but thereās still a structured IPD-like partnering program in place. āI put everybody at the same table,ā says Gott.
The USACE does not use formal IPD contracts, ābut we have all the Building Team members in place when weāre developing the criteria as owners,ā says McCartin. āWeāre using the process without using the title.ā
The GSA is using IPD on its San Ysidro Land Port of Entry and some form of integrated development (including design-build or joint ventures) on all its projects, but it is not a requirement. āWe believe in the idea of integration,ā says the GSAās Bill Guerin. āThree-party agreements are not contemplated, but weāre talking about integration.ā
Unlike the Corps of Engineers, NAVFAC generally does not require applicants to demonstrate lots of design experience at the selection phase, preferring instead to concentrate on candidate firmsā teaming skills, technical expertise, and relevant experience. However, says Gott, āWeāre very specific as to who can do work. We donāt have mechanical engineers doing civil engineering.ā
Most of NAVFACās building projects are performed under multiple work construction contracts. āWeāll interview 10 firms and select three who will then compete for a variety of projects over a period or time or over a specific geographic area,ā says Gott. āIt can be either an A/E or design-build situation; the process is the same.ā Standalone contracts are usually used only for projects over $50 million.
Gott says NAVFAC always deals with a prime contractor, which may sometimes be a design-build entity, very often a joint venture with many subcontractors. He warns, however, that each subcontractor must be identified at the time the proposal is submitted.
As for NAVFACās priorities, Gott names his top two: 1) total ownership cost and 2) energy efficiency. āWeāre always looking for the best value, based on the total ownership cost,ā he says. āI will often use a standing-seam metal roof over a built-up roof, based on total cost of ownership. In fact, weāre going to be rolling out a total-cost template soonāāsomething to look out for.
Speed of delivery can also be your trump card. āIf you can give me the same project at the same price, but earlier than the competition, youāre going to get the job,ā Gott says.
Building durability is another important goal of NAVFACās construction program, with a 50-year lifespan considered typical. That may be the useful life with recapitalization and several occupancy changes occurring over that time span. āWeāll renovate and modify our facilities, and eventually demolish them,ā Gott says. āWeāre currently reducing our footprint, to reduce energy costs. That means that new construction involves eliminating old construction. Weāre taking out the old, inefficient buildingsāour āenergy hogs.āā
NAVFAC has been part of the green building wave since the early days of LEED, starting with the reconstruction of the Washington Navy Yard. NAVFAC began requiring LEED Silver certification as a baseline for its construction projects in FY2009. It has completed 50 LEED-certified buildings, with another 500 or so registered for certification. Just last month, that bar was raised to LEED Gold. Certification must be done by a third party, but Gott does not rule out non-LEED ratings systems, such as Green Globes. āItās a competitive marketplace, so thereās room for others,ā he says.
He points out, however, that NAVFAC requires specific LEED points to be met no matter what certification program is used, specifically those promoting energy efficiency. NAVFAC is also required to use low-impact development to improve stormwater drainage on its sites.
So where do Building Teams go wrong with NAVFAC? When they stray from procedures. āLearn the submittal process,ā says Gott. And be sure to bring the same talent you proposed to the table when itās time to get the work done. āYou canāt bait and switch,ā he says.
Ultimately, the path to a successful project with NAVFAC is relatively straightforward, says Gott. The Building Team should focus on performance, quality, and best value. āTell us how youāre going to do it, and do it,ā he says. āItās very objective.ā
NO RISK, NO REWARD
Thereās no question that working with the civilian and military branches of the federal government can be tough. Each has specific protocols that reflect its long history, and no one is going to let any Building Team work on its own terms. But that doesnāt mean that you should avoid the workāespecially since federal/military is a sector that actually has work these days.
āThe biggest mistake is not applying for our work,ā says the GSAās Bill Guerin. āWe want new faces.ā Guerin notes that the GSAās strong interest in innovationāa quality shared by NAVFAC and the Corps of Engineersādrives it to find new firms. āItās always a challenge the first time. But you can learn quickly,ā he says. āWe want new ideas. Take an interest and try.ā
In the words of Robert A. Peck, Commissioner of Public Buildings for the GSA, āPlease bring us your best game. We need people to challenge usā with better products, better designs, and better programs. BD+C
Related Stories
Building Team | Jul 13, 2022
Austinās newest entertainment and hospitality complex has been made from repurposed shipping containers
A new entertainment and hospitality complex in Austin, The Pitch, has been made out of repurposed shipping containers.Ā
Codes and Standards | Jul 12, 2022
USGBC sets out principles for LEEDās future
The U.S. Green Building Council recently published a report containing principles outlining how LEED will evolve.
Building Team | Jul 12, 2022
10 resource reduction measures for more efficient and sustainable biopharma facilities
Resource reduction measures are solutions that can lead to lifecycle energy and cost savings for a favorable return on investment while simultaneously improving resiliency and promoting health and wellness in your facility.
Office Buildings | Jul 12, 2022
Miami office tower nears completion, topping off at 55 stories
In Miami, construction of OKO Group and Cain Internationalās 830 Brickell office tower is nearing completion.
University Buildings | Jul 11, 2022
Student life design impacts campus wellness
As interior designers, we have the opportunity and responsibility to help students achieve deeper levels of engagement in their learning, social involvement, and personal growth on college campuses.
Museums | Jul 11, 2022
Denmark opens a museum that tells the stories of refugees worldwide
Located on the site of Denmarkās largest World War II refugee camp, the new Refugee Museum of Denmark, FLUGT, tells the stories of refugees from the camp as well as refugees worldwide.Ā
Codes and Standards | Jul 8, 2022
Inefficient supply chains, outdated project delivery systems hamper construction investment
Constructing and justifying the cost of physical assets such as a manufacturing plant is much more difficult than it was decades ago, according to a report by Steffen Fuchs, senior partner with McKinsey & Company.
Airports | Jul 8, 2022
Phoenix Sky Harbor Airportās new terminal prioritizes passenger experience and sustainability
McCarthy Building Companies recently completed construction of the final concourse in Terminal 4 at Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport.
Architects | Jul 7, 2022
Page acquires AE giant EYP to form 1,300-person international design firm
The combined firm will ābe able to invest in research and thought leadership to co-create with our clients,ā stated Page CEO Thomas McCarthy.
Building Team | Jul 7, 2022
Report explores improving architect/contractor relationship
A new study by the American Institute of Architects and the Associated General Contractors of America focuses on improving the relationship between architects and contractors.