In designing and building apartment and condominium projects, parking determines everything from site suitability to the building’s footprint to revenue optimization.
Throughout my career, I’ve had to turn down sites from a development perspective because we couldn’t make the parking work. Parking often dictates building layouts and sometimes even the number of units we can put into the building. For those of us in the multifamily sector, we want to create spaces for people to live, play, and grow, not just projects centered around giving people a place to store their cars.
Over the years, my colleagues and I at The Bradley Projects have developed strategies for site evaluation and alternative methods for maximizing parking and overall return on investment. The following are strategies for parking that we have found serve the site, the residents, and the owner/developer.
KNOWLEDGE AND THOROUGHNESS: STILL THE KEY FACTORS IN SITE ASSESSMENTS
First, there is no “thinking around” a site’s topography related to parking design strategies. As developers ourselves, we occasionally have to pass on a site solely because it doesn’t allow for optimal parking.
Take the matter of subterranean conditions, which can vary significantly across the U.S. In coastal areas, underground parking becomes difficult due to soil conditions and drainage, whereas in Nashville, where we are based, everything is on bedrock. That makes excavation time-consuming and expensive and carries certain liabilities due to the need for explosives to blast the rock. So it is important to identify the unique site-specific conditions before moving on to the rest of the site analysis.
STARTING POINTS FOR EVALUATING PARKING
We typically begin by looking at the geometries of the site, any irregularities, possible ingress and egress points, traffic flow and patterns, and assorted other unique features—all of which is part of our contextual analysis. We study layouts, which are a factor of dimensions, rhythms, and building codes.
Over the years, we have assembled a knowledge base of parking analyses from every project we’ve ever done, based on our work with numerous traffic engineers and parking consultants. Using this knowledge base we can be very efficient in evaluating a site. Specialized software technology can sometimes be helpful, but we often still rely on conventional evaluation methods due to cost and budget to get the job done.
We’ve also found that technology doesn’t quite go that last step to optimize the layout. We have been experimenting with software from several new tech companies, beta testing their products that promise to use in-depth algorithms to essentially compute the most efficient layout from the onset of the study.
We have found that, while these tools can produce results very quickly, the results have been much the same as what we would have developed without the program. We’ve also found the algorithm-based software can lay out the spaces mathematically but has not yet been able to finesse the geometries the way the human brain can. There are just times where a motorcycle space or two can fill in a strange area, or you can move trash collection somewhere else, or a transformer to another location—all solutions that surface through human collaboration, brainstorming, and experience.
THREE APPROACHES TO PARKING IN APARTMENT AND CONDOMINIUM PROJECTS
Once we have completed an initial analysis, we’re ready to consider what building typology makes sense. Usually, that falls into three categories: tuck under, cantilever, and over excavation.
Tuck under is usually the least expensive method for tight areas but only works well off alley-loaded sites. For our Fairfax Flats project, we managed to fit parking for 19 units into a tiny urban infill lot with this tactic.
![Fairfax Flats, Nashville - tuck under parking](/sites/default/files/inline-images/2%20Bradley%20Projects%20-%20Fairfax%20Flats%20Nashville.jpg)
In neighborhood-based urban areas with alley-loaded access, the tuck under approach can work well if the site allows the structure to address the main street and neighborhood while hiding and directing the cars to the alley.
Cantilever. In multifamily projects, cantilevers can break up the typical “box” multifamily development that is running rampant in so many cities and give architects a chance for a more progressive statement. They also provide an ideal way to work covered parking into the project. While more expensive than a tuck under, the cantilever approach can provide more parking spaces.
![Alina apartment complex, Nashville with cantilever parking](/sites/default/files/inline-images/3%20Alina%20Nashville.jpg)
A site with an alley is still preferable for the cantilever technique, although, in tight spatial scenarios, we’ve done this off of a busy city street.
Over excavation is usually the most expensive option. In many urban areas this approach allows parking to be pushed to the extreme edges of the property, then covered by the building or by setback/outdoor space, depending on the zoning requirements.
![Illume Nashville, The Bradley Projects - over excavation parking](/sites/default/files/inline-images/4%20Illume%20Nashville%20%20-%20Ford%20Photographs%20-%20BPIjpg.jpg)
Over excavation is expensive due to the excavation costs, shoring requirements at property lines, and the extra effort needed to build space underground. This approach lends itself to creating plaza-like spaces over the concrete “lid” of the parking area.
Some more enlightened cities have begun to incentivize developers to create this type of ground-level outdoor space to integrate new multifamily communities into the urban fabric and pedestrian realm. Such spaces also can increase retail or residential rents if they are seen as marketable. But it’s still a question of thoughtful and intentional design.
Over excavation can work just about anywhere there is enough room to get a car ramp down and parking allocated.
CHOOSING THE RIGHT PARKING STYLE
Ultimately, the cost-effectiveness equation is more complex than dollars in and dollars out. So many of our projects would never have penciled out without pushing hard on efficiencies and getting creative with how we solve for the highest level of efficiency while addressing all of the various types of users and circulation patterns.
Sometimes the cheapest option isn’t the best. I’ve seen the ROI on a multifamily development increase 20-25% just by rethinking how we handle the parking scenario. It was not because the parking solution saved construction dollars, but because it allowed 20-25% more units, or more retail space, or both.
It’s becoming much more critical to think about and be honest about how much parking your project needs. Cities across the map are lowering their parking requirements. People are becoming less car reliant. In the Nashville region, we are seeing an average 25% decrease in required parking in most areas of our urban areas—even down to zero required parking in areas on multimodal corridors. Nashville’s civic leadership is very wisely and progressively pushing much of the parking requirements back on developers and the market to resolve the parking situation instead of adopting an antiquated, one-size-fits-all policy.
THE FUTURE OF PARKING
Despite the reduced reliance on cars, we’re nowhere near a zero parking world, but the trend is undoubtedly moving toward less and less parking, more EV charging areas, and more drop-off/valet areas.
I’m excited to see the possibility of our cities becoming more populated with autonomous vehicles that can be developed for much safer conditions for riders and pedestrians.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Jared Bradley, AIA, NCARB, is Founder and President of The Bradley Projects, an architecture, construction, and development company headquartered in Nashville, Tenn.
Related Stories
| Aug 11, 2010
First CityCenter projects earn LEED Gold
CityCenter announced today that it has received three Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED Gold certifications from the U.S. Green Building Council for: 1) ARIA Resort's hotel tower; 2) ARIA Resort's convention center and theater; 3) Vdara Hotel. ARIA and Vdara will open in December on the Las Vegas Strip and are the first of CityCenter's developments to be LEED certified.
| Aug 11, 2010
Oldcastle Precast Building Systems wins PCI 2009 Sustainable Design Award
Oldcastle Precast Building Systems was part of the award winning team behind the affordable housing development Melrose Commons Site 5 situated in the South Bronx. PCI (Precast Concrete Institute) recently selected Melrose 5 for the “2009 PCI Design Award for Best Sustainable Project”.
| Aug 11, 2010
National Intrepid Center of Excellence tops out at Walter Reed
SmithGroup and The Intrepid Fallen Heroes Fund (IFHF), a non-profit organization supporting the men and women of the United States Armed Forces and their families, celebrated the overall structural completion of the National Intrepid Center of Excellence (NICoE), an advanced facility dedicated to research, diagnosis and treatment of military personnel and veterans suffering from traumatic brain injury.
| Aug 11, 2010
USGBC honors Brad Pitt's Make It Right New Orleans as the ‘largest and greenest single-family community in the world’
U.S. Green Building Council President, CEO and Founding Chair Rick Fedrizzi today declared that the neighborhood being built by Make It Right New Orleans, the post-Katrina housing initiative launched by actor Brad Pitt, is the “largest and greenest community of single-family homes in the world” at the annual Clinton Global Initiative meeting in New York.
| Aug 11, 2010
Trump luxury condos in Jersey City get more luxurious
Only two years after opening, Jersey City-based Trump Plaza Residences is getting a facelift. Interior designer Benjamin Noriega-Ortiz of BNOdesign has been commissioned to create a fresh design for the residential tower's entrance and outdoor pool, cabana, and lawn spaces. Renovations on the 55-story, 443-unit luxury high-rise will be completed in two phases.
| Aug 11, 2010
Apartments offer skyline view of Houston
Perched atop a hill near downtown Houston, the Gables Memorial Hills residential tower will rise to eight stories and cover 2.68 acres. With an average unit size of 965 sf, the brick and cast-stone complex will consist of 70% one-bedroom units and 30% two-bedroom units, some of which overlook downtown.
| Aug 11, 2010
Sustainable features central to independent-living building
Architecture firm Perkins Eastman, together with Saint Johns on the Lake retirement community, plans to open a 21-story, 88-unit independent-living building for seniors by mid 2011. When the $46-million project is complete, it will offer residents a streetside café, art gallery, spa and wellness center, classroom, and community performance space.
| Aug 11, 2010
Historic building to be restored in Kansas City
Construction has begun on the conversion of the historic 17-story Home Savings Association building in Kansas City, Mo. The transformed structure, to be known as Grand Boulevard Lofts, will house 134 apartment units. The $18-million project, designed by architect Rosemann & Associates, follows a revitalization of downtown Kansas City, where there is high demand for affordable housing to ser...
| Aug 11, 2010
Old factory converted from hearth to home
A former briquette factory in Cologne-Frechen, Germany, was converted into a mixed-use building by Astoc Architects & Planners, Cologne, in association with Rheinischen Amt für Denkmalpflege—the Rhenish agency for historic preservation. The roughly 172,200-sf building includes a mix of residential condominiums, lofts, and leased commercial space.
| Aug 11, 2010
And the world's tallest building is…
At more than 2,600 feet high, the Burj Dubai (right) can still lay claim to the title of world's tallest building—although like all other super-tall buildings, its exact height will have to be recalculated now that the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (CTBUH) announced a change to its height criteria.