With the Affordable Care Act still in its infancy, Building Teams are seeing reverberations in the investment decisions of healthcare providers, including new ideas about the types of buildings they are asked to create.
“To reduce costs, many hospitals, physicians’ groups, and healthcare systems are merging to eliminate duplication of operations,” says Kelly Altes, P.E., Project Executive for KJWW Engineering Consultants and a member of BD+C’s “40 Under 40” Class of 2014. “These and other trends are in many cases the result of the Affordable Care Act, which has providers focusing more than ever on patient experiences and outcomes, as well as outpatient services. This shift is resulting in a significant increase in medical office building and clinic construction and renovation projects.”
The latest version of the annual Hospital Construction Survey conducted by the American Society for Healthcare Engineering with Health Facilities Management magazine confirms this trend. The percentage of respondents planning medical office building expansions, completely new MOBs, neighborhood outpatient facilities and primary-care clinics, and ambulatory surgery centers were all up significantly. Meanwhile, 41% said the new regulatory environment makes it less likely that they’ll proceed with large new hospital construction projects.
TOP HEALTHCARE SECTOR ARCHITECTURE FIRMS
2013 Healthcare Revenue ($)
1 HDR $191,150,000
2 Stantec 126,523,841
3 HKS 113,904,765
4 CannonDesign 108,000,000
5 Perkins+will 96,663,046
6 HOK 92,185,580
7 NBBJ 85,544,000
8 Perkins Eastman 69,750,000
9 Hammel, Green and Abrahamson 66,036,440
10 SmithGroupJJR 58,159,528
SEE FULL LIST
TOP HEALTHCARE SECTOR ENGINEERING FIRMS
2013 Healthcare Revenue ($)
1 AECOM Technology Corp. $180,760,000
2 Jacobs 87,770,000
3 URS Corp. 45,036,525
4 Smith Seckman Reid 40,105,600
5 KPFF Consulting Engineers 38,000,000
6 Allen & Shariff 36,000,000
7 BR+A Consulting Engineers 29,900,000
8 Affiliated Engineers 27,947,000
9 CCRD Partners 23,760,000
10 Burns & McDonnell 19,810,000
SEE FULL LIST
TOP HEALTHCARE SECTOR CONSTRUCTION FIRMS
2013 Healthcare Revenue ($)
1 Turner Construction $2,001,060,000
2 McCarthy Holdings 1,738,000,000
3 Skanska USA 1,207,794,377
4 Brasfield & Gorrie 974,254,444
5 Clark Group 867,497,494
6 DPR Construction 806,488,333
7 PCL Construction 721,107,363
8 Whiting-Turner Contracting Co., The 720,455,505
9 JE Dunn Construction 700,315,855
10 Balfour Beatty US 469,422,190
SEE FULL LIST
With care models changing, medical office buildings increasingly provide services that were once the exclusive province of hospitals, from cancer care to emergency treatment to operations. According to Cushman & Wakefield, 80% of surgeries can successfully be completed in an ambulatory setting.
Giants 300 coverage of Healthcare brought to you by DuPont www.fluidapplied.tyvek.com
By moving these procedures away from large hospital campuses—which are often landlocked with little room for expansion—the volume of patients requiring the hospital is reduced, making way for patients with more complex needs. Since many off-campus MOBs are part of a network associated with a larger hospital, patients who end up needing more advanced care can simply transition to the main campus.
Locations of new MOBs are carefully considered, with developers opting to place them near shopping, restaurants, major roads, and public transit. In the past, many retail centers were wary of making deals with medical tenants because of the overall stigma of having a healthcare provider near retail and dining. Retail developers also believed medical tenants wouldn’t produce attractive levels of revenue. However, some developers have decided that having healthcare tenants is better than no tenants at all.
In particular, medical groups have made good use of large spaces vacated by defunct retail franchises, both stand-alone and within malls. Kaiser Permanente recently opened a 32,000-sf MOB in Portland, Ore., via adaptive reuse of a Circuit City location the healthcare organization bought out of receivership in 2010. Minnesota’s HealthEast Care System has created clinics in St. Paul-area spaces once occupied by Borders, Gander Mountain, and eq-life retail stores.
New partnerships and development models
A Cushman & Wakefield investor survey on medical office buildings reports that many healthcare providers are now seeking to form joint ventures, often between for-profit and not-for-profit health systems. These partnerships may offer the for-profit business the name recognition of the nonprofit, and give the nonprofit access to the financial and physician resources of the for-profit. When smaller clinics partner with larger, better-funded hospitals, they can pool their resources to care for more patients.
A Jones Lang LaSalle report indicates that real estate investors are increasingly enthusiastic about the profit potential of MOBs. In 2013, 78% of MOB buyers and sellers were investors rather than developers or hospitals—a dramatic shift from 36% in 2012. Hospitals and healthcare providers still control 85% of healthcare real estate and are generally not interested in selling, leading to a tight property market, JLL says. The firm predicts that hospitals may be increasingly willing to reconsider leveraging under-used property assets, in light of strong investor interest in the sector.
Regulations transform hospital design
Though construction of big new hospitals has slowed, healthcare groups are still investing in updates to keep properties functional, safe, and competitive. A twist pointed out by the HFM/ASHE report: Obamacare’s “two-midnight rule,” whereby hospital stays lasting less than two midnights must be billed as outpatient services. Some hospitals are creating dedicated units for observation-status patients, a tactic that may reduce overall length of stay.
Private patient rooms are the new normal, typically flooded with natural light and richly equipped with accessibility features. New Facility Guidelines Institute recommendations for 2014 emphasize sterilization and infection control in both hospitals and outpatient facilities. Some clients are also debating pros and cons of “same-handed” layouts, wherein all patient rooms are similarly oriented, versus traditional “mirror” floorplans with back-to-back headwalls.
“To achieve desired healthcare outcomes, evidence-based design and Lean design are becoming increasingly critical tools to design facilities in ways that minimize patient stress, increase patient and staff safety, and improve staff effectiveness and quality of care,” Altes says. “As a result, we’re seeing increased attention on such things as the incorporation of natural elements; ‘family-centered’ spaces; single-bed, same-handed patient rooms; and decentralized materials management.”
Read BD+C's full 2014 Giants 300 Report
Related Stories
| Apr 26, 2013
Documentary shows 'starchitects' competing for museum project
"The Competition," a new documentary produced by Angel Borrego Cuberto of Madrid, focuses on the efforts of five 'starchitects' to capture the design contract for the new National Museum of Art of Andorra: a small country in the Pyrenees between Spain and France.
| Apr 26, 2013
Solving the parking dilemma in U.S. cities
ArchDaily's Rory Stott yesterday posted an interesting exploration of progressive parking strategies being employed by cities and designers. The lack of curbside and lot parking exacerbates traffic congestion, discourages visitors, and leads to increased vehicles emissions.
| Apr 26, 2013
Decaying city: Exhibit demonstrates the fragility of the man-made world
Theater set designer Johanna Mårtensson built a model cityscape out of bread only to watch it decay.
| Apr 25, 2013
SmithGroupJJR hires Lise Newman as Workplace Studio Leader in Detroit
SmithGroupJJR, one of the nation's largest architecture, engineering and planning firms, has hired architect Lise Newman, AIA, as Workplace Studio leader at its Detroit, Mich. office.
| Apr 25, 2013
Colorado State University, DLR Group team to study 12 high-performance schools
DLR Group and the Institute for the Built Environment at Colorado State University have collaborated on a research project to evaluate the effect of green school design on occupants and long-term building performance.
| Apr 24, 2013
More positive momentum for Architecture Billings Index
All regions and building sectors continue to report positive business conditions
| Apr 24, 2013
North Carolina bill would ban green rating systems that put state lumber industry at disadvantage
North Carolina lawmakers have introduced state legislation that would restrict the use of national green building rating programs, including LEED, on public projects.
| Apr 24, 2013
Los Angeles may add cool roofs to its building code
Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa wants cool roofs added to the city’s building code. He is also asking the Department of Water and Power (LADWP) to create incentives that make it financially attractive for homeowners to install cool roofs.
| Apr 23, 2013
Building material innovation: Concrete cloth simplifies difficult pours
Milliken recently debuted a flexible fabric that allows for concrete installations on slopes, in water, and in other hard to reach places—without the need for molds or mixing.
| Apr 23, 2013
Architects to MoMA: Don't destroy Williams/Tsien project
Richard Meier, Thom Mayne, Steven Holl, Hugh Hardy and Robert A.M. Stern are among the prominent architects who on Monday called for the Museum of Modern Art to reconsider its decision to demolish the former home of the American Folk Art Museum.
