Trade partners are still the odd men out during the early stages of many projects, which can make conflicts, change orders, and delays during construction more likely.
To avoid potential snafus on its new Ambulatory Health Center in Greenfield, Wis., Advocate Aurora Health and the real estate developer Cobalt Partners formed an integrated project team with the general contractor CG Schmidt, the national design firm HGA Architects and Engineers, the mechanical contractor J.F. Ahern, and the commercial electrician Staff Electric, the latter two under a Trade Management Partners (TMP) agreement.
âAdvocate Aurora Health is leading the industry in integrated project delivery,â says Cory Powers, CPD, Principal and Project Manager for HGAâs energy and infrastructure group.
TMP exemplifies collaboration. Through this arrangement, skilled contractors and supplies can engage early in the project and its design process, which helps reduce redundancies, address challenges that relate to cost and constructability, and come up with more efficient solutions.
The clientâs key goal for this five-story 146,200-sf project, located in the 40-acre 84South mixed-use development, was speed to market so it could start seeing patients as soon as possible. That objective led the team to focus on using Lean Construction Methods to accelerate the projectâs schedule.
PUSHING THE ENVELOPE ON PREFAB
Two-fifths of the work within 80 MEP racks were prefabricated.
Â
To this end, the project pushed the limits of prefabrication through the use of 80 multi-trade prefab MEP racks that included long sections of duct work in the corridors.
Forty percent of the above-ceiling MEP work was prefabricated off-site. The construction was completed in 18 months, which gave the community local access to healthcare one month earlier compared to a traditional delivery method. Zero percent rework was achieved versus 15% rework in traditional delivery methods. And there were no injuries building and installing the MEP racks.
The team members worked in tandem from a single 3D BIM model, eliminating miscommunication and the need for re-drawings. And to reduce the risk of design errors, the team relied on state-of-the-art fabrication software, with each component barcoded and shipped to the jobsite along with an installation plan.
Using their mobile devices, workers scanned the barcodes to verify the location for each installation. Once on site and verified, the prefabricated racks were lifted to each floor to be connected and attached, a task completed within an hour of each delivery.
Powers of HGA says that prefabrication emerged as a solution during the teamâs early design discussions. And the buildingâs systems âwere laid out to be modular.â Powers adds that prefab is playing an even more prominent role in the design and construction of Advocate Aurora Healthâs next two hospitals that will include bathrooms and exam rooms assembled off site.
The completed Ambulatory Health Center, which opened August 5, is valued at $55.5 million. The building is the central location for Advocate Aurora Childrenâs Health services that include pediatric cardiology, urology, allergy, dermatology, ENT, neuropsychology, and radiology. It has eight surgical suites, two pain management procedure rooms, four GI suites and two outpatient interventional radiology suites that are the first of their kind in Wisconsin.
With the Health Centerâs recent opening, Advocate Aurora Childrenâs Health can offer more comprehensive pediatric services to the area. The facility also houses Advocate Auroraâs Sports Health services, along with a pediatric sports health gym and classroom space. This space brings increased availability for outpatient orthopedic surgery to patients.
The Health Center is home to midwifery services with a variety of womenâs health services provided, ranging from general health education to family planning and obstetric care. Its outpatient center co-locates orthopedic exam, office, and imaging conveniently at the retail-inspired main entry, with surgical, recovery, and pain management services on floors above.Â
IPD âTHE PATH FORWARDâ
âThis 84South facility is actually one of the very largest outpatient ambulatory sites in all of our Wisconsin and Illinois footprint, and it will enable us to open up access for the people of the broader Greenfield community,â said Advocate Aurora Health's COO Bill Santulli, in an interview with the Milwaukee Business Journal.
When asked why integrated project delivery isnât more common, Powers says that each AEC firm and owner is at different stages of its Lean journey. âYou canât fake experience in an IPD.â Too many firms and owners âare stuck in delivery methods that are based on fearâ that they wouldnât get the same value from an IPD contract.
âBut once you go through one of these, thereâs nothing else like them,â says Powers. âWe can go pretty fast on our own. But itâs so much faster when you donât have to explain everything in the field. The team comes out of the gate drumming the same beat when youâve worked out the details months before the first dirt is broken.â
Mark Lillesand, a Vice President with CG Schmidt, thinks that integrated project design will become more prevalent as more owners become familiar with its benefits, which include âfurthering our relationships with subcontractors.â
Lillesand says his firm now âprefabricates everything we canâ especially now when the coronavirus has raised the stakes for jobsite safety. He adds that on other projects, CG Schmidt has included subs for drywall, steel construction, and enclosures into the early design discussions. âThis is the path forward for us.â
Related Stories
| Nov 2, 2010
Energy Analysis No Longer a Luxury
Back in the halcyon days of 2006, energy analysis of building design and performance was a luxury. Sure, many forward-thinking AEC firms ran their designs through services such as Autodeskâs Green Building Studio and IESâs Virtual Environment, and some facility managers used Honeywellâs Energy Manager and other monitoring software. Today, however, knowing exactly how much energy your building will produce and use is survival of the fittest as energy costs and green design requirements demand precision.
| Nov 2, 2010
Yudelson: âIf It Doesnât Perform, It Canât Be Greenâ
Jerry Yudelson, prolific author and veteran green building expert, challenges Building Teams to think big when it comes to controlling energy use and reducing carbon emissions in buildings.
| Nov 1, 2010
John Pearce: First thing I tell designers: Do your homework!
John Pearce, FAIA, University Architect at Duke University, Durham, N.C., tells BD+Câs Robert Cassidy about the schoolâs construction plans and sustainability efforts, how to land work at Duke, and why heâs proceeding with caution when it comes to BIM.
| Nov 1, 2010
Vancouverâs former Olympic Village shoots for Gold
The first tenants of the Millennium Water development in Vancouver, B.C., were Olympic athletes competing in the 2010 Winter Games. Now the former Olympic Village, located on a 17-acre brownfield site, is being transformed into a residential neighborhood targeting LEED ND Gold. The buildings are expected to consume 30-70% less energy than comparable structures.
| Oct 27, 2010
Grid-neutral education complex to serve students, community
MVE Institutional designed the Downtown Educational Complex in Oakland, Calif., to serve as an educational facility, community center, and grid-neutral green building. The 123,000-sf complex, now under construction on a 5.5-acre site in the cityâs Lake Merritt neighborhood, will be built in two phases, the first expected to be completed in spring 2012 and the second in fall 2014.
| Oct 18, 2010
Worldâs first zero-carbon city on track in Abu Dhabi
Masdar City, the worldâs only zero-carbon city, is on track to be built in Abu Dhabi, with completion expected as early as 2020. Foster + Partners developed the $22 billion cityâs master plan, with Adrian Smith + Gordon Gill Architecture, Aedas, and Lava Architects designing buildings for the projectâs first phase, which is on track to be ready for occupancy by 2015.
| Oct 13, 2010
Test run on the HP Z200 SFF Good Value in a Small Package
Contributing Editor Jeff Yoders tests a new small-form factor, workstation-class desktop in Hewlett-Packardâs line that combines performance of its minitower machine with a smaller chassis and a lower price.
| Oct 13, 2010
Prefab Trailblazer
The $137 million, 12-story, 500,000-sf Miami Valley Hospital cardiac center, Dayton, Ohio, is the first major hospital project in the U.S. to have made extensive use of prefabricated components in its design and construction.
| Oct 13, 2010
Thought Leader
Sundra L. Ryce, President and CEO of SLR Contracting & Service Company, Buffalo, N.Y., talks about her firmâs success in new construction, renovation, CM, and design-build projects for the Navy, Air Force, and Buffalo Public Schools.