Green plumbing fixtures these days are not only designed to be water and energy efficient, they are also designed to save time for installers, users, and maintenance personnel. Moreover, many new products are aimed at improving the user experience as much as they seek to improve the environment.
Modern water-efficient products are a far cry from the industry’s first attempts at low-flow, when the Energy Policy Act of 1992 first mandated the 1.6 gallons per flush (gpf) requirement for toilets. “I would be the first to say that when the industry introduced 1.6-gpf toilets, they were a bit of a disaster,” said Ken Martin, senior director of commercial sales for Delta Faucet Co. “The government mandated the change, the industry tried to scramble to catch up, and although they could easily lower the flows, the water closets didn’t perform. Now with the recent high-efficiency toilets, they’re actually putting some effort into designing those water closets so they actually do work.”
More and more Building Teams are looking to increase water efficiency in projects, but performance is still king. While green is great, fixtures still need to just plain work properly. “Users want them to work the same as or better than the old products,” said Rob Zimmerman, manager of engineering, water conservation, and sustainability for Kohler Co. “Performance matters more than water efficiency. If we’re going to make water-efficient toilets that don’t work as well, and we’ve been through this in the ’90s, people will not accept them.”
Since the dark days of those first 1.6-gpf toilets, manufacturers have met and surpassed the low-flow challenge. Today, there are more eco-friendly faucet, showerhead, and toilet fixtures than ever, and they perform better than ever. Now, manufacturers are moving to provide plenty of options and features that improve both user experience and ease of installation and maintenance.
Expanding the world of choices
If performance is the top consideration, providing lots of options is a close runner-up. “There are some products that are better fits for certain applications than others,” said Zimmerman. “What we’ve tried to do is provide those options.” While a waterless urinal may sound great for the environment, it might not be right for a particular building or application. But whatever the specification or preference, manufacturers aim to fit the bill.
Another benefit to options: they allow plumbers and contractors a step-down program of sorts to familiarize themselves with the new technologies and become comfortable working with them. Kohler offers a variety of flow capacities in both toilets and urinals for just that reason. In addition to the standard 1.6-gpf toilets and 1.0-gpf urinals, the company now offers 1.28- and 1.0-gpf toilets, one-pint urinals, and waterless urinals.
As low-flow becomes more commonplace, companies also are developing innovations that save water in other ways. Low-flow fixtures can be complemented with standard-flow fixtures that guard against wasting water. Delta takes its toilet fixtures a step further with its 81T series flush valves, equipped with automatic dual-flush technology. An H2Optics sensor determines whether to use a 1.6- or 1.1-gal flush by measuring not only the time a user spends at the toilet, as is common with many automatic dual-flush valves, but also the user’s distance from the toilet.
According to Martin, the technology is similar to that of a point-and-shoot digital camera, which sends out a beam of infrared light that bounces off the user to determine how far away he or she is. “The flush valve itself is going to know when you’re within a certain distance, whether sitting down versus standing up,” he said. “It couples that with time to make the determination on whether to go with a full flush or a partial flush, the concept being to try to predict whether you have a liquid load of a solid load to remove.”
Improved sensing technologies also can help faucets avoid unnecessary water waste. Delta’s Proximity Sensor creates a four-inch field around the faucet that activates the flow when a hand enters the field, without the need for sensors or infrared technology. The field is self-calibrating upon installation, adding convenience for the installer. The company also offers a manual option—a faucet that starts and stops with tap of a finger. The one-touch activation improves hygiene, while reducing the number of false activations.
Kohler’s Insight Touchless Technology adapts to the lighting conditions of a restroom to avoid unnecessary activation. Most of the new faucets also include preset shutoff features, which can be set to a stop the flow of water at a desired time.
Give users what they want
The pervasiveness of eco-friendly products on the market also means that manufacturers need to add something extra to their products to differentiate them from every other low-flow fixture out there. Improved user experience and easier installation and maintenance are features that manufacturers are focusing on to make their products stand out.
“We talked to facility managers and plumbers, people who are involved with servicing these products,” said Zimmerman. “They said the real issue for them is maintenance.” In response, Kohler developed the Hybrid energy system for its Insight Touchless Technology. The Hybrid system uses a layered capacitor that collects small electrical discharges from the battery, which the faucet then uses for power. The cell is able to store power, and since the Insight technology uses very small amounts of energy, the battery can last for 30 years or more, according to the manufacturer.
Manufacturers also concentrate on user experience to further improve low-flow technology. One of Delta’s major innovations concerns low-flow showerheads. “We went to 2.5 gallons per minute back when the toilets went to 1.6 gpf, and not a lot of people were all that happy with them. We’re kind of used to them now,” said Martin. The low-flow standard has since dropped to 1.5 gallons per minute, which is relatively easy to achieve simply by restricting the flow of water from the showerhead.
But, says Martin, that low flow can affect the user’s ability to keep warm and still get wet enough to wash. Delta’s solution is H2OKinetics technology, which keeps the flow at 1.5 gpm, but increases the size of the water droplets in order to save both water and energy. “The bigger the drop of water, the more heat it’s going to retain when it hits you,” he said. Since the water stays warmer, users are less likely to crank up the heat. That saves energy and will result in a more satisfactory showering experience.
What’s next for green plumbing?
[pagebreak]
Although plumbing fixture performance has greatly improved in the last two decades, the introduction of increasingly stringent low-flow standards has created problems of its own. “As the flows get driven down, it’s getting more and more challenging to do the job, so to speak, of what the product is supposed to do, particularly in the case of the flush valves or urinals,” said Martin. That is, there is concern whether the new fixtures provide enough water flow to flush the system.
The plumbing products industry is looking to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) WaterSense program to not only increase industry accountability that green products continue to perform, but also to raise consumer awareness and acceptance of these products.
“Their criteria in those standards are not just about lowering the flow, they’re also about how the fixture performs,” said Martin. He points to the showerhead standard that WaterSense recently released, which not only drops water use to two gallons a minute, but also provides for heating, thermal, and wetting property standards that have to be met by the showerhead as well.“In other words, you can’t just put a pencil stream of water out there and drop the flow,” said Martin. “It actually has to feel good.”
WaterSense also provides municipalities a sort of guide to follow when determining local flow standards, helping both manufacturers and specifiers by increasing code uniformity. “What we in the industry get worried about is when individual municipalities unilaterally start cranking down flow rates without any regard for safety or performance issues,” said Martin. “WaterSense is creating a common sort of standard, if you like, that municipalities can look to and say, We’ll just require that.”
The potential of not having enough water in drains and pipes to carry waste from toilets and urinals—the so-called “drain line carry problem”—is already starting to become the next big concern in eco-friendly plumbing. “Here’s the problem: you’ve got a big infrastructure already in place throughout the country that’s designed to remove waste on the assumption that these toilets are going to flush 3.5 or more gallons per flush,” said Martin. “These systems work fine at 3.5 gpf, but when they start dropping the water flows that go into the sewer, then you’re basically going to end up with sludge.”
Municipalities in the U.S. have not faced this problem yet, but that may be because low-flow toilets and urinals are still relatively new, said Kohler’s Zimmerman. “I have heard very sporadic comments and anecdotes out there, but nothing that suggests a major trend,” he said. “There are still a lot of water-wasting toilets, urinals, and faucets in the marketplace. As those gradually get changed out and the amount of water in the system is decreased, the drain line problem may sneak up on us.” BD+C
A ‘Nonaqueous’ Way to Conserve in the Restroom
While water and energy conservation get a lot of the fanfare, PMRG Realty, a building management company, found another way to help its client improve its ecological footprint at a Dallas office building. PMRG recently renovated the restrooms at the one million-sf Campbell Center office complex, but found that paper towels were being wasted. “They fall to the floor and aren’t picked up, so the tidiness and waste were the two main reasons we were looking for some sort of solution,” said Rebecca Jack, assistant property manager for the complex.
PMRG solved the property manager’s problem with Bobrick-Koala TowelMate Towel Dispenser Retainers. These stainless steel inserts fit into existing folded towel dispensers and limit the number of paper towels that can be dispensed at one time to just a single towel. This prevents guests from pulling out a handful of towels and possibly dropping some on the floor. According to the manufacturer, the TowelMate reduces paper usage and waste by as much as 20%. The inserts accommodate recycled paper towels for added conservation.
In the two months since they were installed in her building, says Jack, the retainers have worked flawlessly. “Because of this product, there’s no waste going on, and the restrooms are tidy,” she says. BD+C
Related Stories
Sponsored | Metals | Jul 20, 2015
Life cycle assessment, and why you should care
LCA is a way of quantifying the environmental impact generated by the manufacture and delivery of a product.
Green | May 5, 2015
Top three 2030 Challenge trends
The growth of IPD is among the key takeaways from the USGBC Region 7 Conference.
Green | Feb 23, 2015
State of the green union, and the next big shift in sustainability
The history of the green movement offers cues that we are on the precipice of another significant shift in the green union.
Multifamily Housing | Feb 18, 2015
Make It Right unveils six designs for affordable housing complex
BNIM is among the six firms involved in the project.
Energy Efficiency | Jan 28, 2015
An urban wind and solar energy system that may actually work
The system was designed to take advantage of a building's air flow and generate energy even if its in the middle of a city.
| Dec 29, 2014
Leo A Daly's minimally invasive approach to remote field site design [BD+C's 2014 Great Solutions Report]
For the past six years, Leo A Daly has been designing sites for remote field stations with near-zero ecological disturbance. The firm's environmentally delicate work was named a 2014 Great Solution by the editors of Building Design+Construction.
| Dec 23, 2014
5 tech trends transforming BIM/VDC
From energy modeling on the fly to prefabrication of building systems, these advancements are potential game changers for AEC firms that are serious about building information modeling.
| Dec 19, 2014
Zaha Hadid unveils dune-shaped HQ for Emirati environmental management company
Zaha Hadid Architects released designs for the new headquarters of Emirati environmental management company Bee’ah, revealing a structure that references the shape and motion of a sand dune.
| Oct 30, 2014
CannonDesign releases guide for specifying flooring in healthcare settings
The new report, "Flooring Applications in Healthcare Settings," compares and contrasts different flooring types in the context of parameters such as health and safety impact, design and operational issues, environmental considerations, economics, and product options.
| Oct 27, 2014
Report estimates 1.2 million people experience LEED-certified retail centers daily
The "LEED In Motion: Retail" report includes USGBC’s conceptualization of the future of retail, emphasizing the economic and social benefit of green building for retailers of all sizes and types.