In the rapidly changing world of virtual design and construction, the mechanical-electrical-plumbing component of building information modeling has earned a reputation as something of a technology laggard. BIM for structural work? Beautiful. For architectural design? Lovely. For general construction? Terrif’. But BIM for MEP? Not so hot.
That negative perception is changing, as MEP engineers find new ways to put BIM to more effective use in their work—which, in the case of a complex project like a hospital, can account for 30-40% of total construction costs.
Southland Industries, Garden Grove, Calif., is one such innovator. The design-build mechanical contractor is applying electronic surveying technology to BIM and 3D models to enhance the accuracy and reliability of prefabricated HVAC and plumbing systems. In so doing, it is saving time and money on complex hospital projects while improving quality.
Forging a unified Building Team
Three years ago, a major client commissioned Southland and its partners to design-build a complex of three facilities totaling more than a half-million square feet—a multi-story patient tower with a diagnostic/treatment center, a health services building, and a central utility plant.
The Building Team—which in addition to Southland included HMC Architects (architect), Ted Jacob Engineering Group (M/E OR and electrical COR), Sasco Electric (design-assist electrical contractor), Berger Bros. (exterior framing), Sharpe Interior Systems (interior framing), and McCarthy Building Cos. (GC)—had worked together successfully on a previous job for this healthcare provider. The client wanted to keep the same team and bring them together early in the design process, a practice that had not been followed in the earlier project.
Southland’s role was to provide design-assist mechanical/plumbing services. According to Patrick Reed, Contract Executive in the firm’s healthcare division, the company grasped the opportunity to make better use of the available BIM/3D documents to improve its prefabrication of mechanical and plumbing systems.
Southland had been prefabbing piping and sheet metal in its 80,000-sf shop in Garden Grove, Calif., for decades. For the new project, Reed and his team planned to apply electronic surveying technology normally used for exterior applications—in this case, Trimble Total Station RTS-555, with AutoCAD CADMEP+ solution software—to the BIM models of the interior HVAC and plumbing systems.
“Our Northern California office had used a system like this in previous projects,” says Reed. For the new project, the goal was to take the data from the BIM model and prefab the mechanical and plumbing systems in whole assemblies—for 100% of the job.
“You can run into problems because the documents don’t match what’s out in the field,” says Reed. The surveying system would, it was hoped, provide the accuracy needed to make sure all the prefabbed pieces fit together perfectly at the site.
Dialing down the tolerances
Linking the interior survey to the BIM model proved an enormous time saver for prefabbing and installing such components as piping insert hangers, seismic inserts, and sleeves. “We had not preassembled our hangers before,” says Reed. Instead, hangers would be delivered to the field and cut on site. “The Trimble system allowed us to set a zero point on the metal deck so that we could prefab hangers to a half-inch accuracy in height,” he says.
The system also provided a level of accuracy of plus or minus one-eighth of an inch, versus a quarter-inch industry standard. “We had a reproducibility that allowed us to use 98-99% of the inserts and prefabricated hangers, compared to about 85% in previous jobs,” says Reed. “Three-D coordination allowed that level of reproducibility.”
Plumbing and pipefitting installation was vastly improved. Instead of having crews of five or six using string and tape to measure and lay out mechanical system inserts, Southland was able to use two-person crews to do the same job more accurately, using the electronic survey equipment. “It took about two weeks of training to learn how to use the device and the methodology,” recalls Reed. “After becoming proficient with the device, their productivity excelled.”
That training paid off in a 50% time savings for making these measurements. “A building on the scale we were working on would have 10,000 to 15,000 data points,” says Reed. “We were hitting 800 or 900 points per deck per day. We could lay out a 25,000-sf floor plate in three or four days with a two-man crew. That would take a typical crew of six a week to perform the same task.” Even more important, says Reed, “Our accuracy was 99% in the field.”
The Southland team took that expertise and applied it to mechanical system penetrations through framed walls. “In the past, we’d use tape and string,” says Reed. “With Trimble, we’d go out with the model and make the measurements. Trimble was much more accurate, and this cut down problems with the drywall framer,” Sharpe Interior Systems.
Improving logistical flow on the job
Combining the interior survey with the BIM model produced other benefits as well. “To us, prefab is more than just cutting pipe to length and welding it in the shop, or assembling ductwork in the shop,” says Reed. “Now, it’s taking the information from the BIM model so that we have right-size batching of whole sections—preassembled, presoldered, prebraced—to ship to the site.” Reed says his team learned a lot about logistics, just-in-time workflow, and right-size batching—packaging, documenting, and numbering all the parts and pieces in the floor plan.
And because Southland was able to get its work done more quickly, the contractor could move along faster, too. “McCarthy could pour a deck every three or four days,” says Reed.
However, Reed acknowledges that melding the electronic survey data into the BIM model did not always work perfectly. “In some cases we had limitations when the files were too large,” he says. He cautions that electronic surveying for interior measurements works best for large-scale projects with repetitive floor plans—a high-rise hotel, for example.
Reed’s team also found that its original system for numbering and ordering hangers didn’t work in the field and had to be changed midstream. Shipping preassembled trapeze hangers with the rods already installed also proved overly cumbersome. Instead, they taped the struts and other pieces to the rods and had crews put them together in the field. “That solution sounds counterintuitive, but it was 15% faster to do it that way,” says Reed.
But there’s no thought of going back to the old stick-and-tape ways of measuring interiors. Southland has adopted a standard of prefabricating 100% of all hangers for major new construction work. “The Trimble system’s accuracy eliminates a lot of human error,” says Reed. “It’s enabling us to take our prefab capability to the next level, to plan further in advance without having to do rework in the field.”
Related Stories
| Jul 16, 2013
As the U.S. economy sputters back to life, contractors wait for the green light on projects [2013 Giants 300 Report]
There are enough positive indictors in the economy to justify greenlighting projects, but building owners and developers remain reluctant to pull the trigger.
| Jul 16, 2013
Robotics: A new way to demolish buildings
A robot prototype uses water jets to break up concrete structures and then sucks up the water and debris for reuse and recycling.
| Jul 15, 2013
Mergers and acquisitions transform engineering sector [2013 Giants 300 Report]
Merger and acquisition deals by MEP, commissioning, structural, and specialty engineering firms were up 14% nationwide in 2012 compared with 2011.
| Jul 15, 2013
Top Engineering/Architecture Firms [2013 Giants 300 Report]
Jacobs, AECOM, Parsons Brinckerhoff top Building Design+Construction's 2013 ranking of the largest engineering/architecture firms in the United States.
| Jul 15, 2013
Top Architecture/Engineering Firms [2013 Giants 300 Report]
Stantec, HOK, HDR top Building Design+Construction's 2013 ranking of the largest architecture/engineering firms in the United States.
| Jul 15, 2013
Top Architecture Firms [2013 Giants 300 Report]
Gensler, Perkins+Will, NBBJ top Building Design+Construction's 2013 ranking of the largest architecture firms in the United States.
| Jul 15, 2013
Zaha Hadid unveils plan for boutique condo development in New York
Related Companies taps the London-based architect for the 11-story 520 West 28th Street residential development adjacent to the High Line in Chelsea.
| Jul 12, 2013
12 award-winning healthcare projects [slideshow]
AIA's Academy of Architecture for Health announced the recipients of the 2013 AIA National Healthcare Design Awards.
| Jul 11, 2013
Bill to borrow more for college spending in Michigan criticized due to ‘higher-ed bubble’
An amendment to a Michigan appropriations budget authorizes an increase in state debt to pay for state university construction projects. But some experts see a “higher education bubble” on the horizon, and said more taxpayer debt for more buildings is a bad idea.