Designed by H. H. Richardson in the 1870s to serve the city's burgeoning Back Bay neighborhood, Trinity Church in the City of Boston would come to represent the essence of the Richardsonian Romanesque style, with its clay tile roof, abundant use of polychromy, rough-faced stone, heavy arches, and massive size. Its 9,500 tons rested on four elephantine granite pyramids, which were set atop 4,000 wooden pilings to prevent the structure from sinking into Back Bay's marshy wetlands.
PHOTOS: SHAWMUT DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION |
Some 125 years after its completion, Trinity Church had grown into one of the largest Episcopal congregations in the country, holding 19 services a week and averaging 1,200 worshippers on Sundays. Trinity also drew 100,000 tourists a year, thanks to its status as a National Historic Landmark and one of the AIA's “10 Most Important Buildings in the United States.” Add to that more than 140 community programs that kept meeting rooms bustling 15 hours a day, six days a week, and it was easy to see how Trinity needed room for expansion.
Unfortunately, the passage of time had taken its toll on the building. The church's precious murals, stained glass, and intricate stonework had all been marred by a century-plus of wear. Worse, below ground, fluctuating water tables had damaged the wood pilings, threatening Trinity's very stability.
PHOTOS: SHAWMUT DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION |
In 1995, church leaders inaugurated three years of master planning that led to a full-scale restoration and expansion of the church. The plan, like the structure itself, rested on four pillars: 1) return Trinity to its original beauty; 2) expand the church for future generations, 3) update the heating and cooling systems, and 4) keep the church operating during reconstruction.
Heavenly artwork
John La Farge, the father of the American Mural Movement, decorated the interior of Trinity Church with the goal of making parishioners feel as though they were “walking into a painting.” Bringing the church back to its original grandeur required years of historical research, planning, and troubleshooting.
To keep the renovation effort from interrupting religious services and tour groups, general contractor Shawmut Design and Construction and architects/preservationists Goody Clancy installed a series of mobile access towers high above the main sanctuary. Instead of having the usual ungainly wooden beams planted throughout the church, the scaffolding was supported by steel poles planted into the building's stone foundation pyramids.
Trinity Church occupies a tight, urban site in the heart of Boston’s bustling Copley Square. The Building Team focused on minimizing the impact construction would have on the neighborhood’s offices, hotels, and shops. PHOTO: FARRELL ASSOCIATES CONSTRUCTION PHOTOGRAPHY |
Work focused first on restoring basic structural integrity: repointing masonry, re-roofing, and installing flashing. The team went to great lengths to replicate and restore the original red mortar and replace broken stonework, much of which came from quarries that had vanished long ago. Fortunately, a cache of original stone remnants discovered under the church's west porch allowed the team to complete the repairs in fine fashion.
Moving on to Trinity's artwork, the conservators—including experts from John Canning Painting & Conservation Studios and Gianfranco Pocobene Studio—engaged in a nearly yearlong process that included restoring La Farge's murals and surrounding decoration, bringing back the original brick red background specified by Richardson and La Farge.
Growing God's house
Trinity's biggest concern, however, was lack of space for the growing congregation. Although church leaders had considered expanding into nearby buildings, Trinity's location in a tightly packed urban center limited that option. Instead of looking horizontally, Shawmut, Goody Clancy, and structural engineer LeMessurier Consultants turned their gaze downward to the basement.
Little more than a large crawlspace at the start of renovation, the basement eventually became a 13,000-sf addition, known as the Undercroft. Creating this space required lowering the basement by four feet, which sometimes had to be done by hand to avoid disturbing the sanctuary above or damaging wooden pilings below. Damaged pilings were repaired and capped with metal sections. Engineers also installed pumps to keep the pilings below the water line.
The Parish House, used for classes, meetings, and rehearsals, sits adjacent to Trinity Church and also was completely renovated and restored. PHOTO: DAVID LAMB ARCHITECTURAL PHOTOGRAPHY |
The excavation left a vast space that exposed the handsome raw granite of Trinity's pyramid footings. The stone was complemented by warm cherry millwork and, inspired by the church's collection of stained glass, a commissioned series of pivoting glass doors that allowed the Undercroft to be portioned up into rooms of various sizes.
Saving more than souls
Technically speaking, the Building Team's most difficult task proved to be updating the HVAC system. Due to its location, the building had no real “back end,” and M/E engineer Cosentini Associates determined that installing an HVAC system in the attic would pose a risk (moisture and vibration) to the works of art below.
The team turned to geothermal energy for a solution. Installing the geothermal pumps meant drilling six wells through soil and bedrock to a depth of 1,500 feet—twice the height of the nearby John Hancock Tower. The job was made doubly difficult by the need to drill without disturbing church services or social activity in adjacent Copley Square. Shawmut solved this problem by erecting noise-reducing wooden structures around the drill system.
All told, the Trinity renovation proved to be one of Boston's most remarkable transformations, earning numerous awards and acclaim from across the nation. Today, with its lusciously restored decoration, its gentle embrace of environmental values, and its firm commitment to future growth, Trinity carries on its founders' vibrant religious and community mission.
Related Stories
Digital Twin | May 24, 2021
Digital twin’s value propositions for the built environment, explained
Ernst & Young’s white paper makes its cases for the technology’s myriad benefits.
Wood | May 14, 2021
What's next for mass timber design?
An architect who has worked on some of the nation's largest and most significant mass timber construction projects shares his thoughts on the latest design trends and innovations in mass timber.
Cultural Facilities | Apr 1, 2021
A Connecticut firm deploys design to assist underserved people and communities
Hartford, Conn.-based JCJ Architecture traces its roots to 1936, when the U.S. was just coming out of an economic depression and its unemployment rate was still 14%. In 2021, with the country trying to recover economically from the impact of the coronavirus, and with questions about social inequity entering the public debate as rarely before, JCJ has focused its design work on projects and clients that are committed to social responsibility and advocacy, particularly for underserved or marginalized communities.
Cultural Facilities | Mar 1, 2021
Moise Safra Center completes in New York City
The project will act as a second home for the Jewish community it serves.
Market Data | Feb 24, 2021
2021 won’t be a growth year for construction spending, says latest JLL forecast
Predicts second-half improvement toward normalization next year.
Giants 400 | Dec 16, 2020
Download a PDF of all 2020 Giants 400 Rankings
This 70-page PDF features AEC firm rankings across 51 building sectors, disciplines, and specialty services.
Giants 400 | Dec 3, 2020
2020 Cultural Facilities Giants: Top architecture, engineering, and construction firms in the U.S. cultural facilities sector
AECOM, Arup, and Populous head BD+C's rankings of the nation's largest cultural facilities sector architecture, engineering, and construction firms, as reported in the 2020 Giants 400 Report.
Government Buildings | Nov 13, 2020
Tax shortfalls nip government projects in the bud
Federal contracts are proceeding, but states and cities are delaying, deferring, and looking for private investment.
Cultural Facilities | Oct 13, 2020
Thailand’s Elephant Museum reinforces the bond between humans and beasts
The complex, in Surin Province, was built with 480,000 clay bricks.
Libraries | Sep 25, 2020
Major renovation to Providence’s downtown library is completed
The $29 million project adds light and collaborative space to a 67-year-old wing.