When Sara Lee Corp. changed its name to Hillshire Brands and relocated from the suburbs to downtown Chicago in December 2012, the company gained a new lease on life.
Hillshire moved a portion of its corporate headquarters into the newly renovated, four-story 400 South Jefferson Street building in the city’s West Loop. Built in 1944 for the Newman-Rudolph Lithographing Co., the 230,000-sf structure was stripped down to its cast-in-place concrete frame and rebuilt with a modern glass curtain wall façade, new passenger elevators, major building system updates, and an indoor parking garage.
The $70 million, fast-track project—led by Proteus Group (architect, core and shell), Leopardo (general contractor, core and shell), Perkins+Will (architect, interior build-out), Clune (general contractor, interior build-out), Sterling Bay Cos. (owner/developer), Environmental Systems Design (MEP/FP), Project Management Advisors (project management), and Colliers (tenant representative)—was completed in just 10 months using a BIM/VDC/IPD workflow.
The core and shell team had the full 10 months to complete its portion of the project, but the interior build-out team had just four months. The interior work entailed four general office floors, three test kitchens, and a tower housing conference rooms.
Initially, the base building contractor modeled the as-built conditions using BIM, after which the interior design was added by Perkins+Will, before releasing the model to Environmental Systems Design. ESD had just four weeks to complete bid and permit documentation for the building’s MEP and fire protection systems.
5 Tips for collaborating with BIM
1. All consultants working in BIM should coordinate during architectural model development, rather than after completion of the architectural model. Communicating your expectations prevents coordination issues from occurring later in the project design. In the case of the Hillshire HQ project, the architects and engineers met before the BIM model was initiated to talk about past concerns and project design expectations.2. Set up trade drawing sheets at the start of the project. Designers often forget to set up trade drawing sheets and don’t think about them until the end of the project when they want to print. The absence of trade drawing sheets can hold up a project. As cool as the 3D model is, the 2D drawing is what everyone will use after the design has been completed.3. BIM programs are not CAD; don’t use them as if they were. Most AEC professionals learn how to design in 2D CAD, so when moving into BIM they try to replicate what is done in CAD, like drawing text boxes, without utilizing the “smarts” in BIM. In addition, understand that you’re working in a 3D environment and you need to pay attention to the “Z” axis, or the vertical plane. For the first time, height needs to be defined. How high are you mounting the ductwork or the light fixture? Those questions need to be answered early on.4. Use BIM to create ventilation schedules. Take advantage of the information already held in the model, such as the defined volume and ceiling height of each room. Let the BIM model fill out ventilation schedules and calculate air quantities of individual air terminals.5. Set up electrical equipment properties and panel schedules at the beginning. This speeds up circuiting in the end. Every time a piece of equipment is placed into the BIM model, fill in the information about the piece of equipment from the start so that schedules auto-populate at the end.— Amanda Carter
Could BIM really speed up design, eliminate coordination issues among the trades, and limit requests for information during construction? ESD set out to find the answer.
Beginning with Autodesk’s Revit MEP, ESD engineers created a 3D interactive model. Using Revit’s automatic scheduling feature, they simulated the building’s potential loads, including air quantities and electrical loads. Defining the space types and square footage of each room within the model allowed BIM to automatically calculate the ventilation requirements of the applicable mechanical codes for each space. These quantities were scheduled and allowed the mechanical engineers to assure that the proper amount of supply air would be provided to each room.
Similarly, by defining specific loads and demand factors for the electrical elements within the Revit model, the panel schedules were able to self-populate and properly calculate both the total connected and demand load for each piece of electrical equipment in the building. This allowed for proper sizing of over-current protection for each piece of equipment throughout the electrical distribution, as well as the associated feeders and conduit.
Because each of the schedules was based on the definition of elements within the model, they were able to self-populate and automatically update to changes, allowing for fewer coordination issues within the construction documents. The model also helped the team lay out the ductwork so that it coordinated with light fixture locations in the building’s open ceiling layout, and ensured that the design of the electrical equipment met the dimensions of the designated equipment areas.
Together, these elements produced a complete model of the building’s MEP infrastructure with much more certainty than the traditional 2D modeling, and did so within the tight time frame.
Unfortunately, however, BIM can’t read the human mind. When the base building contractor altered the layout of the large electrical rooms in the field, the project’s contractor couldn’t build out the space as designed by ESD, per the base building model. Switches and equipment were housed in different locations within the space, resulting in an RFI that required re-coordination.
After the contractor in the field proposed a couple of options for the final equipment layout and ESD submitted the redesign, the large electrical rooms were built within the desired time frame. Despite this challenge, using BIM to coordinate between trades on the front end still resulted in fewer RFIs and allowed the Building Team to meet the tight design and construction schedule, avoiding major discrepancies in the field.
Comparing 2D to 3D for Performance
As a comparison, ESD previously designed a similar project in 2D CAD. This second project employed the same lead engineers and interiors contractors, with similar square footage and a large commercial kitchen, and was designed and constructed as the base building was being completed. The result? The Hillshire headquarters had approximately half the RFIs of the 2D-designed project.
To further test the success of BIM in the field, ESD selected a few locations throughout the Hillshire headquarters where “snapshots” of the Revit model were compared to post-construction photos of the same space. In every case, side-by-side visual comparisons showed that the construction documents were almost identical to what was installed in the field. Considering the speed at which both design and construction were completed, it was amazing that the end result so closely matched the original design.
While BIM was used on the project primarily to coordinate between trades during design, in the end, it helped the entire Building Team meet a tight schedule, eliminate coordination problems between the trades, and limit RFIs in the field.
Amanda Carter, FE, is an Electrical Engineer and Associate at Environmental Systems Design, Chicago (www.esdesign.com). She can be reached at acarter@esdglobal.com.
Related Stories
| Jul 17, 2014
A harmful trade-off many U.S. green buildings make
The Urban Green Council addresses a concern that many "green" buildings in the U.S. have: poor insulation.
| Jul 17, 2014
A high-rise with outdoor, vertical community space? It's possible! [slideshow]
Danish design firm C.F. Møller has developed a novel way to increase community space without compromising privacy or indoor space.
| Jul 17, 2014
How the 'pop-up' retail concept can be applied to workplace design
“Pop-up” has rapidly become one of the most pervasive design trends in recent years. It has given us pop-up shops and pop-up restaurants, but can it be applied to the professional work environment?
Sponsored | | Jul 17, 2014
A major hop forward
The construction of efficient metal buildings has helped Perrault Farms expand its hops-harvesting business.
| Jul 17, 2014
22 land questions to decide if your build site works
When you’re ready to build, land needs a serious amount of attention. Since it can singlehandedly shift your building plans, land must be investigated, questioned, and eyed from every angle. SPONSORED CONTENT
| Jul 16, 2014
Mergers and acquisitions of AE firms on track for strong year in 2014
Through the first six months of 2014, Morrissey Goodale tracked 101 sales of U.S.-based architecture and engineering firms, roughly the same amount as during the first six months of 2013.
| Jul 16, 2014
Learning design fundamentals in the digital age – How to balance learning and technology
My colleague and I were once asked an insightful question by a Civil Engineering Professor that sparked an interesting conversation. He’d been told about our software by some of his students who had used it during their summer internship. SPONSORED CONTENT
| Jul 16, 2014
Check out this tree-like skyscraper concept for vertical farming
Aprilli Design Studio has stepped forward with a new idea for a vertical farm, which is intended to resemble a giant tree. It uses lightweight decks as outdoor growing space, adding up to about 25 acres of space.
| Jul 16, 2014
User input on aquatics center keeps students in the swim [2014 Building Team Awards]
Collaborative spirit abounds in the expansion and renovation of a high school pool facility in suburban Chicago.
| Jul 16, 2014
Nonresidential construction starts up 34% in June
Construction starts for nonresidential work saw a surge in June, rising more than a third compared with the previous month, according to Reed Construction Data.
