The resolution of global construction disputes remained steady in 2016, and the average time it took to resolve those disputes declined bit, according to the seventh annual Arcadis Global Construction Disputes Report 2017, which is subtitled “Avoiding the Same Pitfalls.”
This report reflects the construction disputes that Arcadis’ team handled around the world. The report infers that the roadblocks to expeditious and less cost dispute resolution often stem from the need for better contract administration, robust documentation, and a proactive approach to risk management.
“Our industry contains the best problem solvers in the world,” the report states. “But there often seems to be a lack of ability or willingness of the project participants to compromise and resolve disputes at the earliest and most inexpensive stage possible.” Roy Cooper, Senior Vice President of Arcadis Contract Solutions, attributes disputes to “human emotions that can impede settlements, as they do with physical factors such as differing site conditions and design errors.”
The world’s economic expansion generally is not seen as an impediment to resolving contract disputes. Global growth is projected at 3.5% in 2017, and 3.6% in 2018, according to the International Monetary Fund.
While the outlook is positive, the report sees risks in labor contraction, increasing commodities prices, and uncertain immigration policies. “A potential widening of global imbalances, coupled with sharp currency exchange rate movements, should those occur in response to major policy shifts, could further intensify protectionist pressures.”
A summary of Arcadis' findings for 2016. Image: Arcadis US
That being said, the global average construction dispute value declined in 2016 by nearly 7% to US$42.8 million (and that includes one US$2 billion dispute Arcadis handled). Asia averaged the highest dispute value, at US$84 million, and the United Kingdom saw a double-digit increase in its average dispute value, to US$34 million.
The global average length of a dispute also fell slightly last year, to 14 months. North America’s dispute duration was the longest of all Arcadis’ regions, an average of 15.6 months. For the third consecutive year, the most common cause for disputes in North America in 2016 was errors and/or omissions in the contract documentation.
Asia had the highest average dispute value last year; North America the longest time it took to resolve a dispute. Image: Arcadis
Globally, Arcadis identifies failure to properly administer a contract among the five most common causes of disputes, along with poorly drafted or incomplete/unsubstantiated claims; the failure of an employer, contractor or subcontractor to understand or comply with its contractual obligations; errors and omissions in the contract; and incomplete design information or employer requires.
The most common methods to resolve construction disputes were, in order of preference, party-to-party negotiation, arbitration, and mediation.
And the most important activities to avoid disputes were led by proper contract administration, accurate documents, and fair and appropriate risk and balances in contracts.
Related Stories
Market Data | Dec 13, 2016
ABC predicts modest growth for 2017 nonresidential construction sector; warns of vulnerability for contractor
“The U.S. economy continues to expand amid a weak global economy and, despite risks to the construction industry, nonresidential spending should expand 3.5 percent in 2017,” says ABC Chief Economist Anirban Basu.
Market Data | Dec 2, 2016
Nonresidential construction spending gains momentum
Nonresidential spending is now 2.6 percent higher than at the same time one year ago.
Market Data | Nov 30, 2016
Marcum Commercial Construction Index reports industry outlook has shifted; more change expected
Overall nonresidential construction spending in September totaled $690.5 billion, down a slight 0.7 percent from a year earlier.
Industry Research | Nov 30, 2016
Multifamily millennials: Here is what millennial renters want in 2017
It’s all about technology and convenience when it comes to the things millennial renters value most in a multifamily facility.
Market Data | Nov 29, 2016
It’s not just traditional infrastructure that requires investment
A national survey finds strong support for essential community buildings.
Industry Research | Nov 28, 2016
Building America: The Merit Shop Scorecard
ABC releases state rankings on policies affecting construction industry.
Multifamily Housing | Nov 28, 2016
Axiometrics predicts apartment deliveries will peak by mid 2017
New York is projected to lead the nation next year, thanks to construction delays in 2016
Market Data | Nov 22, 2016
Construction activity will slow next year: JLL
Risk, labor, and technology are impacting what gets built.
Market Data | Nov 17, 2016
Architecture Billings Index rebounds after two down months
Decline in new design contracts suggests volatility in design activity to persist.
Market Data | Nov 11, 2016
Brand marketing: Why the B2B world needs to embrace consumers
The relevance of brand recognition has always been debatable in the B2B universe. With notable exceptions like BASF, few manufacturers or industry groups see value in generating top-of-mind awareness for their products and services with consumers.