In the ever changing world of technology and innovation, we now have tools that are designed to increase our productivity and communication. This move toward a “world is flat” format of conducting business is constantly evolving and thus communication and collaboration must continually be enhanced.
Capital facility projects will always require expertise from either local specialists or industry leaders within a specific field. Forming a collaborative environment and cohesive team, due to potential location and cost issues, can be challenging at best. Only by harnessing the opportunities available through technology and processes will project team members increase their chances for establishing cohesiveness to ensure project success.
THE LOCKER ROOM CONCEPT
Keeping with the “world is flat” format of conducting business, it is not uncommon for a capital facility project to have nonlocal team members involved from remote cities. Obviously, having all local contractors would be ideal, but the skill and expertise required for a multimillion dollar healthcare project is not always available locally. Identifying opportunities for team interaction that provide the most value to the client is critical to project success.
For example, projects typically provide onsite offices with various meeting rooms, yet these spaces do little to accommodate and promote a true team atmosphere. Wouldn’t it make sense to create an environment where all “players” on the team could collocate, similar to a football locker room?
Imagine applying the team locker room concept and dynamics to the design and construction of a building project, thus creating a "Project Big Room." Much like a football team in a locker room developing their game plan for an upcoming season, the entire project team (architect, engineers, contractors, and subcontractors) could use a similar philosophy and approach to design, plan, and construct a capital project.
Collocating in a Big Room environment fosters collaborative behavior that encourages brainstorming and innovation. Teams within the Big Room can be broken into position groups, much like linebackers and quarterbacks. Groups focused on various aspects of the project such as site, mechanical, structural, interiors, enclosure, etc., are formed, very early on, to tackle different issues and challenges. Each group is tasked with identifying solutions to reduce time, waste, and cost to the benefit of the project.
For example, by working together early in the process, the enclosure group can eliminate duplication of efforts. Instead of the architect developing detailed drawings that would then be altered or redone by the fabricator, they merely complete concept drawings which are shared with the group and then the fabricator completes the detailed design. All meetings and interactions take place in the common space that is shared with the other groups thus opening the lines of communication and input.
A meeting cadence is established to ensure team members are communicating on a daily basis, whether in person or by phone, as opposed to once or twice a month.
If you are thinking this sounds a lot like integrated project delivery, you are right. But, the Big Room does not require an Integrated Form of Agreement. It harnesses the philosophy and culture without the contract.
GAME WEEK
Interaction in the Big Room would be structured very similar to preparations for the game of the week. An onsite team meeting is scheduled for the beginning of the week to help structure the goals and activities ahead. This meeting allows the various groups to report on their progress and to share their ideas for the upcoming week. It is imperative that the entire group understand how their individual parts fit into the bigger picture and to collaborate to achieve efficiencies. From there, teams “huddle” each morning for five or 10 minutes to touch base and stay informed.
One of the tools used in the Big Room to create the master schedule is Pull Planning. A Pull Planning session outlines all activities to enable a global perspective of each group’s responsibilities. Scheduling, utilizing Pull Planning, requires establishing specific milestones and then pulling back from identified dates to generate event timelines. This method of scheduling is challenging at first, but after practicing, the expectations of pulling rather than pushing toward a milestone start to drive out waste in your project schedule. With a milestone schedule and a pull plan in place, the teams can then work through their tasks and resolve any issues in their focused groups.
An additional tool that is helpful in a Big Room structure is the use of A3 methodology for issue resolution and decision making. An A3 is a “Lean” tool used to conduct a thorough analysis of a current state. It helps to create a one-page story on a specific topic or issue that makes it easy for any member of the entire team to read and understand what the group is working to resolve. Regularly posting A3 documents on the walls of the Big Room is a great way to create further collaboration across different focused groups. An example of the value of an A3 is apparent when analyzing the benefits of different building materials on a project.
Referring back to our previously mentioned Enclosure group, an A3 could be used to evaluate brick verses glass curtain wall for the building exterior. The A3, created by the enclosure group, would be reviewed by the structural group to determine cost savings or impact between the two. While the enclosure group feels there are advantages to choosing brick, the structural group identifies the disadvantages due to the added weight and required supports that would drive up the cost on their scope of work.
Other groups also have the opportunity to provide input prior to final decision making. The goal is to allow the A3 to tell a story that ultimately identifies a solution that balances value, cost, and innovation.
As teams outline challenges and identify steps for resolution, A3’s are posted so other groups that may be impacted by these changes can review the plan and react if necessary. These discussions save design effort, improve the quality of the project, and ultimately deliver a savings to the project. During the entire planning week, each group strategizes in the Big Room and posts their progress which enhances collaboration much more so than meeting behind closed doors.
At the end of the week, a meeting similar to a final walk through before the big game is conducted. Each group presents their weekly accomplishments and discusses any remaining obstacles. A final report presented to client leadership provides insight as to potential changes or project savings.
During planning, it can be determined how much repetition is needed on the project. For example, maybe the entire team is brought together in-person every other week or maybe just once a month. One nice feature of using a “flat business” platform is that technology has created ways for teams to have a Big Room that conceivably meets every week, alternating in-person and virtual meetings. You can keep the same group structure and meeting cadence whether in-person or through conference calls and web conferencing.
While in-person meetings are more effective, keeping the cadence of the group planning virtually creates a stronger focus on the project and in turn makes the in-person team meetings run more smoothly. The true goal of this collaborative focus is to huddle daily and meet every week with an entire team focused on accomplishing as much as possible during the time the groups are together in the Big Room.
CONCLUSION
On a major capital facility project, team performance can make or break the ultimate outcome. Engaging the most knowledgeable experts and skilled talent is critical in delivering the most value to the client. However, these vital team members may not be locally based which can pose challenges due to onsite availability.
Implementing collocation via the Big Room concept will remove silos, ensure a cadence for daily communication, promote collaboration and elevate your chances for success. When setting up your next project, you may want to consult your favorite football team’s gameday strategy for inspiration.
About the Authors
Stephen Powell is a Consultant and Magnus Nilsson is Senior Consultant with CBRE Healthcare.
Related Stories
Market Data | Nov 27, 2023
Number of employees returning to the office varies significantly by city
While the return-to-the-office trend is felt across the country, the percentage of employees moving back to their offices varies significantly according to geography, according to Eptura’s Q3 Workplace Index.
Resiliency | Nov 27, 2023
All levels of government need to act to cope with climate-driven flooding and sea level rise
The latest National Climate Assessment highlights the need for local, state, and federal governments to adopt policies to mitigate the effects of climate-driven flooding and sea level rise, according to a policy expert with the National Resources Defense Council.
Data Centers | Nov 22, 2023
How is artificial intelligence impacting data center design?
As AI is reshaping how we interact with machines and the world around us, the design of data centers needs to adapt to this fast-changing landscape. So, Page pairs expert thinking with high-performing solutions to meet the needs of rapidly advancing technologies.
Cultural Facilities | Nov 21, 2023
Arizona’s Water Education Center will teach visitors about water conservation and reuse strategies
Phoenix-based architecture firm Jones Studio will design the Water Education Center for Central Arizona Project (CAP)—a 336-mile aqueduct system that delivers Colorado River water to almost 6 million people, more than 80% of the state’s population. The Center will allow the public to explore CAP’s history, operations, and impact on Arizona.
MFPRO+ New Projects | Nov 21, 2023
An 'eco-obsessed' multifamily housing project takes advantage of downtown Austin’s small lots
In downtown Austin, Tex., architecture firm McKinney York says it built Capitol Quarters to be “eco-obsessed, not just eco-minded.” With airtight walls, better insulation, and super-efficient VRF (variable refrigerant flow) systems, Capitol Quarters uses 30% less energy than other living spaces in Austin, according to a statement from McKinney York.
MFPRO+ News | Nov 21, 2023
California building electrification laws could prompt more evictions and rent increases
California laws requiring apartment owners to ditch appliances that use fossil fuels could prompt more evictions and rent increases in the state, according to a report from the nonprofit Strategic Actions for a Just Economy. The law could spur more evictions if landlords undertake major renovations to comply with the electrification rule.
Codes and Standards | Nov 21, 2023
Austin becomes largest U.S. city to waive minimum parking requirements
Austin, Texas recently became the largest city in the United States to stop requiring new developments to set a minimum amount of parking. The Austin City Council voted 8-2 earlier this month to eliminate parking requirements in an effort to fight climate change and spur more housing construction as Texas’s capitol grapples with a housing affordability crisis.
MFPRO+ News | Nov 21, 2023
Underused strip malls offer great potential for conversions to residential use
Replacing moribund strip malls with multifamily housing could make a notable dent in the housing shortage and revitalize under-used properties across the country, according to a report from housing nonprofit Enterprise Community Partners.
Giants 400 | Nov 16, 2023
Top 100 Science + Technology Facility Architecture Firms for 2023
Gensler, HDR, Page Southerland Page, Flad Architects, and DGA top BD+C's ranking of the nation's largest science and technology (S+T) facility architecture and architecture/engineering (AE) firms for 2023, as reported in Building Design+Construction's 2023 Giants 400 Report. Note: This ranking factors revenue from all science and technology (S+T) buildings work, including laboratories, research buildings, technology/innovation buildings, pharmaceutical production facilities, and semiconductor production facilities.
Resiliency | Nov 16, 2023
How inclusive design supports resilience and climate preparedness
Gail Napell, AIA, LEED AP BD+C, shares five tips and examples of inclusive design across a variety of building sectors.