More than two decades into the building information modeling movement, AEC firms are still discovering ways to utilize BIM/VDC tools more effectively. One major current area of focus is how to cut waste in the BIM implementation process.
Inefficient virtual coordination meetings, cumbersome BIM files, and a ârush to modelâ mentality are just some of the profit-eating miscues that are commonplace in the AEC industry. Â Â
We reached out to several BIM/VDC power users for their top tips for eliminating waste in BIM/VDC workflows. Hereâs what they said:
1. Recognize the importance of âtribal knowledgeâÂ
Many large, corporate AEC firms operate their BIM-driven projects like a manufacturing production line, with staff assigned to specific rolesâdesign specialists, production experts, and construction administration specialists, all of whom move from project to project as they finish their piece of the BIM puzzle. Â Â
While efficient in theory, this Henry Fordish workflow model ultimately leads to waste and added costs, says Thom Chuparkoff, AIA, LEED AP, Associate with Populous. The problem, he says, lies in the turnover of staff during the transitions from design to documentation. At each transition, as certain staff members exit the project and others enter, the design team loses a bit of its âtribal knowledgeââits sense of knowing where a project came from and where itâs going, says Chuparkoff. Consistency of the team throughout the design and documentation phases is absolutely critical, he adds.Â
Â
By employing basic process-mapping techniques at the outset of projects, Building Teams can reduce the amount of BIM modeling required on a project and develop models that offer increased value for the team and the client, says John Haymaker, PhD, AIA, LEED AP, Director of Research with Perkins+Will. Illustration: John Haymaker, Georgia Institute of Technology
Â
âItâs troublesome to have, say, five people on the production team, none of whom had anything to do with the design,â says Chuparkoff. âTheyâre scratching their heads wondering why something was done the way it was. With construction schedules getting shorter, design teams donât have time to go back and try to figure out what another team member was thinking.â
2. Master the art of the BIM coordination meetingÂ
BIM/VDC tools are great, but if you canât run efficient, productive coordination meetings, the Building Team will never realize the benefits of true BIM coordination. Gensler Project Architect and BIM/VDC expert Jared Krieger, AIA, LEED AP, recommends the following tips for making the most of virtual coordination meetings:
Practice and prepare. It takes skill to be able to navigate the project model and have the correct model views loaded and visibility settings adjusted for a meeting. Make the most of everyoneâs time by allocating at least 15 minutes prior to each coordination meeting for one team member to load the model and specific views.
Assign a âdesignated driver,â someone who knows the model and is savvy about the software platform. Models can be cumbersome to navigate. Suffering through an inexperienced person trying desperately to steer the model will absolutely kill the momentum and productivity of the meeting.
âWe often bypass conceptual 3D modeling software by encouraging the use of other mediums, such as clay and digital sketch models.â
âThom Chuparkoff, AIA, LEED AP
Consider splitting meetings. Keep meetings focused on small components of the project, and include only the team members directly involved. Consider splitting meetings by profession. For example, meet with the structural engineer first to review structural-specific coordination. Then, have some overlap time with MEP and structural for common coordination. Finish the meeting with MEP coordination.
Use meeting notes to stay focused. Open action items and homework from the previous meeting should be the basis for discussion in your next meeting. Use this structure to keep your team on track, and resolve open coordination issues before moving on to new items.
Â
3. Avoid double modeling whenever you canÂ
Even with all the high-tech design and sketching tools available to designers, Chuparkoff advocates for a pen-and-paper approach to working with clients on early design concepts. He argues that firms allocate too much of their precious resources to creating overly complex 3D conceptual models, which then have to be painstakingly re-created in a BIM environment.Â
âAt some firms, people will spend 40 hours or more building three different project models in SketchUp,â he says. âYou donât need three fully baked ideas, fully modeled, to present to the client. You need five or six good ideas, and not necessarily modeled. We often bypass conceptual 3D modeling software by encouraging the use of other mediums, such as clay and digital sketch models, early on to develop and refine ideas to the point where they can be modeled in BIM for the client one time. Before you get into the hard-line modeling, try to vet as much as you can the good old-fashioned way.â
Â
4. Map your processesÂ
AEC professionals have been trained to jump right in and start building the model. But this ârush to modelâ mentality often leads to inefficiencies, waste, and less-than-ideal models, says John Haymaker, PhD, AIA, LEED AP, Director of Research with Perkins+Will.Â
Haymaker, Assistant Professor of Architecture and Building Construction at Georgia Tech, recommends the use of process-mapping techniquesâincluding value stream mapping and business process modelingâat the project outset to identify the decisions that need to be made during the design process, as well as the processes required to make those decisions. When done well, process mapping can help reduce the amount of BIM modeling required on a project and also lead to models that offer increased value for the team and the client, says Haymaker.
âFor example, if an architect, mechanical engineer, and contractor can get together to map out their process for performing preliminary energy and cost analysis, the architect may realize that they only need to model spaces and exterior surfaces,â says Haymaker. âThis would greatly simplify their modeling effort, and potentially eliminate useless or inaccurate data.â
Â
5. Divvy up the model to avoid unwieldy file sizesÂ
Four years into the Tysons Tower project in Tysons Corner, Va., Genslerâs Krieger has just one minor regret: not managing the size of the BIM file more effectively. âOur model is pretty big, and even with great computers, it can become a bit of a bear at times when all the pieces are loaded in,â he says.Â
Working with a central BIM model has its benefitsânotably, having a single repository for all project information. But on large, complex projects, BIM files can become ponderous, resulting in longer load times during virtual coordination meetings. Â Â
Splitting the model into chunks is one approach to managing the file size. âWe try to think of logical pieces to keep as separate models,â says Krieger. âFor example, if you have a tall building with a podium, you can keep the tower and podium as separate models and reference them into each other as needed. Or, on a building project with a complicated skin, you can keep the curtain wall as a separate model. The earlier you plan the split the better.â
Krieger also advises Building Teams to take note of the file size of BIM object families used on projects. Complicated projects can incorporate more than a thousand families, and some sets can exceed 10 megabytes in size. âWe are very careful about how complicated and large the families can get,â he says.Â
Â
6. Make sure someone âownsâ your companywide BIM/VDC standardÂ
Given the rapid pace of change and innovation in the BIM/VDC software industry, it is imperative that AEC firms designate an in-house power user to maintain and update the company BIM/VDC standard.Â
âThese tools are constantly evolving, and the company standard needs to evolve with them,â says Adam Lasota, Junior Architect with Rietveld Architects, New York. âNewer functions and features can make company standards obsolete, so itâs a matter of productivity.â
Â
7. Create a simple BIM execution planâand stick to it
Setting expectations and staying organized can be addressed through a simple, straightforward BIM execution plan that covers everything from schedule and roles to model sharing and level of development.Â
âItâs absolutely worth the effort,â says Genslerâs Krieger, referring to the firmâs work setting up an execution plan for Tysons Tower. âAll the time we spent setting up views, sheet templates, and detail organization in the beginning is paying off in the construction administration process.â
When in the thick of a large, multi-year project, itâs easy for a team to stray from the original BIM execution plan. Fight that urge, because doing so can save thousands, perhaps millions, of dollars in avoided costs during construction. Â
âThe biggest payoff has come from our teamâs early commitment to have weekly BIM coordination sessions throughout the design process,â says Krieger. âIt has resulted in a low number of RFIs and very few significant field coordination issues.â
Related Stories
Architects | Jun 14, 2019
Making public facilities more public
Municipal facilities must strike a delicate balance between openness and security.
Architects | Jun 4, 2019
Big design, small budget: These are the best small projects for 2019
Bjarke Ingels Group's prototype mountainside cabin and Fieldwork's forest pedestrian bridges are among 12 projects honored by AIA's Small Project Practitioners group.
Architects | Apr 26, 2019
Designing for the final frontier: Space architecture
Colonizing Mars is an exciting possibility in the not-too-distant future, and architects will play a vital role in making it a reality, despite the plethora of challenges that need to be overcome.
Architects | Apr 12, 2019
Bipartisan 'Invest in America Act' gains industry support
The bill would attract as much as $125 billion investment for buildings, infrastructure.
Office Buildings | Apr 8, 2019
Itâs time for office amenities to get to work
Amenities with the greatest impact on effectiveness and experience are those that directly support the work needs of individual employees and their teams.Â
Industry Research | Apr 8, 2019
New research finds benefits to hiring architectural services based on qualifications
Government agencies gain by evaluating beyond price, according to a new Dodge survey of government officials.Â
Architects | Mar 17, 2019
HMC Architects sets up a âdesign labâ to explore new ideas
The goal is for project team members to collaborate earlier to inspire innovation.
Architects | Mar 12, 2019
Thrown a curve: Fitting a restaurant into spherical dome was the design challenge for Willmottâs Ghost
The Seattle eatery nests inside the conservatories on Amazonâs massive campus.
Building Technology | Mar 8, 2019
What is your firm's innovation 'hit rate'?
As firms begin to adopt the practices and mindset of Silicon Valley tech and advanced manufacturing, itâs fair to ask: Are all of these innovation projects and initiatives working?