Editor's note: This article was originally published as part of BD+C's two-part March 2014 Healthcare Facilities Report. Read the first installment of the report, "How your firm can win more healthcare projects."
Â
Â
For BD+C's March 2014 Healthcare Facilities Report, we interviewed seven healthcare planning and design experts from major healthcare organizations, including Sutter Health, Ascension Health, and CHE Trinity Health. They cited the following factors that Building Teams need to keep in mind on their healthcare projects:
1. CONSOLIDATION OF HEALTHCARE FACILITIES
A large organization like Ascension can find savings through an examination of its national property portfolio. âWe have to look at each region,â says Ascension SVP Bob McCoole. âDoes it have 10 half-full physicianâs offices? We have to look at all opportunities to consolidate and manage space more efficiently.â
In some cases, the result of facilities consolidation isnât to reduce the overall system footprint, but to expand it. MaineGeneral replaced two existing hospitals, totaling about 400,000 sf, with the new 640,000 sf Alfond Center for Health. The new institution holds 192 inpatient beds, a reduction from the 225 beds that the two old hospitals held. Much of Alfondâs non-inpatient space is taken up by outpatient services, and the entire Thayer facility (one of the two old hospitals) is being converted to outpatient services. So, this consolidation of inpatient capacity enabled a big jump in outpatient service capacity.
Â
2. EFFICIENCY AND STANDARDIZATION
Much of a healthcare property executiveâs time is spent on finding better, more efficient designs and rolling them out systemwide in the form of standards. In recent years, CHE Trinity had been focused on standards such as cost-per-bed based on market norms. âWeâre moving toward developing norms for department and key room sizes that are based on group wisdom, with input from outside firms as well as in-house personnel,â says CHE Trinity Healthâs Young.Â
In some cases, a small, dedicated staff of passionate hospital staffers has led the push for new standards to improve efficiency. Froedtert staff has gone through a concerted effort to analyze process flow using mapping and simulation tools. These exercises are essential to guide design, says Balzer. âYou want visioning and modeling to inform design, rather than have them happen simultaneously,â he says. âIf you bring in architects too early in the process, you will have a hard time stopping them from sketching drawings before you are finished gathering input.â
Sutter is a leader among major healthcare systems in adopting Lean design principles for construction and clinical practices. This had led to an innovative use of technology, with several sites using or testing kiosk patient registration. âThey are similar to what you see at airports,â says Sutter Healthâs Conwell. âYou swipe your Sutter card or a credit card and the monitor tells you to go to a particular exam room.â This reduces waiting times for patientsâa metric many healthcare systems are trying to improve.
Â
Reception desk at the 640,000-sf MaineGeneral Medical Center, which consolidated two campuses that were 20 miles apart. Facilities include a 16-room interventional suite, a 27-bed ED, a 25-room imaging center, a cardiac gym, a conference center, and a two-story medical office building. Photo: © Anton Grassl/Esto
Â
3. SPACE FLEXIBILITY
Facing formidable unknowns associated with implementing the Affordable Care Act, hospital designers have to bake in flexibility. Reducing walls and barriers so clinical areas can easily be reconfigured is a common tacticâa particularly important one as medical professionals learn to work more collaboratively. âWe donât want to do anything that precludes people from working together,â says Sutter Healthâs Scheuerman. Sutter has also made exam rooms specialty-agnostic by providing mobile equipment carts that make any exam room capable of serving multiple specialties.
Spaces that can pull double duty can be valuable. One recent CHE Trinity project included six flex rooms on inpatient floors, to be used initially as rehab space. Should demand require it, these rooms can be easily converted to inpatient use.
Infrastructure planning is another area where providing flexibility is paramount. âWe donât want infrastructure to become dated, but we also donât want to burden our locations with investments they donât need,â says Froedtertâs Balzer. âIf we think we might need an MRI at a location in a few years, we might upsize the electrical feeder into the building now, which can be done at relatively low cost, and up the distribution, if necessary, later.â
Â
4. IMPROVING PATIENT OUTCOMES
With the ACA pushing hospitals hard to produce better patient outcomes, using both a carrot (financial incentives) and a stick (penalties), healthcare Building Teams need to be actively involved in research initiatives that could reduce infections, speed recovery periods, and improve medical staff performance.Â
Froedtert was one of the first participants in the Center for Health Designâs Pebble Project (www.healthdesign.org/pebble), an effort to compile and distribute research related to quality of care and building design. âFor anything we design, we refer to the Pebble database and see what research is out there,â says Balzer.
MaineGeneralâs Alfond project was designed with evidence-based research in mind. When considering the use of generous fenestration, for instance, research on the benefits of daylight was factored in. âIf it improves staff satisfaction and patient recovery, plentiful daylighting can be worth the extra expense,â says Stein. MaineGeneral also installed a pneumatic tube system to transport lab specimens to the central lab, instead of having staff wheel the samples around on carts. The reduced turnaround on test results has improved quality of care along with staff efficiency.
Â
CHE Trinity Healthâs 237,000-sf Holy Cross Germantown Hospital will provide medical/surgical, obstetrics, and psychiatric services on the campus of Montgomery College when completed later this year. The facility, the first new hospital in Montgomery County, Md., in more than 30 years, will include 98 patient rooms, five ORs, 14 emergency beds, five labor rooms, an eight-bassinet neonatal unit, and an on-site medical office facility. Building Team: SmithGroupJJR (architect, medical planner, programming, interiors, lighting, landscape architecture), Leach Wallace/Syska Hennessy (MEP), McMullan & Associates (SE), CBRE (ownerâs rep), and Whiting-Turner (CM). KLMK (now CBRE Health) served as ownerâs project manager. Photo: courtesy SmithGroupJJR and CHE Trinity Health
Â
5. COST-CUTTING AND IMPROVED EFFICIENCY BY DESIGN
Hospital systems are breaking the design mold to cut costs. In the past, every major medical discipline had its own reception area. No more. Now, as many as four different disciplines may share a single reception space.
Healthcare providers are also struggling with how elaborately appointed their facilities have to be to attract patients. Finding the right balance between spending enough on attractive furnishings and finishes to be competitive, versus overspending on ornamentation, is a constant dilemma.
If Ascensionâs McCoole had his way, the whole industry would take a pill and slow down a bit on accoutrements. He points to the use of precast concrete in the construction of the recently completed St. Vincentâs HealthCare facility in Jacksonville, Fla. No fancy twisted elevations here: the buildingâs corners were kept at an economical 90 degrees. âIt wonât win any design awards,â says McCoole. âWe included nice lobbies with terrazzo floors, but thatâs the extent of the ornamentation.âÂ
CHE Trinityâs new strategy of employing commissioning agents early in the design process is already a proven money-saver, says Young. Commissioning experts found that plans for the central plant of a new hospital had improperly routed the piping. A redesign yielded a much smaller central plant. and the energy savings will total millions of dollars over the lifespan of the facility, Young says.
Life cycle analysis to evaluate sustainable elements in hospital projects is a calculus that is constantly in flux. For example, Froedtert recently mandated LED lighting as the standard on new construction and major renovations as LED prices continue to drop.
Â
6. BIM, IPD, AND PREFABRICATION
Healthcare organizations increasingly demand some flavor of integrated project deliveryâformal or otherwiseâon major projects. âWeâre using it in spirit, but not in contracts,â says Balzer. All of our experts told us that collaboration among Building Team member firms is a must.Â
The major Building Team players should also be BIM-savvy. Healthcare organizations are increasingly looking to use BIM throughout a buildingâs life cycle. âOur maintenance staff is instrumental in driving our standards and how we leverage BIM,â says Froedtertâs Balzer.
Prefabrication of parts and units is also becoming a more frequently used tool. CHE Trinity uses off-site prefab for above-ceiling utilities, and sometimes on bathrooms. The central plant on a new 80-bed hospital currently under design will be prefabricatedâa first for CHE Trinity, says Young.Â
âPrefab is near and dear to my heart,â says Froedtertâs Balzer. âWeâre looking at the feasibility of offsite construction of exam rooms for a Advanced Care Center. Five years from now, we expect to be using prefab more heavily."
Read the first installment of BD+C's March 2014 Healthcare Facilities Report, "How your firm can win more healthcare projects."
Related Stories
Healthcare Facilities | Dec 15, 2021
MEP design considerations for rural hospitals
Rural hospitals present unique opportunities and challenges for healthcare facility operators. Oftentimes, the infrastructure and building systems have not been updated for years and require significant improvements in order to meet todayâs modern medical demands. Additionally, as these smaller, more remote hospitals are acquired by larger regional and national healthcare systems, the first step by new ownership is often to update and rehabilitate the building. But how can this be done thoughtfully, economically, and efficiently in ways that allow the engineering and facility staff to adapt to the changes? And how can the updates accurately reflect the specific needs of rural communities and the afflictions with which these areas most commonly face?
Architects | Dec 13, 2021
Dan Hart, FAIA, inaugurated AIA 2022 President
Dan Hart will be the AIA's 98th President.
Architects | Dec 13, 2021
MASS Design Group receives 2022 AIA Architecture Firm Award
The annual AIA Architecture Firm Award is the highest honor the AIA bestows on an architecture practice.
Architects | Dec 13, 2021
2022 AIA Gold Medal awarded to Angela Brooks and Lawrence Scarpa
The Gold Medal honors an individual or pair whose significant body of work has had a lasting influence on the theory and practice of architecture.
K-12 Schools | Dec 10, 2021
Trends in K-12 school design, with Dan Boggio and Melissa Turnbaugh of PBK
Dan Boggio and Melissa Turnbaugh of PBK, the largest K-12 design firm in the U.S.,  discuss the favorable market conditions and the latest trends in K-12 school design with BD+C's Rob Cassidy.  Â
Architects | Dec 9, 2021
Hoffmann Architects wins Connecticut American Institute of Architects Justice, Equity, Diversity & Inclusion Award
The AIA Connecticut J.E.D.I. Challenge, launched in November 2020, offers member firms the opportunity to commit to actions in each of the Challenge areas.
Giants 400 | Dec 5, 2021
2021 Justice Facility Sector Giants: Top architecture, engineering, and construction firms in the U.S. justice facility/public safety sector
Turner Construction, DLR Group, AECOM, and Stantec top BD+C's rankings of the nation's largest architecture, engineering, and construction firms for justice facility/public safety buildings work, including correctional facilities, fire stations, jails, police stations, and prisons, as reported in the 2021 Giants 400 Report.
Giants 400 | Dec 3, 2021
2021 Hotel Sector Giants: Top architecture, engineering, and construction firms in the U.S. hospitality sector
Gensler, Jacobs, Suffolk Construction, and WATG top BD+C's rankings of the nation's largest hotel sector architecture, engineering, and construction firms, as reported in the 2021 Giants 400 Report.
Architects | Nov 29, 2021
LRK Names Tony Pellicciotti âManaging Principalâ of firm
Pellicciotti is one of LRKâs fourteen principals representing its markets in Memphis, Dallas, Philadelphia, Orlando/Celebration, New Orleans, Baton Rouge, Little Rock, and Princeton.
Architects | Nov 23, 2021
HMC names new Director of Design
James Krueger will oversee design and lead strategies to improve the impact of HMCâs work.