Building owners and Building Teams seeking sustainable, aesthetically pleasing roofing solutions are turning to metal for its favorable life cycle benefits, longevity, and resistance to wind uplift, fire, and physical impact.
While metal is typically specified for new construction, it has significant potential for growth in retrofits. “Metal adds insulation, a ventilated cavity, and a reflective coating that makes the [old] roof several hundred percent more energy efficient,” says Chuck Howard, PE, of Metal Roof Consultants, Cary, N.C. “And the roof panels can last well over 60 years.”
Moreover, the installation cost of a metal roof is estimated to be comparable to tearing off and replacing the existing flat roof, says Ken Buchinger, vice president of R&D and business development for Houston-based manufacturer MBCI.
Metal roofing is unquestionably more design-friendly than it was 25 years ago. While steel remains the dominant material, metal roofing can also be fabricated from aluminum, copper, and zinc. Building Teams can dress it up with such features as dormers, Dutch hips, and offset ridges with clerestories. Many panel profiles and paint colors are available, as well as finishes that emulate copper, aluminum, stone, brick, and glass.
Thanks to more advanced manufacturing equipment, metal can be curved, tapered, and perforated in a variety of ways, says Dave Brown, director of new product development for Euramax International’s North American Commercial Division, Lancaster, Pa. Euramax is the parent company of Fabral Metal Roof and Wall Systems.
Brown urges designers to review drawings and specifications with the roofing manufacturer early on in the process. According to architect Mickey Conrad, AIA, “Metal roofs are great, but you can design yourself into a flashing and waterproofing jam if you’re not careful about how different roof forms intersect.”
Six things you should know about using metal roofing
1. If the roof geometry of your project is complicated, request a weather-tightness warranty from the manufacturer. Such warranties call for multiple roof inspections throughout the installation process.
2. Metal roofing is an especially good substrate for solar installations because it requires no roof penetrations. With proper maintenance, the roof should outlast the solar array.
3. Insulated metal roof panels eliminate the need for highly skilled labor on site and can be installed quickly.
4. In retrofits, if a metal roof is installed over the existing roof, the new framing will create a ventilated cavity that can be insulated to reduce the building’s energy consumption.
5. Architects can get the maximum creativity out of their roof design by working with the manufacturer in the early stages of a project.
6. Consult with the manufacturer for a recommendation on the right installer for the job.
Conrad, principal-in-charge of OCO Architects, San Antonio, Texas, prefers vertical standing-seam metal roofs with concealed fasteners: “They’re going to give our clients the best performance over many years.”
Insulated metal roof panels could become more widespread as Building Teams strive for LEED points. Doug Pickens, vice president of marketing for IMP roofing manufacturer Metl-Span, Lewisville, Texas, says the volume of IMPs sold in the U.S. and Canada has doubled in the last three years, even though IMP systems cost twice as much as single-ply or standing-seam metal roofing.
Because they have insulating foam sandwiched between two layers of metal, he says, IMPs provide an air and vapor barrier with no thermal bridging. “The insulation is continuous across the entire roof,” says Pickens. “The panels go down incredibly fast. A contractor who has a little bit of experience can put down as much as 10,000 sf a day with a five-man crew and a crane.”
Let’s take a look at how metal systems have been used in three different kinds of applications.
1. METAL ROOF MAKES A SPLASH
The new water park at Hope Lake Lodge in Virgil, N.Y., has transformed the resort into a year-round destination. By installing a metal roof, the owners of the water park have been able to maintain its interior temperature at 80-84°F, even during the coldest months.
VIP Structures, Syracuse, N.Y., erected the building and installed 60,000 sf of Metl-Span insulated roof and wall panels. The steep roof, with its 100-foot-long skylight at the ridge line, was something of a challenge, but the crew successfully managed the hips, valleys, and trim, according to Leonard Pogroski, project manager for VIP Structures.
The LEED Silver project was designed by RBA Group, Charlotte, N.C. “By using a steel superstructure with insulated panels, we were able to create the large clear spans necessary for housing the water-park features and provide high thermal efficiency,” says architect Steven E. Finch, LEED AP, Assoc. AIA, RBA’s director of hospitality. IMPs were also chosen because they permitted multiple punched openings where the waterslide chutes exit and reenter the building, according to Finch.
2. RETROFIT HELPS DRY OUT SCHOOL ROOF
During its 42 years of service, the BUR roof of Winchester High School in Richmond, Ind., had been patched numerous times, but continued to leak. Students and teachers regularly complained about the wet, humid environment and unpleasant odor.
The school board considered a flat-roof retrofit, but parents and students protested so vehemently that the board called in Metal Roof Consultants. MRC proposed installing a sloped metal roof over the existing flat roof. This meant that there would be no interruption of school activities.
Six inches of unfaced fiberglass insulation were installed directly over the existing roof, raising insulating value from R-3.5 to R-22.5. The existing roof was able to release its moisture through the insulation into the new roof cavity, where it was expelled through side vents. “The classroom wing was the wettest, so we worked on that first,” says MRC’s Howard. “It dried out in less than a year.”
Energy Star paint additives create a cool roof that reflects approximately 80% of the solar heat back into the atmosphere. Howard says the roof system is warranted against leaking for 20 years but should provide 50-60 years of service, with no maintenance other than periodic checks for external damage.
Smarrelli General Contractor, Richmond, Ind., used MBCI’s NuRoof system, in which light-gauge steel framing is installed over existing framing members to create a sloped plane. BattenLok HS standing-seam panels were installed over the framing. Steve Shute, Smarrelli’s general manager, says the manufacturer made the project, even with its high load conditions and roof curbs, “work very well.” Most important, there haven’t been any leaks.
3. ROOFTOP SOLAR ADDS TO SUSTAINABILITY
When the city of Allegan, Mich., had to upgrade its water-treatment plant, it rejected a costly retrofit and decided instead to build a new reverse-osmosis facility. The $10 million project, funded by federal grants and a low-interest loan from the state, includes a half-million-gallon ground storage tank, an on-site mixed-oxidant generation system, and a rooftop solar system.
Architect/engineer Prein & Newhof, Grand Rapids, Mich., specified Fabral’s Solar SSR, which integrates flexible thin-film solar laminates with a standing-seam metal roof. Once the wood-truss framing and sheathing were in place, Erhardt Construction, Ada, Mich., installed the roof and solar array, which generates 29.38 kW of electricity.
Dave Brown of Euramax, Fabral’s parent company, says thin-film laminates are lightweight and flexible and achieve high relative efficiency under high temperatures and low light. “No roof penetrations or additional structural support are needed, and you can walk on the laminates,” says Brown. He says the panel/laminate bond has been proven to withstand 160 mph winds. +
Related Stories
| Jan 19, 2011
Industrial history museum gets new home in steel plant
The National Museum of Industrial History recently renovated the exterior of a 1913 steel plant in Bethlehem, Pa., to house its new 40,000-sf exhibition space. The museum chose VOA Associates, which is headquartered in Chicago, to complete the design for the exhibit’s interior. The exhibit, which has views of five historic blast furnaces, will feature artifacts from the Smithsonian Institution to illustrate early industrial America.
| Jan 19, 2011
Baltimore mixed-use development combines working, living, and shopping
The Shoppes at McHenry Row, a $117 million mixed-use complex developed by 28 Walker Associates for downtown Baltimore, will include 65,000 sf of office space, 250 apartments, and two parking garages. The 48,000 sf of main street retail space currently is 65% occupied, with space for small shops and a restaurant remaining.
| Jan 19, 2011
Biomedical research center in Texas to foster scientific collaboration
The new Health and Biomedical Sciences Center at the University of Houston will facilitate interaction between scientists in a 167,000-sf, six-story research facility. The center will bring together researchers from many of the school’s departments to collaborate on interdisciplinary projects. The facility also will feature an ambulatory surgery center for the College of Optometry, the first of its kind for an optometry school. Boston-based firms Shepley Bulfinch and Bailey Architects designed the project.
| Jan 19, 2011
San Diego casino renovations upgrade gaming and entertainment
The Sycuan Casino in San Diego will get an update with a $27 million, 245,000-sf renovation. Hnedak Bobo Group, Memphis, Tenn., and Cleo Design, Las Vegas, drew design inspiration from the historic culture of the Sycuan tribe and the desert landscape, creating a more open space with better circulation. Renovation highlights include a new “waterless” water entry feature and new sports bar and grill, plus updates to gaming, poker, off-track-betting, retail, and bingo areas. The local office of San Francisco-based Swinerton Builders will provide construction services.
| Jan 19, 2011
Extended stay hotel aims to provide comfort of home
Housing development company Campus Apartments broke ground on a new extended stay hotel that will serve the medical and academic facilities in Philadelphia’s University City, including the University of Pennsylvania and the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. The 11,000-sf hotel will operate under Hilton’s Homewood Suites brand, with 136 suites with full kitchens and dining and work areas. A part of the city’s EnergyWorks loan program, the project aims for LEED with a green roof, low-flow fixtures, and onsite stormwater management. Local firms Alesker & Dundon Architects and GC L.F. Driscoll Co. complete the Building Team.
| Jan 19, 2011
New Fort Hood hospital will replace aging medical center
The Army Corps of Engineers selected London-based Balfour Beatty and St. Louis-based McCarthy to provide design-build services for the Fort Hood Replacement Hospital in Texas, a $503 million, 944,000-sf complex partially funded by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. The firm plans to use BIM for the project, which will include outpatient clinics, an ambulance garage, a central utility plant, and three parking structures. Texas firms HKS Architects and Wingler & Sharp will participate as design partners. The project seeks LEED Gold.
| Jan 19, 2011
Museum design integrates Greek history and architecture
Construction is under way in Chicago on the National Hellenic Museum, the nation’s first museum devoted to Greek history and culture. RTKL designed the 40,000-sf limestone and glass building to include such historic references as the covered walkway of classical architecture and the natural wood accents of Byzantine monasteries. The museum will include a research library and oral history center, plus a 3,600-sf rooftop terrace featuring three gardens. The project seeks LEED Silver.
| Jan 19, 2011
Architecture Billings Index jumped more than 2 points in December
On the heels of its highest mark since 2007, the Architecture Billings Index jumped more than two points in December. The American Institute of Architects reported the December ABI score was 54.2, up from a reading of 52.0 the previous month.
| Jan 19, 2011
Large-Scale Concrete Reconstruction Solid Thinking
Driven by both current economic conditions and sustainable building trends, Building Teams are looking more and more to retrofits and reconstruction as the most viable alternative to new construction. In that context, large-scale concrete restoration projects are playing an important role within this growing specialty.
