Building owners and Building Teams seeking sustainable, aesthetically pleasing roofing solutions are turning to metal for its favorable life cycle benefits, longevity, and resistance to wind uplift, fire, and physical impact.
While metal is typically specified for new construction, it has significant potential for growth in retrofits. “Metal adds insulation, a ventilated cavity, and a reflective coating that makes the [old] roof several hundred percent more energy efficient,” says Chuck Howard, PE, of Metal Roof Consultants, Cary, N.C. “And the roof panels can last well over 60 years.”
Moreover, the installation cost of a metal roof is estimated to be comparable to tearing off and replacing the existing flat roof, says Ken Buchinger, vice president of R&D and business development for Houston-based manufacturer MBCI.
Metal roofing is unquestionably more design-friendly than it was 25 years ago. While steel remains the dominant material, metal roofing can also be fabricated from aluminum, copper, and zinc. Building Teams can dress it up with such features as dormers, Dutch hips, and offset ridges with clerestories. Many panel profiles and paint colors are available, as well as finishes that emulate copper, aluminum, stone, brick, and glass.
Thanks to more advanced manufacturing equipment, metal can be curved, tapered, and perforated in a variety of ways, says Dave Brown, director of new product development for Euramax International’s North American Commercial Division, Lancaster, Pa. Euramax is the parent company of Fabral Metal Roof and Wall Systems.
Brown urges designers to review drawings and specifications with the roofing manufacturer early on in the process. According to architect Mickey Conrad, AIA, “Metal roofs are great, but you can design yourself into a flashing and waterproofing jam if you’re not careful about how different roof forms intersect.”
Six things you should know about using metal roofing
1. If the roof geometry of your project is complicated, request a weather-tightness warranty from the manufacturer. Such warranties call for multiple roof inspections throughout the installation process.
2. Metal roofing is an especially good substrate for solar installations because it requires no roof penetrations. With proper maintenance, the roof should outlast the solar array.
3. Insulated metal roof panels eliminate the need for highly skilled labor on site and can be installed quickly.
4. In retrofits, if a metal roof is installed over the existing roof, the new framing will create a ventilated cavity that can be insulated to reduce the building’s energy consumption.
5. Architects can get the maximum creativity out of their roof design by working with the manufacturer in the early stages of a project.
6. Consult with the manufacturer for a recommendation on the right installer for the job.
Conrad, principal-in-charge of OCO Architects, San Antonio, Texas, prefers vertical standing-seam metal roofs with concealed fasteners: “They’re going to give our clients the best performance over many years.”
Insulated metal roof panels could become more widespread as Building Teams strive for LEED points. Doug Pickens, vice president of marketing for IMP roofing manufacturer Metl-Span, Lewisville, Texas, says the volume of IMPs sold in the U.S. and Canada has doubled in the last three years, even though IMP systems cost twice as much as single-ply or standing-seam metal roofing.
Because they have insulating foam sandwiched between two layers of metal, he says, IMPs provide an air and vapor barrier with no thermal bridging. “The insulation is continuous across the entire roof,” says Pickens. “The panels go down incredibly fast. A contractor who has a little bit of experience can put down as much as 10,000 sf a day with a five-man crew and a crane.”
Let’s take a look at how metal systems have been used in three different kinds of applications.
1. METAL ROOF MAKES A SPLASH
The new water park at Hope Lake Lodge in Virgil, N.Y., has transformed the resort into a year-round destination. By installing a metal roof, the owners of the water park have been able to maintain its interior temperature at 80-84°F, even during the coldest months.
VIP Structures, Syracuse, N.Y., erected the building and installed 60,000 sf of Metl-Span insulated roof and wall panels. The steep roof, with its 100-foot-long skylight at the ridge line, was something of a challenge, but the crew successfully managed the hips, valleys, and trim, according to Leonard Pogroski, project manager for VIP Structures.
The LEED Silver project was designed by RBA Group, Charlotte, N.C. “By using a steel superstructure with insulated panels, we were able to create the large clear spans necessary for housing the water-park features and provide high thermal efficiency,” says architect Steven E. Finch, LEED AP, Assoc. AIA, RBA’s director of hospitality. IMPs were also chosen because they permitted multiple punched openings where the waterslide chutes exit and reenter the building, according to Finch.
2. RETROFIT HELPS DRY OUT SCHOOL ROOF
During its 42 years of service, the BUR roof of Winchester High School in Richmond, Ind., had been patched numerous times, but continued to leak. Students and teachers regularly complained about the wet, humid environment and unpleasant odor.
The school board considered a flat-roof retrofit, but parents and students protested so vehemently that the board called in Metal Roof Consultants. MRC proposed installing a sloped metal roof over the existing flat roof. This meant that there would be no interruption of school activities.
Six inches of unfaced fiberglass insulation were installed directly over the existing roof, raising insulating value from R-3.5 to R-22.5. The existing roof was able to release its moisture through the insulation into the new roof cavity, where it was expelled through side vents. “The classroom wing was the wettest, so we worked on that first,” says MRC’s Howard. “It dried out in less than a year.”
Energy Star paint additives create a cool roof that reflects approximately 80% of the solar heat back into the atmosphere. Howard says the roof system is warranted against leaking for 20 years but should provide 50-60 years of service, with no maintenance other than periodic checks for external damage.
Smarrelli General Contractor, Richmond, Ind., used MBCI’s NuRoof system, in which light-gauge steel framing is installed over existing framing members to create a sloped plane. BattenLok HS standing-seam panels were installed over the framing. Steve Shute, Smarrelli’s general manager, says the manufacturer made the project, even with its high load conditions and roof curbs, “work very well.” Most important, there haven’t been any leaks.
3. ROOFTOP SOLAR ADDS TO SUSTAINABILITY
When the city of Allegan, Mich., had to upgrade its water-treatment plant, it rejected a costly retrofit and decided instead to build a new reverse-osmosis facility. The $10 million project, funded by federal grants and a low-interest loan from the state, includes a half-million-gallon ground storage tank, an on-site mixed-oxidant generation system, and a rooftop solar system.
Architect/engineer Prein & Newhof, Grand Rapids, Mich., specified Fabral’s Solar SSR, which integrates flexible thin-film solar laminates with a standing-seam metal roof. Once the wood-truss framing and sheathing were in place, Erhardt Construction, Ada, Mich., installed the roof and solar array, which generates 29.38 kW of electricity.
Dave Brown of Euramax, Fabral’s parent company, says thin-film laminates are lightweight and flexible and achieve high relative efficiency under high temperatures and low light. “No roof penetrations or additional structural support are needed, and you can walk on the laminates,” says Brown. He says the panel/laminate bond has been proven to withstand 160 mph winds. +
Related Stories
| May 10, 2011
Google hires Ingenhoven Architects to design new Mountain View office
The current Googleplex is straining at the seams and yet the company is preparing its biggest hiring surge ever, so Google decided now’s the time to build its own office space—a first for the Internet giant. The company hired Ingenhoven Architects, a German firm that specializes in sustainable architecture, to create plans for what could be a 600,000-sf office.
| May 10, 2011
Solar installations on multifamily rooftops aid social change
The Los Angeles Business Council's study on the feasibility of installing solar panels on the city’s multifamily buildings shows there's tremendous rooftop capacity, and that a significant portion of that rooftop capacity comes from buildings in economically depressed neighborhoods. Solar installations could therefore be used to create jobs, lower utility costs, and improve conditions for residents in these neighborhood.
| May 10, 2011
Dinner is now served…atop the Lincoln Memorial?
Take a look at the temporary restaurant sitting atop Brussels’ historic Arc de Triomphe-Triomfboog. The Cube, by Electrolux, offers 18 diners a spectacular view of the Parc du Cinquantenair, and is one of two structures traveling across Europe, making stops at famous landmarks in Belgium, Italy, Switzerland, Sweden, and Russia. What do you think about one of these 60-tonne structures being placed on a U.S. memorial?
| May 6, 2011
Ellerbe Becket now operating as AECOM
*/ The architecture, interiors and engineering firm Ellerbe Becket, which joined AECOM in 2009, has fully transitioned to operating as AECOM as of May 2, 2011.
| May 2, 2011
URS acquires Apptis Holdings, a federal IT service provider
SAN FRANCISCO, CA and CHANTILLY, VA– April 28, 2011 – URS Corporation and Apptis Holdings, Inc., a leading provider of information technology and communications services to the federal government, announced that they have signed a definitive agreement under which URS will acquire Apptis.
| May 2, 2011
Perkins+Will merges with Vermeulen Hind Architects, offically launches Perkins+Will Canada
Ottawa and Hamilton-based Vermeulen Hind Architects, one of Canada’s leading healthcare architectural firms, has merged with Perkins+Will. Vermeulen Hind joins Toronto-based Shore Tilbe Perkins+Will and Vancouver-based Busby Perkins+Will to create Perkins+Will Canada. The combination marks the official launch of Perkins+Will Canada, a merge that will establish the firm as among the pre-eminent interdisciplinary design practices in Canada.
| Apr 26, 2011
Ed Mazria on how NYC can achieve carbon neutrality in buildings by 2030
The New York Chapter of the American Institute of Architects invited Mr. Mazria to present a keynote lecture to launch its 2030 training program. In advance of that lecture, Jacob Slevin, co-founder of DesignerPages.com and a contributor to The Huffington Post, interviewed Mazria about creating a sustainable vision for the future and how New York City's architects and designers can rise to the occasion.
| Apr 26, 2011
Video: Are China's ghost cities a bubble waiting to burst?
It's estimated that 10 new cities are being built in China every year, but many are virtually deserted. Retail space remains empty and hundreds of apartments are vacant, but the Chinese government is more concerned with maintaining economic growth—and building cities is one way of achieving that goal.
| Apr 25, 2011
Earn $300 million by NOT hiring Frank Gehry
An Iowa philanthropist and architecture aficionado—who wishes to remain anonymous—is offering a $300 million “reward” to any city anywhere in the world that’s brave enough to hire someone other than Frank Gehry to design its new art museum.
